Who do you keep if it is a cumulative, wins-based decision here:

 

Hudson or Penny?

 

I'm leaning toward keeping Penny, but I'm not sure which I want/would be better suited with.

 

and

 

who do you drop, if you have to pick one or the other:

 

Lincecum or Cain?

 

I drop Cain because Lincecum is a K machine and they're both healthy.

Also: Marmol or Bell?

Tough call between Penny and Hudson.

 

I'd go with Penny, though I'd be tempted to go with Hudson since Penny had what was the best season of his career.

 

I'd also drop Cain, like you said Lincecum is a K machine, I would keep the guy with the better whip and ks generally.

 

Between Marmol and Bell, well neither are the closers just yet, I'd go with Marmol, I don't buy into Wood holding that closer job and Marmol should be next in line if he already isn't the closer.

Penny gets more Ks I think but he's due for a "back to normal" season.

 

Hudson's an injury waiting to happen.

 

push.

 

I agree on Rock's other points. (scary! )