January 19, 20233 yr I'd have to start with Walsh, Buehrle and Wood. Not sure about the final 2 spots.
January 19, 20233 yr Author Here's the thing. If you transported the entire top $5 line to this era, they would all be toast, except MAYBE Tom Seaver, though I am guessing he probably didn't arm tunnel enough to hide his curve-ball enough to make it a weapon in 2023. Especially those 78 mph 1900's junkballers would be teeball fodder in this day and age.
January 19, 20233 yr 1 hour ago, southsider2k5 said: Here's the thing. If you transported the entire top $5 line to this era, they would all be toast, except MAYBE Tom Seaver, though I am guessing he probably didn't arm tunnel enough to hide his curve-ball enough to make it a weapon in 2023. Especially those 78 mph 1900's junkballers would be teeball fodder in this day and age. I was working on the assumption that each pitcher would be facing hitters from their own eras.
January 19, 20233 yr I assumed you were getting the WS version of these pitchers so I didn't think Seaver was a $5 but anyway Buehrle: bulldog, durable, dependable Wood: no one lately has seen a knuckle ball. Anyone injured, he covers lol. One year had 49 starts. Hell, he could probably be your bullpen. Hoyt: bulldog, versatile Garcia: here for big games Fernandez: bargain at $2
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.