Whitesox get- Odalis Perez and Jeff Weaver

 

Dodgers get- Paul Konerko Jose Valentin and 1 or 2 minor leagures

Welcome, I hope you come here to add to the discussion

 

Anyways, If the Minor Leaguers are not Cotts, Pacheco, Reed, Muñoz, Rudy Yan or Felix Diaz... I would do it

I just don't like Weaver after the beanball incident. So no thanks. Change Weaver to Dreifort or something.

You are giving up too much talent for too little.

I just don't like Weaver after the beanball incident. So no thanks. Change Weaver to Dreifort or something.

Driefort makes 13 Million Bucks.. No thanks

Dodgers would not do that deal

well i think they would if we put Borchard and another descent hitter in the deal

well i think they would if we put Borchard and another descent hitter in the deal

If you mean a 'descent' hitter as in one who hits alright in AAA but whose batting average descends in the majors, the Borchard's your guy. If you meant 'decent' hitter, then I don't think that can be applied to Borchard yet. I'm also in the camp that wants nothing to do with a trade involving waste of space Weaver.

 

Welcome aboard, btw.

I dont know. It depends on who the prospects are. PK could go back to old form (like he did in the 2nd half) and Valentin will be replaced by Uribe so hes expendable. Then Weaver and the Sox probably have bad blood (and Weavers ERA was 5.99), and Odalis Perez is good but not great. So, after looking at it, Id have to say no.