I bet Josh Fields could hold his own in a fight. The guy played Division 1 football. It ain't intramurals brother.

Edited November 26, 200718 yr by BaseballNick

Ozzie. He's outsized and would have to fight dirty. He's crazy enough to take a bite otta someone's chest.

 

"I don't know karate, but I know cuh-razy".

Joey Cora. Stay away from him unless you want your leg bitten the s*** out of.

 

Okay, I think Jenks and Anderson would be in the top. Jenks does have the history. I remember reading Jenks was going to beat the crap out of a bartender who threw ice cubes at his head because he was a scrubs fan.

 

 

 

I think Jermaine Dye would ace everyone else. Anderson is a panzee. Jenks is lazy. AJ is old and beat up. I think the only person that would have a chance would be carl everett if it would be allowed.

I think it is obvious that AJ Pierzynski would win: (1) He has all the catchers gear for protection (2) He would fight dirty, just to maintain his reputation.

This is my favorite thread this off season.

 

And I voted for Brian Anderson after the cub brawl where he pummeled John Mabry. The kid is smaller but he can do some damage if he's angry.

Honestly, Jim Thome is a nice guy, but if someone pisses him off, it's over. He's a quiet monster. Fields is a close second.

Edited November 26, 200718 yr by SoxAce

Well if Carl Everett is allowed then......hands down Aaron Rowand would destroy everyone. I remember a couple years ago there was an article and some players said they would want Rowand taking there back more than anyone.

 

"thats grown man s***"

Is this really true? Was that in his Indian or Phillie days?

 

They were good friends, though, so it's okay that he whomped him.

 

Actually, I am a little off. From an interview:

 

Q. What is the angriest you have been on a baseball field?

 

A. I could say when I charged the mound in Boston a few years ago, but I wasn't really angry. I was charging Rheal Cormier, a buddy of mine, out of obligation, so that doesn't count. Angry, like berserk? To be honest, I can't think of one.

 

Q. What were you thinking on your way out to tangle with Cormier?

 

A. Get him in a headlock, get him on the ground and just lay on him. I wasn't thinking about punching him. I just wanted to lay on him and tell him, "Stay here, don't move and nobody gets hurt." He did what he had to do, and I did what I had to do.

Brian Anderson.. what a scrappy little man.

They were good friends, though, so it's okay that he whomped him.

 

Actually, I am a little off. From an interview:

 

ROFFLE

I thought it would be Thome or Jenks.

I went with Thome cause I just sense him needing just one punch to knock the s***

out of somebody.

 

Joey Cora. Stay away from him unless you want your leg bitten the s*** out of.

 

don't forget he took out zambrano with the fungo bat

If Frank Thomas was on this list would you vote for him? I know I would, I could see Big Frank picking up Matt Murton and breaking him in half like a twig.

 

 

Frank's probably waiting for his 600th home run to do that.

It seems like the biggest guys in MLB rarely fight. Can you name a big MLB guy that got into a lot of fights or near fights?

lol@ AJP getting all these votes.

 

He didnt do s*** in that brawl against the Cubs.

 

All talk and no walk.