TCQ No doubt... even if Carter pans out and Q can't stay healthy, the only argument would be hindsight is 20/20...
KW made the trade for the last 2 seasons as well as the future... he could not have known last season would unravel as it did... if the Sox had won the division, Thome is still around..
then, as was the case 2 years ago, thome is DH and Konerko is at 1st base and the earliest Carter becomes a white sox rookie is 2011...
If Carter were an outfielder or third baseman, maybe it's something to consider but as a 1B/DH this was a no brainer for where our organization was...
Brandon Allen was also very highly thought of at the time, and I fear that trade for Tony Pena may come back to bite us even more...