QUOTE(Greg Hibbard @ Jun 2, 2006 -> 10:35 AM)
BULLPEN
Okay, Jenks appears to be just fine generally. Cotts' ERA and WHIP are now down to very respectable numbers, and will continue to fall. Thorton had an amazing May and outside of last night, appears to be the real deal. Politte has respectable numbers. So we have a closer and three set up guys. Obviously this Nelson thing did not work. Fine, we tried something, it didn't work. Obviously McCarthy is not really that comfortable in this role some of the time, but he has shown flashes of brilliance. He is still a kid and needs a long leash.
I'll take my chances with Starter/Thorton/Politte/Cotts/Jenks against anyone any day of the week, and probably win 3/5 of those games on average. So what if some relievers had a s***ty night. It happens.
I'm with you until the Bullpen analysis. What did I miss -- how did the Nelson thing not work? I haven't watched the last few games, only listened to them with Farmer and Singleton, but Jeff Nelson has looked okay to me every time he's been in there; in fact, I've wondered why Ozzie hasn't used him more. Am I wrong, did he bomb?
And I have no confidence whatsoever in Politte. I want to, I really do, but I just don't feel good when he's in the game (and neither, obviously, does he). IMO Cliff is expendable.
I would like to see B-Mac in the starting rotation, maybe even this year. I'm sorry that Jon Garland has a no-trade clause.