July 18, 200322 yr AL comeback player of the year: Frank Thomas, White Sox Hmmm, Thomas ... or Loaiza? The White Sox have a couple of candidates for comeback player of the year (and if Roberto Alomar re-signs there as a free agent, they'll certainly have another candidate next year). The pick here is Thomas, because his value to the White Sox when he's on comes in many different ways. And he has traveled quite a distance, from getting scolded by Paul Konerko last year on the weekend before the All-Star Game for not being a team guy to being a legitimate candidate for the game this July. http://www.sportsline.com/mlb/story/6483237
July 18, 200322 yr I'd say Carl Everett has a better shot than Frank at winning the award. At this point last season Everett was hitting under .200. Loaiza has to be on pace to win the award.
July 18, 200322 yr My vote is for Estaban... Hell, he might even pick up the Cy Young if we start scoring for him
July 18, 200322 yr Next year we'll have a whole s***potful of candidates for Comeback Player of the Year. At least at the beginning of the 2004 season. Of course, if they duplicate their 2003 season(s) next year, they wouldn't really qualify for the Comeback award. And, Jason, I wasn't aware that Everett had such a bad year last year. If that is the case, then please tell me why we gave up so much for him.
July 18, 200322 yr Everett was banged up last year, but this year he's playing very well and has always been one of the more talented players in the majors. Most of the guys in the deal aren't that great in my mind. I still can't say whether the Sox won or lost this deal simply because the trade isn't finalized. Plus, if the Sox get two first rounders out of it plus get Everetts services for a few months for free, then they are definately doing just fine.
July 18, 200322 yr Jason, I'll agree with you IF we get the two first rounders, but it might result in us eating a big contract next year through arbitration or whatever.
July 18, 200322 yr Everett was banged up last year, but this year he's playing very well and has always been one of the more talented players in the majors. Most of the guys in the deal aren't that great in my mind. I still can't say whether the Sox won or lost this deal simply because the trade isn't finalized. Plus, if the Sox get two first rounders out of it plus get Everetts services for a few months for free, then they are definately doing just fine. Jason, Carl Everett has averaged the following numbers over the 8 years of his career. .267 17 HR 67 RBI And that INCLUDES his two monster years. He may be talented, but those two years have clouded everyone's brain as to the kind of player he really is. He is an average player at best who has the ability to have a huge year if the stars align properly. There are lots of those type players in the Big Leagues, including Carlos Lee, who's numbers are better.
July 19, 200322 yr Loaiza all the way. He deserves it more than any of the corpses that posess the same dugout that he does.
July 19, 200322 yr the big question mark is are we going to go after any fa, which means we will lose our 1 rounder. but that pick may be in the 20's
July 19, 200322 yr To be comeback player of the year, don't you need something to come back from? As far as I'm concernd, E-Lo never arrived as a major force until this season, so what did he come back from? He was just a below average pitcher before this season...
July 19, 200322 yr To be comeback player of the year, don't you need something to come back from? As far as I'm concernd, E-Lo never arrived as a major force until this season, so what did he come back from? He was just a below average pitcher before this season... Wasn't he injured last season ?
July 19, 200322 yr Wasn't he injured last season ? i remember something like that. but still he is having a career yr, i wonder if he can do it again?
July 19, 200322 yr Everett was banged up last year, but this year he's playing very well and has always been one of the more talented players in the majors. Most of the guys in the deal aren't that great in my mind. I still can't say whether the Sox won or lost this deal simply because the trade isn't finalized. Plus, if the Sox get two first rounders out of it plus get Everetts services for a few months for free, then they are definately doing just fine. Jason, Carl Everett has averaged the following numbers over the 8 years of his career. .267 17 HR 67 RBI And that INCLUDES his two monster years. He may be talented, but those two years have clouded everyone's brain as to the kind of player he really is. He is an average player at best who has the ability to have a huge year if the stars align properly. There are lots of those type players in the Big Leagues, including Carlos Lee, who's numbers are better. first you attack king alvarez, then jurassic carl in the same day. enough! :fyou
July 19, 200322 yr You can only win the awARD once and i think THomas won in 2000 You're right. He did.
July 19, 200322 yr Rex, I agree his numbers aren't great, career wise. But he did develop into a pretty good player and when healthy he has been pretty good. From what I've seen of him I love what he does. The Sox did overpay though. Well if the Rangers take Pacheco and Rupe they overpaid.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.