Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Penny's option declined....
Soxtalk.com > Sox Baseball Headquarters > The Diamond Club
Wanne
QUOTE
The Los Angeles Dodgers, needing money for other pursuits, have declined a $8.75 million option for 2009 on pitcher Brad Penny.
Penny will get a $2 million buyout from the Dodgers. The right-hander is now eligible for free agency.
Penny, 30, went 6-9 with a 6.27 ERA for L.A. in 2008, after going 16-4 with a 3.03 ERA in 2007.


Kenny...start dialing!
Balta1701
He'll make more than that on the open market I think.
Steve9347
Foolish to decline an option that pays an above average starter less than 10 million.
Wanne
QUOTE (Steve9347 @ Nov 5, 2008 -> 04:33 PM) *
Foolish to decline an option that pays an above average starter less than 10 million.


That's what I was thinkin' too...that's a REEEEEALLY attractive salary to have on a pitcher like him to dangle as trade bait. Not sure what the hell the Dodgers were thinking.
caulfield12
If the White Sox were to acquire Penny, imagine the expectations that would be set? LOL.

Cooper will have him looking like Loaiza Version 2003 in no time (while simultaneously adding to Poreda's arsenal and nurturing Danks/Floyd/Richard). Everyone would be saying the White Sox POTENTIALLY have the best rotation in the game of baseball...
Balta1701
QUOTE (caulfield12 @ Nov 5, 2008 -> 02:41 PM) *
If the White Sox were to acquire Penny, imagine the expectations that would be set? LOL.

Cooper will have him looking like Loaiza Version 2003 in no time (while simultaneously adding to Poreda's arsenal and nurturing Danks/Floyd/Richard). Everyone would be saying the White Sox POTENTIALLY have the best rotation in the game of baseball...

Hell, if I were Penny...I might well be looking at a team like the White Sox...a team with a record of helping turn guys around or building guys up, maybe for a short 1-2 year deal to take another shot at FA after a "Contract season" type performance. Like the Sox, or Cardinals, or perhaps the Braves or Padres. Someone like that.
caulfield12
While we're at it, whatever happened to Leo Mazzone? Maybe his influence in ATL was overrated, because he didn't do very much to turn around those Baltimore hurlers (well, he did get some results from Bedard before he flaked out).

Daniel Cabrera is another intimidating physical presence that would/could be a Cooper project...as long as he still has his 94-98 MPH fastball.

I'm starting to think the White Sox should pay Cooper more than Guillen or Barack Obama. He seems to be responsible for fixing almost every problem with our pitchers, not only at the MLB level, but also our top pitching prospects.
Wanne
QUOTE (caulfield12 @ Nov 5, 2008 -> 05:01 PM) *
Daniel Cabrera is another intimidating physical presence that would/could be a Cooper project...as long as he still has his 94-98 MPH fastball.


That's the other guy I thought we be a nice target. My thinking being having a package starting with Javy and Getz (and fill in the blank(s) with possibly JD) for Cabrera and Roberts. Don't flame...it's a starting point. But if you're gonna deal with the O's...make it a type of blockbuster.
sircaffey
The Dodgers must not think Penny is 100%.
Thunderbolt
Penny isn't the 1st to be punished for partying with BA, and he won't be the last.
On a serious note,
If you could promise me a healthy Penny for a decent price I’d give him a spot as the 5th starter.
However the Penny we have seen over the last few years is anything but healthy. He's too much of a liability to put any real investment in.
Kalapse
Wait, so Don Cooper is now a surgeon/miracle healer? How exactly is he going to "fix" this:

http://www.insidesocal.com/dodgers/2008/08...s-mri-resu.html
QUOTE
The [MRI] revealed increased scar tissue in the front part of the right shoulder, which appeared to be impinging on the rotator-cuff tendon, causing inflammation and irritation.

Because that's what was wrong with him in 2008 and why he finished the season on the 60 day DL, shoulder problems. There's still a belief that Penny might need shoulder surgery in the offseason, that's why the Dodgers declined his option not because he forgot how to pitch.
That funky motion
Pavano was bought out.
witesoxfan
He did talk about his shoulder in the party video. It would make sense, and I bet he is still hurt as caffey said.
Dick Allen
Penny's option was $8.75 million. Considering the buyout was $2 million, the Dodgers were only saving $6.75 million which would be a steal if he pitched anywhere near where he did before the shoulder problems. Considering the Dodgers have a better idea than any of us about his physical condition in the shoulder, the buy out tells me they must think his regaining his form is not very likely.
SoxFan101
I would have no problem if KW took a flyer on Penny/Pavano.
southsider2k5
Are we willing to pay what Marquis got a couple of winters ago from the Cubs for Penny (3 years $21 million) or more?
TCQ
Penny/Pavano might be a good idea but it has been said that penny is a bad work ethic guy, which is something we dont need. Anyone know if pavano is actually healthy?
Dick Allen
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Nov 6, 2008 -> 10:13 AM) *
Are we willing to pay what Marquis got a couple of winters ago from the Cubs for Penny (3 years $21 million) or more?

No way. If he would take an incentive laden deal one year deal, fine. Maybe with some kickers that guarantee 2010 if he reaches some performance standards, but the Dodgers could have exercised the option and traded him. Obviously, there wasn't much interest at $6.75 million (assuming the Dodgers would eat the $2 million they ate) for one year. Why stretch it to 3? He's fat, lazy and injured. Maybe he's got something to prove and works hard in 2009, I have no idea about his shoulder, but it would be a mistake going multiple years.
Dick Allen
QUOTE (TCQ @ Nov 6, 2008 -> 10:15 AM) *
Penny/Pavano might be a good idea but it has been said that penny is a bad work ethic guy, which is something we dont need. Anyone know if pavano is actually healthy?

If he is, chances are it won't be for long. He's another guy it makes no sense to sign if there really is any risk taken by the team. If he's willing to work cheap with incentives, give him a shot, but no guarantees.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.