We were having a discussion about the AS game and how stupid the one man rule is on another thread. So I decided to find out who you think should represent the Tigers. Id say Monroe. He has like half the ABs everyone else has but if he got the playing time hed lead the time in just about every offensive category. I just wonder what position he plays...

MAROTH FOR ALL-STAR!

Maroth sucks. Hell lose twenty games easy and it wont be because hes a tough luck loser like Ritchie was at the beginning of last year, it will be because his ERa is 5.66. When you have an ERA of 5.66, youll lose the majority of your games...

The exact reason the one man per team rule has to be abolished in every sport. I don't watch the allstar game just to watch the white sox players. If there we none in the game i'd still watch just the same.

Got to go with Cornejo. Hes got 2 of the Tigers 5 wins for God's sake!

 

And the Tigers are leading 4-0 in the 4th, Detroit winning 3 in a row? They're hot!

Maroth sucks. Hell lose twenty games easy and it wont be because hes a tough luck loser like Ritchie was at the beginning of last year, it will be because his ERa is 5.66. When you have an ERA of 5.66, youll lose the majority of your games...

Ritchie had an ERA of 6.06 or so.

 

And you don't think Maroth has had it tough? He's gotten lit up in like 2 outings all year. That's why ERA is overrated. He was supported with about 0 runs in his first 2 or 3 starts....you won't win games when you are supported by 0 runs.

 

I'd Maroth on our team. All he needs is a little confidence. He can be great(see 7 no-hit innings against Baltimore)

If the Tigers have anyone on the DL, that's who gets my vote.

Ritchie had an ERA of 6.06 or so.

 

And you don't think Maroth has had it tough?  He's gotten lit up in like 2 outings all year.  That's why ERA is overrated.  He was supported with about 0 runs in his first 2 or 3 starts....you won't win games when you are supported by 0 runs.

 

I'd Maroth on our team.  All he needs is a little confidence.  He can be great(see 7 no-hit innings against Baltimore)

Maroth looked good both times against us, he just has had no luck. Everytime he pitches well the Tigers don't score.

Does Kirk Gibson still play for the Tigers?