Per Passan, Elvis Andrus signing with White Sox, joining team in Cleveland

[Soxfest]

Better than playing Sosa or Gonzalez

[zisk]

3 hours ago, Soxfest said:

Better than playing Sosa or Gonzalez

Andrus is finished. Sosa and maybe Gonzalez have a future. Playing Andrus will only ensure that we won't have 

a MLB ready player next year for 2B. It's what stupid teams do.

[dohnut]

7 hours ago, southsider2k5 said:

I don't even remember what happened to Crick.

I didn’t even remember we had a Crick.

[ShoeLessRob]

33 minutes ago, zisk said:

Andrus is finished. Sosa and maybe Gonzalez have a future. Playing Andrus will only ensure that we won't have 

a MLB ready player next year for 2B. It's what stupid teams do.

This 100%.

[GreenSox]

43 minutes ago, zisk said:

Andrus is finished. Sosa and maybe Gonzalez have a future. Playing Andrus will only ensure that we won't have 

a MLB ready player next year for 2B. It's what stupid teams do.

But expected.  This type of move is the M.O. of this front office.
Maybe it will work out for once.

[Lip Man 1]

55 minutes ago, zisk said:

Andrus is finished. Sosa and maybe Gonzalez have a future. Playing Andrus will only ensure that we won't have 

a MLB ready player next year for 2B. It's what stupid teams do.

Maybe, maybe not. No guarantees what the G.M. may do in the off season, he may ignore Sosa or Gonzales completely and get another mediocre veteran player. The Sox still have a chance to make the post season (I don't think they'll be around long if they do but that's for another time), shortstop is a key position. The Sox defensively are challenged the way it is, putting a guy at that spot who has shown to be able to play the position is pretty important right now in my opinion.

[JoeC]

57 minutes ago, zisk said:

Andrus is finished. Sosa and maybe Gonzalez have a future. Playing Andrus will only ensure that we won't have 

a MLB ready player next year for 2B. It's what stupid teams do.

By this logic why have a AAA team at all?

It’s not just an overflow roster.

[Bob Sacamano]

1 hour ago, GreenSox said:

But expected.  This type of move is the M.O. of this front office.
Maybe it will work out for once.

Give me the guy hitting .237 over the guy hitting .114.

[pcq]

His glove stats are negative. Leave him in Cleveland. 

[southsider2k5]

10 hours ago, GreenSox said:

But expected.  This type of move is the M.O. of this front office.
Maybe it will work out for once.

The team has lost their top 3 SS, the last 2 of which happened after the trade deadline.  I am curious what move should be made here.

[GreenSox]

9 hours ago, Bob Sacamano said:

Give me the guy hitting .237 over the guy hitting .114.

Yes, in a static world this would be an upgrade.  The world were old decliners stop declining and young players don't improve. That's how the FO has seen things for years.
Hopefully it works out for 2 months.

[Harry Chappas]

22 minutes ago, GreenSox said:

Yes, in a static world this would be an upgrade.  The world were old decliners stop declining and young players don't improve. That's how the FO has seen things for years.
Hopefully it works out for 2 months.

How can you say this?

Robert, Jimenez, Cease, Kopech, Vaughan, Sheets were all brought up when they could have been left down longer.....Collins had no business being given opportunities 

[JoeC]

23 minutes ago, GreenSox said:

Yes, in a static world this would be an upgrade.  The world were old decliners stop declining and young players don't improve. That's how the FO has seen things for years.
Hopefully it works out for 2 months.

I mean, the definition for "success" of this signing is literally "Andrus doesn't completely suck."

He can be below average (or even moderately suck), and I'd consider it a success. The replacements (Sosa, Romy) are not viable ML players at this point, given the circumstances.

[Balta1701]

24 minutes ago, GreenSox said:

Yes, in a static world this would be an upgrade.  The world were old decliners stop declining and young players don't improve. That's how the FO has seen things for years.
Hopefully it works out for 2 months.

Well do we really have confidence in the young guys being at a level where they can step up and contribute any time soon rather than being a black hole? That’s not a thing this franchise does very well.

And yes, other franchises can do this and the white Sox can’t, this is a separate issue.

