I saw your back and forth in the other thread.

 

Brady NO way would be winning super bowls with the Colts.

 

But I'm not sure Manning would in NE either.

 

Probably, because as you said, NE is definitely a better all-around team.

Why don't we make a poll about whether Peyton would have 47 TD's throwing to Deion Branch and David Patten, and handing off to Antwain Smith?

Why don't we make a poll about whether Peyton would have 47 TD's throwing to Deion Branch and David Patten, and handing off to Antwain Smith?

Go for it. If you really want to know. While you're at it, make a poll if Brady would win a playoff game with the Indianapolis defense.

Peyton would make David Terrel look good.

Peyton would make David Terrel look good.

Actually I have to disagree there.

There is just no way, this guy drops practically everything thrown his way.

Brady looked great tonight. :rolly

Actually I have to disagree there.

There is just no way, this guy drops practically everything thrown his way.

The fact that he makes Reggie Wayne look good makes one believe that Terrell could do halfway decent with Peyton.

Brady looked great tonight.  :rolly

Brady was horrible tonight. Nothing around that.

Nothing like the Dolphins handing homefield to the Steelers. A loss to the Jets this weekend would seal a wild card bid for NY and might even cost the Pats a bye.

 

How screwed up is that when a 13-3 team wouldn't even get a bye, but two 8-8 teams are gonna make the post season?

The fact that he makes Reggie Wayne look good makes one believe that Terrell could do halfway decent with Peyton.

??

 

Reggie Wayne IS good.. Peyton doesnt MAKE him look good

While Peyton is one of my favorite players, Brady still owns him until Manning gets the ring.

?? 

 

Reggie Wayne IS good.. Peyton doesnt MAKE him look good

One reason for his success is Stokley and primarily Harrison.

 

Make him the #1 receiver on someone's team and see what he does.

This seems like a nice thread to peronally thank Tom Brady for home field throughout the playoffs.

One reason for his success is Stokley and primarily Harrison.

 

Make him the #1 receiver on someone's team and see what he does.

Wayne is the leading WR on the Colts.. Wayne is good

The people who are voting 'Yes'...did y'all vote for Alan Keyes as well? I noticed that he also got about 20% of the vote.

 

Brady is a kick-ass quarterback who would make a team like the Ravens or Jaguars a prime super bowl contender (as they are just shy of the elite level as of now with insane defense and insane running backs), but the Colts? Yeah, right. :rolly

 

Manning is the absolute best in the league, and if he can't turn the Colts into a super bowl contender, then nobody can.

 

So what, he has pieces on offense...big deal. Montana had Rice, Taylor, Craig, Jones, Barton, Cross, Paris, etc. The list goes on and on and on for Montana. But nobody in their right mind is gonna question Montana's greatness. Now why is that?

 

Hmmm

 

47 TDs, 8 INTs, 127 rating...ahh, just chalk it up to his pieces. Don't give the man any credit for being hands down the most intelligent QB in the league.

 

Steve Young holds the all-time record for highest QB rating in a season with 112. Manning is at 127 with two games to go. That's some Barry Bonds type s*** right there.

Steve Young holds the all-time record for highest QB rating in a season with 112.  Manning is at 127 with two games to go.  That's some Barry Bonds type s*** right there.

Check that, his passer rating has dipped down to 124.

 

You suck, Manning :fyou

Brady is not a great QB, he is good yes, but the Patriots play together better than anyone in the league.. I think with Weis leaving they may start to slip a little..

 

And last night Brady looked very below average against Miami, but they always play him tough..

 

And the INT he threw away, wow, I never thought I would see Mr. Tom Brady make that mistake... But I LOVED it

The people who are voting 'Yes'...did y'all vote for Alan Keyes as well?  I noticed that he also got about 20% of the vote.

 

Maybe they don't understand the question. They probably think that I meant that if Brady was traded to the Colts, would he still have his rings.