QUOTE(witesoxfan @ Feb 16, 2007 -> 07:23 PM)
no, he really didn't. There were people forgiving him - me included - but he didn't do a good job at all. You can't give up that many homers out of the bullpen and be considered good.
I tell you what, look at the other mid/long guys in the AL. Find me two that did a better job than McCarthy. Homeruns, doubles, singles walks, who cares. A run is a run. I don't see any difference in a homerun versus two hits and walk mixed in. It's about eating up innings and giving the very good offense a chance to battle back. Sure, McCarthy gave up a high percentage of bombs/IP. If you want to argue the end of the season was poor, you're right, his ERA jumped over the 4.5 mark and he struggled. Then at least give me that until September he was perhaps the best in the AL when his ERA was at or under 4. All in all, the sox were way ahead of the game compared to the rest of the AL.