Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

American Idol Predictions

Featured Replies

QUOTE(The Critic @ May 11, 2006 -> 06:36 PM)
For what it's worth, Chris is going to become the new singer for Fuel.

They've struck a deal to buy out Chris' AI contract so he can record the new disc and then tour.

There's some debate whether AI will allow this to happen until the summer tour ends.

I like Fuel a lot, but I've never heard this guy sing. I hope he fits Fuel's sound.

 

What happened to Fuel's previous lead singer?

  • Replies 281
  • Views 17.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

QUOTE(Rex Hudler @ May 11, 2006 -> 10:32 PM)
What happened to Fuel's previous lead singer?

He quit the band, I never heard why.

His cousin is Johnnie Putnam from WGN's overnight radio show, and she keeps saying what an idiot she thinks he is for quitting the band. But she didn't say why either, at least not that I heard.

 

(and YEAH, YEAH, I listen to GN's overnight show a little.....it's hard to listen to David Stein on SCR or Jason Smith on MVP for very long, so I do a lot of channel-flipping on the train.)

QUOTE(The Critic @ May 12, 2006 -> 07:21 AM)
(and YEAH, YEAH, I listen to GN's overnight show a little.....it's hard to listen to David Stein on SCR or Jason Smith on MVP for very long, so I do a lot of channel-flipping on the train.)

 

They do make CD's and other things so that you can bring your music with you and you don't have to listen to the radio. Just letting you in on a secret.

I think it is pretty easy to envision Chris being the most successful guy from this season no matter who wins it. You couldn't get a better situation for an idol by surrounding him with a band that fits him perfectly. It will be interesting to see how it plays out.

QUOTE(Kid Gleason @ May 12, 2006 -> 07:52 AM)
They do make CD's and other things so that you can bring your music with you and you don't have to listen to the radio. Just letting you in on a secret.

Thanks for the insight, Copernicus!

:P :D

I get bored bringing the same tunes with me all the time.

When I get my iCrap for my birthday, I'll bring my whole collection with me and then I won't listen to the radio as much.

But I'll still bring my little Walkman, because I like to hear the news of the day and I have no intention of subscribing to podcasts.

I guess you know this by this point, but three songs each. First one chosen by Clive Davis, the second by one of the judges and the third chosen by the contestant.

 

I thought Taylor was the best, followed by Katharine and then Elliott. I'll go ahead and predict that order of finish from here on out, even though I originally predicted Kat would win. I think Taylor just has too big of a following at this point.

QUOTE(Rex Hudler @ May 11, 2006 -> 10:32 PM)
What happened to Fuel's previous lead singer?

Threadjack Update:

Brett Scallions, Fuel's former lead singer, is now playing bass for two bands, The X's and Circus Diablo ( with Billy Duffy from The Cult on guitar ).

Rumor has it that Brett's voice is shot, but he strongly denies this. He had surgery to correct a deviated septum, but the things I've seen online indicate that this type of surgery would not damage the pitch or strength of a singing voice.

Anyway, that's why the opening is there in Fuel, but no official word on whether that Chris guy has accepted the spot.

QUOTE(The Critic @ May 16, 2006 -> 09:21 PM)
Threadjack Update:

Brett Scallions, Fuel's former lead singer, is now playing bass for two bands, The X's and Circus Diablo ( with Billy Duffy from The Cult on guitar ).

Rumor has it that Brett's voice is shot, but he strongly denies this. He had surgery to correct a deviated septum, but the things I've seen online indicate that this type of surgery would not damage the pitch or strength of a singing voice.

Anyway, that's why the opening is there in Fuel, but no official word on whether that Chris guy has accepted the spot.

 

He's under contract with American Idol until the end of the summer, so I wouldn't expect him to decide anything right away.

  • Author

Overall, not a great song choice night (which can really be said any time I have to hear "I believe I can fly." I agree that Taylor had the best night. But I was bored through most of Katherine and Elliot's performances. Maybe it was just my tv set, but I thought that Katherine's version of Over the Rainbow was not hot (and at times almost painful).

Boy last night the differences were profound. Taylor was by far the best, and Katharine was way better than Elliot. Elliot looked scared out of his mind last night. Katharine did to for her first song, but was OK after that.

There does seem to be a judges attempt to sabotage Kat. Her's and Elliot's voices are both just as technnically sound, but Kat has a stage presence that is really captivating. Elliot has none. I never hear Kat being flat or "pitchy" (a favorite word it seems).

 

It was funny, once Clive said that he wanted Elliot to do Journey, I did a Randy impression of what he would respond with. I was pretty much dead on, even with all the Randy-isms.

 

I think Taylor will win. He's the one out of them all that is seasoned performer. The guy obviously has done his time on a stage and it shows. Hopefully if he does win it AI will let him bring his band with him.

