This trade in in the process in League #8. Should it be vetoed? If so, tell me why...

 

Mark Texeira for Lyle Overbay

 

2004

 

Overbay---1st full year----83 R, 16HR, 87RBI, .301AVG

Texeira---101R, 38HR, 112 RBI, .281AVG

 

In 2003

Texeira--1st full year ---66R, 26HR, 84RBI, .259AVG

Nope, lyle well do much better this year with the new milwauke offense, his average is better. Texeira however may still be better, but its 2 close to veto IMO.

definitely overbay was a one hit wonder and texeira is just amazing, veto it

Texeira >> Overbay

 

He had better stats in '04 and has a better lineup around him than Overbay.

That's a major difference, Texiera is a second or third rounder, Overbay is much later. On a side note, check out this laugher. It's certainly going to get vetoed, this came right after Pujols for Damon was vetoed:

 

Pujols, Podsednik, and Delgado

 

for

 

Orlando Hernandez, Scott Kazmir, and Esteban Loaiza

 

I'm not sure if the better smiley is :headshake or

That's a major difference, Texiera is a second or third rounder, Overbay is much later. On a side note, check out this laugher. It's certainly going to get vetoed, this came right after Pujols for Damon was vetoed:

 

Pujols, Podsednik, and Delgado

 

for

 

Orlando Hernandez, Scott Kazmir, and Esteban Loaiza

 

I'm not sure if the better smiley is  :headshake  or 

 

I need that guy in my league!

I need that guy in my league!

 

I think everyone needs that guy in their league, unfortunately you're also going to need several people that are just as clueless to get the trade passed. Sometimes I wonder why these people even bother running teams. What's worse is he flat out dropped Orlando Cabrera, Mark Mulder, and Eric Chavez (works for me I guess, I got Chavez).