Baldwin has made some of the highest difficulty plays among Sox outfielders this year in terms of catch probability — he's a good runner and gets some good jumps. But the finer points of outfielding have gotten him badly with balls near the fence and windy days. And his throwing arm is not good at all so he loses value there too. I think if he had time to learn the position he could end up being decent but he's not there now and his bat isn't picking him up. He hasn't fielded well in the infield either and there aren't many excuses for it.
So if you're Cannon, you had the guy struck out but the call isn't made, then the guy squeaks one inside the foul line, guy barely safe at home (if at all), pop up gets dropped, crazy slide gets the guy an extra base..
I don't watch the Cubs enough anymore to know: is the insane wind all the time or more of a rare thing that's just going on this weekend? Feels like a meaningful home field advantage to get used to the crazy things happening to fly balls and pop ups.
I'll admit the only thing that keeps me from constant ranting and raving about it is that I don't have a promising suggestion for who should be taking his job
I just don't see the upside with Burke. He has a good rising fastball, but the velo isn't very good which limits how much he can get out of it. None of his other pitches have either a good shape or get good results (his curveball is a big breaker, but it seems a good curveball doesn't get you anywhere these days). On top of that, he has zero command. So what's the point? Normally a guy who is so strike-challenged has something else going for him besides he's got a pitcher's body and has "mound presence."
FWIW, entering today Quero ranks 12th out of 64 catchers in throwing value, per Statcast. Not sure he had any chance to get the man on the three steals today. The high throw was obviously a bad throw, but not clear to me a good one would get him. Incidentally, Burke generally rates well at keeping runners close but not looking good today. His fellow Massachusettan Mike Vasil ranks 2nd to last (or worst on a per-batter basis) in MLB at stopping the run game.
Smith got screwed by his defense that inning but he's got nothing right now. Finally used his changeup a few times against Busch and got what he needed. If he isn't feeling the changeup then he's dead meat because none of the other pitches are very good
Smith apparently isn't willing to use his changeup today (only thrown 3, just one was in the zone) and you can see why the Brewers weren't interested in hanging onto a version of Smith without a changeup