you think a guy that is hitting 272 in high A is going to put up around a 300 average in MLB? That's wishcasting. Other than his K rate there is nothing in Madrigal's batted ball profile to suggest he'll be a 300 hitter in MLB.
@oldsox is 100% correct right now Yolmer is the better hitter. Yolmer also put up better lines, at a younger age, in the minors. At 22, Yolmer was hitting 293 in AAA with a 293/349/412 line.
There is a strange confirmation bias going on with Madrigal and certain segments of the fanbase. Because he was typecast as a polished college player with a high floor it's almost assumed that's what he'll pan out as. So far, he hasn't panned out into jack shit. If his FV was something like 60 on draft day right now it looks close to 45.
He's got time to turn things around and his next three months in AA are absolutely critical either way. If he can hold his own he looks back on a "solid regular in 2021" path. If he can't hang, he's going to be repeating 2020 in AA at 23, which isn't ideal for a guy drafted where he was.