I hope it's Elliot's turn to go. He would look absolutely dull on that big stage where the finale is filmed. Please, send "Mr. No-It-Factor" home

QUOTE(Kid Gleason @ May 17, 2006 -> 09:35 AM)
There does seem to be a judges attempt to sabotage Kat. Her's and Elliot's voices are both just as technnically sound, but Kat has a stage presence that is really captivating. Elliot has none. I never hear Kat being flat or "pitchy" (a favorite word it seems).

 

It was funny, once Clive said that he wanted Elliot to do Journey, I did a Randy impression of what he would respond with. I was pretty much dead on, even with all the Randy-isms.

 

I think Taylor will win. He's the one out of them all that is seasoned performer. The guy obviously has done his time on a stage and it shows. Hopefully if he does win it AI will let him bring his band with him.

 

Speaking of Clive...I don't know where he was going picking "I believe I can fly" for Kat, I thought that was a horrible choice. As for them picking their own songs...I think they all pretty much suck at it except for Taylor.

Now that Elliott is gone, I'm going to do the unthinkable and cheer for Taylor.

 

IMO Katharine is has let all of this get to her head and hasn't taken any criticism well the past few weeks.

 

Plus I will admit Taylor was awesome this past week.

 

Dancing in the Dark was badass.

 

Also, thought it was awesome the reception they gave Elliott back in Virginia. Of all of the return trips, I thought Elliott enjoyed his the most and he was just geniunely happy to be on the show to begin with. Probably my favorite contestant ever on the show.

QUOTE(aboz56 @ May 18, 2006 -> 11:14 AM)
Now that Elliott is gone, I'm going to do the unthinkable and cheer for Taylor.

 

IMO Katharine is has let all of this get to her head and hasn't taken any criticism well the past few weeks.

 

Plus I will admit Taylor was awesome this past week.

 

Dancing in the Dark was badass.

 

Also, thought it was awesome the reception they gave Elliott back in Virginia. Of all of the return trips, I thought Elliott enjoyed his the most and he was just geniunely happy to be on the show to begin with. Probably my favorite contestant ever on the show.

 

 

Elliot seems like the nicest guy out of all the AI contestants since the show started. He just seems like a genuinely cool guy. No stage presence at all, but still a cool guy.

 

I agree about Katharine. Her reply to Ryan about who that guy was who went up to her at her homecoming was really arrogant sounding.

QUOTE(Kid Gleason @ May 18, 2006 -> 02:12 PM)
Elliot seems like the nicest guy out of all the AI contestants since the show started. He just seems like a genuinely cool guy. No stage presence at all, but still a cool guy.

 

I agree about Katharine. Her reply to Ryan about who that guy was who went up to her at her homecoming was really arrogant sounding.

Plus she looked at Randy and Paula funny when they didn't like her last performance.

 

And I want her Mom to sit the hell down.

 

I think Taylor's going to win, but I really see Chris as the best talent on the show this year.

 

Listening back to his Suspicious Minds performance from his last show, I thought that was one of the stronger performances of the whole season, it's just too bad his second performance that show wasn't as great or I have no doubt he'd still be in.

Great quote from Elliott today:

 

"I'm going to do whatever I can to just be heard and be successful," he told The Associated Press in an interview Thursday.

 

"If that means that I have to hit the studio tomorrow and record an `Old McDonald Had a Farm' remix, then that's what I'll do. I don't want to compromise my style though. ... But whatever comes my way I'll take," Yamin said.

Yeah, but Katharine is still fun to look at. :D

QUOTE(Rex Hudler @ May 18, 2006 -> 11:22 PM)
Yeah, but Katharine is still fun to look at. :D

 

Can't argue that!

Tuesday night should be a good night. Two of the three songs each will sing will reportedly be repeats from some point this season. I predicted about 6 months ago that Kat would win and Taylor will finish second. Two weeks ago I reversed course. I do think Taylor will win, but it seems the results aren't very reliable at this point.

 

With all three contestants at 33% and change last week, that just tells me that the phone systems are maxed. I don't think the voting would be so close if there was more capacity to take votes. When people reportedly call for two hours and get busy signals 90-95% of the time, then the votes aren't getting counted. I'm not sure if they can remedy that this week, but as popular as this show has gotten, the voting procedure certainly has come into question in my mind.

 

Either way, I think all of the top 5 or 6 contestants were very talented this year, more so than others. I think you will see at least decent success from many of them. Tuesday night should be fun.

Well tonight is the nights... Just for fun, pick a song, artist or style you would pick for each contestant...

 

For Taylor I would love to hear him sing somemore of the gravely rockers around. Something like Jim Croce, Bob Seager, Joe Walsh, etc.

 

For Katharine I would like to hear her sing something with some soul and range. I could see her knocking out some Aretha or something like that.

I want Taylor pulling out some Sam Cooke. Another Otis tune would be cool also. He needs to hit on his Soul, R&B and or Gospel influence and it will all be in the bag.

Rumor has it Taylor may break out the harmonica tonight.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.