Thanks for reading my post. Glad to see so many White Sox fans clicking on it.
And I have to say I've written 25 of these so far and have found that White Sox fans have been very cool and not leaving "He's a Retard" posts on the blog.
Let me address a few things:
QUOTE (CaliSoxFanViaSWside @ Mar 18, 2009 -> 10:51 AM)
There was a similar article in Sox Machine ( one of the best Sox blogs out there) and seems as though many of his picks came from the Sox release of the all-time team that was out in 2000 (which you can find somewhere on the Sox website.
I've never read this article. I put the team together based on BaseballReference.com (the single greatest website in the history of mankind) and weighing heavily the 2005 team along with the 1917, 1959, 1983 and 1993 teams.
I always lean heavily towards post season success.
That's why I had to put Doc White in there (he's a White Sox pitcher who beat the Cubs to win a World Series... you people should be naming your children after him!!!)
Contreras beating my Red Sox and clinching the first pennant since Eisenhower was in office was what gave him a spot for me.
But trust me, I understand wanting Freddie Garcia (or Jon Garland for that matter) on the roster. It's a challenge writing these bad boys and there will inevitably be a person or two who gets left off.
As for Albert Belle... yes he was great those two years in Chicago... but they weren't the greatest years for the Sox. I know, not his fault, but as a fan of the White Sox, wouldn't you rather show your love to Jermaine Dye, Scott Podsednik, Ron Kittle, Paul Kornerko and Minnie Minoso?
For Jim Thome... BELIEVE ME that was a tough call for me.
Basically it boiled down to Dick Allen or Jim Thome.
Thome is a great player.
There is NO WAY on Heaven, Hell or Earth I am leaving Dick Allen off of this list.
Roberto Hernandez was REALLY hard to leave off.
But I know I needed Jenks.
Hoyt Wilhem needed to be on.
Wilbur Wood needed to be on.
And it would be wrong to not honor Doc White. (See above)
So it boiled down to Keith Foulke, Roberto Hernandez or Jerry Staley. And as I said in the post, I wrestled with it and I gave the slot to Staley based on his role with the 1959 champs.