Value Over Replacement Player (From Baseball Prospectus):
Chicago White Sox (Olivo, Konerko, Harris, Crede, Valentin, Lee, Rowand, Thomas, Ordonez) ... 186.2
Detroit Tigers (Rodriguez, Pena, Vina, Munson, Guillen, White, Sanchez, Higginson, Young) ... 176.6
Seems to me that your lineup isn't as superior as you think it is and that you are overrating your players.