for those of you who say you don't want paulie in it why? hes not going to hurt himself swinging for the fences. hes not derrek lee

We could only hope... Tell me how on earth PK is deserving? He isn't even deserving of an All-Star spot. My gawsh I'd rather have Timo as an All-Star 1st baseman than PK....at least his hits matter most of the time. :headshake

We could only hope...   Tell me how on earth PK is deserving? He isn't even deserving of an All-Star spot. My gawsh I'd rather have Timo as an All-Star 1st baseman than PK....at least his hits matter most of the time.  :headshake

 

well, he's deserving of being in the homerun derby, because he has 20 homeruns. that being said, arod has more, manny has more, and so on. pudge doesnt deserve it no matter which way you look at it.

D-Lee declined b/c of shoulder soreness. I kind of like the format. They should've added Ichiro to see if this guy can swing for the fences in addition to slapping singles everywhere.

well, he's deserving of being in the homerun derby, because he has 20 homeruns.  that being said, arod has more, manny has more, and so on.  pudge doesnt deserve it no matter which way you look at it.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

There are always players who don't deserve to go. Get rid of this "every team needs a rep" Bulls***. It's not a true All-Star Game when every team needs to be represented.

There are always players who don't deserve to go. Get rid of this "every team needs a rep" Bulls***. It's not a true All-Star Game when every team needs to be represented.

A la the NBA....the Bulls havent had a rep since Jordan....

Question: If a Cub's player was to represent the US, would the Americans still root for him????

 

PS: I'm thinking we should have a HR Derby chat....anyone up for it????

Edited July 11, 200520 yr by SoxFan1

How can you guys not be rooting for Carlos???

 

Although I just heard a Cub (D. Lee) predict him winning it, that cant be good.... :banghead

 

Where's the smiley with a Panama flag!

 

GO ELCABALLO!