[wegner]

I'm not going to complain about what amounts to a "no brainer" move.  I would put Cueto in that same category and that obviously worked out great.  If it doesn't work, you move on.....after Elvis night of course.

[Bob Sacamano]

25 minutes ago, Balta1701 said:

Well do we really have confidence in the young guys being at a level where they can step up and contribute any time soon rather than being a black hole? That’s not a thing this franchise does very well.

And yes, other franchises can do this and the white Sox can’t, this is a separate issue.

Sosa has looked so overmatched. Not saying he won’t improve but just don’t think it will be this year. The offense isn’t good enough to wait.

[HoosierSox]

12 hours ago, zisk said:

Andrus is finished. Sosa and maybe Gonzalez have a future. Playing Andrus will only ensure that we won't have 

a MLB ready player next year for 2B. It's what stupid teams do.

Sosa clearly needs time in AAA. Romy is at best a utility infielder. Andrus can at least provide average SS play until TA gets back. 

Edited August 19, 2022 by HoosierSox

[GreenSox]

26 minutes ago, Balta1701 said:

Well do we really have confidence in the young guys being at a level where they can step up and contribute any time soon rather than being a black hole? That’s not a thing this franchise does very well.

And yes, other franchises can do this and the white Sox can’t, this is a separate issue.

 I don't disagree with anything in your post.

To me, adding Andrus is like bunting:  it probably has a higher chance to score one run - to  be just enough to eek into the playoffs.
I just think young players  (and I would go beyond just SS; don't see much value from Pollock either) increase the odds of us actually being good; and better prepare and position the team for the next year or three.  And part of the reason for my position on this is that I'm not convinced that the team, as is, is simply good enough even if Andrus plays decently.  At least not with this power outage.

 

[JoeC]

3 minutes ago, GreenSox said:

 I don't disagree with anything in your post.

To me, adding Andrus is like bunting:  it probably has a higher chance to score one run - to  be just enough to eek into the playoffs.
I just think young players  (and I would go beyond just SS; don't see much value from Pollock either) increase the odds of us actually being good; and better prepare and position the team for the next year or three.  And part of the reason for my position on this is that I'm not convinced that the team, as is, is simply good enough even if Andrus plays decently.  At least not with this power outage.

 

What is it about Romy and Sosa that makes you think they're going to be productive at the big league level?

[CaliSoxFanViaSWside]

11 hours ago, Lip Man 1 said:

Maybe, maybe not. No guarantees what the G.M. may do in the off season, he may ignore Sosa or Gonzales completely and get another mediocre veteran player. The Sox still have a chance to make the post season (I don't think they'll be around long if they do but that's for another time), shortstop is a key position. The Sox defensively are challenged the way it is, putting a guy at that spot who has shown to be able to play the position is pretty important right now in my opinion.

Yes it is plus Andrus hits Cleveland very well in his career at their field.

[wegner]

3 minutes ago, CaliSoxFanViaSWside said:

Yes it is plus Andrus hits Cleveland very well in his career at their field.

I would like Elvis to enter the building and have a Carlos Lee at Wrigley type of weekend.

[Bossanoveralls]

It would sure be swell if Elvis turns out to be the next Julio Cruz, eh?

Not a prediction.

[Buehrle>Wood]

21 minutes ago, JoeC said:

What is it about Romy and Sosa that makes you think they're going to be productive at the big league level?

Not sure if either will succeed but at least Romy looks like he belongs. Sosa at times looks like we put a fan out there.

[GreenSox]

9 minutes ago, JoeC said:

What is it about Romy and Sosa that makes you think they're going to be productive at the big league level?

 I just  think this team needs a "hail mary." (and I wouldn't necessarily limit the "hail mary" to those 2). hopefully the Cleveland series will reveal that  I'm premature on that. 
 

[wegner]

13 minutes ago, GreenSox said:

 I just  think this team needs a "hail mary." (and I wouldn't necessarily limit the "hail mary" to those 2). hopefully the Cleveland series will reveal that  I'm premature on that. 
 

2 Hail Marys, 1 Our Father, and an Oscar Colas

Edited August 19, 2022 by wegner
Apologize for missing the Oxford Comma 1st time for those fans of Vampire Weekend