-
Davis Martin & Luis Castillo to the Rockies for Salary Relief
Gotta wait and see how the rest of the offseason plays out, but right now this is spending Davis for the ability to transform Luis Castillo into Dustin May without adding money. It’s hard to imagine that the upgrade is worth creating the additional need.
-
Skubal to Dodgers
I can’t tell if you’re just not reading anyone’s response or what. He HAS progressed. The pace isn’t even weird. He was drafted in 2021 as a two way player, who converted to pitching full time in 2022. He then “progressed” all the way to the majors in 2024, and pitched really well, before going down to TJ. So he missed all of 2025 and started pitching again this year until he hurt his hamstring. So, college draftee. Wasted one year hitting, took two years to get to the majors, succeeded, and then lost a year and half to Tommy John. That’s why he’s 27.
-
Skubal to Dodgers
The revenue issue is legitimately unfair. There’s no reason to hate the dodgers for what they do, but their revenues are so much higher than mean/median that I’m not sure it’s something they actually deserve credit for. Their TV revenue alone is comparable to or in some cases higher than the TOTAL revenue of half of the league, and TV revenue is traditionally the third-highest revenue source, meaning their resources are (extremely likely) so laughably more abundant than average, who is to say they’re even being all that aggressive? It is not uncharitable to say that something needs to be done to address competitive balance. However. The MLBPA has a very strong point that the imbalance can be addressed with an overhauled revenue sharing framework, something that could be solved entirely within the ownership class, without input or even opinion from the players, beyond token ratification. The problem being highlighted by Manfred is real, but it’s being used as a Trojan horse for the salary cap, which is NOT the only (or even necessarily the simplest) way to address the problem. The reason the owners want the cap is black and white: their franchise values are constrained by the uncapped and rising market costs of competitive labor. You can see this each time a team sells — the sale values are significantly lower than those of the NBA despite the MLBs greater reach and drastically more monetizable schedule. I have been recently convinced that the owners are very much prepared to absorb very substantial short term loss in order to get this implemented, in some form, this time around — because they see it as their best opportunity to do so. Not because the dodgers got Skubal. The coming lockout was a certainty long before that happened. Don’t allow the narratives to twist your thought processes.
-
Skubal to Dodgers
Because he’s on the IL for a hamstring strain. I gotta say, you’re line of reasoning on this is really strange. You’re hyper-fixated on a single point of PROXY data that isn’t even a direct measurement of his ability, at the complete exclusion of a plethora of performance data that paints a different picture. I mean, I just got done listening to Eno Sarris say that Ryan has the third highest Stuff+ (the metric most highly correlated with future mlb success) in all of AAA, has FIVE pitches that rate above average, and is able to command them to hitters of both-handedness. Don’t you think THAT might be what makes him a prospect? Rather than his outlier age, which is easily explained by the combo of his late conversion to pitching and TJ surgery during his rookie year?
-
Do you think the Sox should really be buying?
Jake Rogers is a very good clubhouse presence, at least. Really down year on both sides of the ball, but is a good game caller and usually a good defender even if he isn’t hitting.
-
Do you think the Sox should really be buying?
You can use that same argument to make the case they can’t afford NOT to take the bird in the hand here. The Tigers should have run away with this division, but they fumbled and left a door open. Cleveland and Detroit will be right back there whenever we play again, and the other two aren’t any further behind than the Sox, in terms of their own “expected” returns to prominence. If you want to wait for a year that the team looks like a WS favorite coming into preseason, you’re going to be waiting a very long time. It’s simply not true that anything less than a WS win is meaningless — and they’re absolutely capable of winning a (EDIT: playoff) series or two, even if they enter each as an underdog. A significant postseason run would a be a huge positive to this franchise, and would benefit the current competitive window, even if it costs something to obtain. More revenue in the short term, more fan interest in the short and mid term, important experience for young players, confidence from a core that can’t be acquired any other way than being there. There’s even a chance it means JR is more confident and willing to spend. You can and should draw a line wherever you think at which guys are untouchable, but the benefits of a successful year are worth investing in.
-
Do you think the Sox should really be buying?
Sox should be adding, shopping in the rental market. An opportunity is an opportunity, and a playoff appearance is meaningful to the fanbase, the players on the team, and the bottom line. They should absolutely not be trading top prospects, for all the usual reasons plus the fact that this is not the year to be paying extra for a player with an additional year or two of control, as there is a very real possibility of losing next year.
-
Trade Ideas/Rumors/Proposals Thread
Sox should push in and try to make it happen this year. There’s no need to trade a major prospect to do it. We know better than most that tomorrow is never guaranteed. It’s not wise to assume everyone stays good/improves.
-
Teel injured in WBC - Grade 2 hamstring strain, out 4-6 weeks
But how is it “totally meaningless?” It’s not the MLB, it’s a different baseball entity. Just because you’ve decided YOU only care about the MLB season doesn’t mean the rest of the baseball world needs to. The overwhelming majority of all professional players don’t ever get to the World Series, meaning that this is likely the most significant championship they’ll ever get to play for. There are thousands of fans around the world, some from countries whose cultures hold baseball in higher esteem than the United States does, who care much more about this tournament than anything that happens in the MLB. I couldn’t possibly care less about the NFL, and every year I feel the media shift away from baseball pennant races toward NFL camp coverage, and I hate it. That doesn’t make that coverage “totally meaningless.” It’s just not for me.
-
Teel injured in WBC - Grade 2 hamstring strain, out 4-6 weeks
It’s some of the most compelling baseball happening anywhere in the world, behind only mlb playoffs and certain pennant chases. If you’re a baseball fan, or even just a sports fan, the value is self-evident. The very game he got hurt in was awesome. If you’re a White Sox fan over a baseball fan, I’d see why you feel that way. But it shouldn’t be difficult to imagine the other side.
-
An ominous future...
Right. I’ve been careful to keep saying “average” team. Outliers on both ends.
-
An ominous future...
The only way those revenue figures are accurate is if they are counting all concession/merchandise revenue 1:1, which is only true for teams that run their own concessions operation. Most don’t, using legends or Aramark or Delaware north or whatever, and those deals are profit sharing models. There are also a very wide range of parking arrangements, which are very lucrative because they are high margin. It’s not safe to assume the team sees all of that revenue, or even any in some cases if they share or utilize facilities controlled by the city. 2024 was also the final year before most of the RSN deals imploded. Knock 30-60M off those numbers and the percentages increase quite a bit.
-
An ominous future...
I can tell you with the utmost confidence that one of those numbers is very wrong.
-
An ominous future...
I don’t disagree with this at all. But it’s just important to point out that the players were getting like 40-50% of the revenue then and they’re getting 80-90% of the revenue now. Which, good on the players and their union. Only point I want to make is that there is not the same amount of fat to trim off anymore, and that leads to a fundamentally different set of circumstances. But yes, revenue is not the same as wealth. The owners are doing fine. But “owner” does not equal “team” in terms of revenues/P&L/etc.
-
An ominous future...
Yeah, I have also struggled to come up with the best solution from a fan experience perspective. The hardest part is that no matter what you go with, you won’t know if it sucks until you try it