nitetrain8601
-
Posts
9,673 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Calendar
Posts posted by nitetrain8601
-
-
18 hours ago, oldsox said:
That's not why the franchise sucks. Passan is as shallow as Lake Erie.
Disagreed. He only had a 2 minute segment on it, but he goes through TLR and not adding top tier FA talent. He's clearly talking about being able to add a Harper or Machado, then failing to do so.
I mean, if you want a catch all in terms of why the rebuild failed, he could tell you too. Not sure why you're going at Passan who is as fair as they come.
-
3
-
-
14 hours ago, pcq said:
You have to plan ahead when a site like Arlington or Maywood Park becomes available.Too bold for our blood. I would check on Hawthorne race track or a shopping mall.
The 78 which is the area north of Ping Tom Park
-
4 minutes ago, South Side Hit Men said:
Both Fangraphs and Baseball Reference indicate Benintendi is a below average left fielder this season, and having his worst season defensively in his career.
Worst defensive season fWAR = 2023 (-10.5 YTD)
https://www.fangraphs.com/players/andrew-benintendi/17901/stats?position=OF
Worst defensive season bWAR = 2023 (-0.8 YTD)
https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/b/beninan01.shtml
Basically, no matter how you spin it, this might be the worst contract in Sox history. The sad part is, Beni would be the focus of a lot of negative if he was on almost any other organization. Our team, however, is so rotten, as long as Beni doesn't get himself in trouble, no one is going to blink an eye.
-
1
-
-
On 8/20/2023 at 6:56 AM, wrathofhahn said:
Hahn actually has done alright on trades and been about average hitting on prospects.
But hes been absolutely f'n god awful in free agency. Wasted hundreds of millions of dollars on barely replacement level players. FA should really should be the easiest part the job but time and time he wastes money on guys which absolutely kills our ability to field a competitive team.
The worst part is Beni had a .352 BABIP last year. This is around what his normalized OPS should have been last year. Anyone with half a brain could have seen this coming.
Infact his xWOBP (his expected weighted OBA) was .334 according to fangraphs his actual OBP so far this year is you guessed it .334. His slugging and ISO numbers are a bit down and he probably a bit better than his power numbers this year but when we signed him we should known what he was.
He never was going to be the 122 wRC+ of last year.
Bingo. Never liked the signing, considering Beni never had any deal on that table. He's a 7-8-9 hitter at best.
-
13 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:
Yes, we need wholesale change, but we all know that Hahn is a problem. There is zero downside risk to firing him and going with someone else. Realistically, we need to bring in someone from the outside to be our President of Baseball Ops and let them scorch Earth this org. I think outside of Shirley & Paddy, all other members of the front office should be on the chopping block. But I’ll take a Hahn firing as an appetizer to hopefully bigger things to come.
Shirley and Paddy need to go too. It's rotten to the core. But as someone else stated, until they spend money on something, they're not going anywhere.
If you suck at Scouting, Development, International Signings, then you need to pony up the money for FAs to cover that gap. If you suck at FA because you're too cheap, or your team misevaluates players, or you have a GM who loves to spend the dough on a bullpen, then you better have a strong Scouting, Development and International presence.
The Sox do neither. And that's why the entire thing is rotten. It's caught up to them.
Add to the fact that they hired Pedro Grifol who clearly knows nothing about what he's doing (he's worse than Trestman was for the Bears) from a losing organization who they tried to upsell to the fanbase when that losing organization would rather not hire him, and you have a team in shambles. Is help on the way? Nope. Getz and KW Jr have done nothing in the minors. Our analytics department is a step away from non-existent. And we have a FO who they allowed to lead the draft and trade deadline when they're more concerned with keeping their job everyday.
They need a Theo, but they would never commit the money that Theo commands, not just for the ballclub, but to have an actual infrastructure put in place. Sox thought they were hiring Theo-lite when they promoted Hahn. Another failure.
-
2
-
1
-
-
1 hour ago, waltwilliams said:
Absolutely right ... the renovations done in 2003-2004 really helped make new Sox Park seem less generic.
It's now an attractive facility, especially inside -- well-maintained, great sightlines, etc.
This is by far the most accessible stadium in the city -- located in a central location in the region, near three (!) public transportation lines and two major expressways (Dan Ryan and LSD). It's got the best tailgating scene in the city. And then there's the fact that it's the same location as the old park -- so in essence the Sox have played at the same location for 113 years. There's a definite appeal to that.
There's nowhere else in the city/region that would work as well as their present stadium/location.
That said, it's definitely time for another major renovation -- they really need to overhaul the outfield/bleacher section (would love to see them get rid of the Tinkertoy ad space in the outfield).
There's also room for development around the stadium. Before he died, Jim Thompson talked about how he wanted to build a hotel on the property, perhaps in the area where the old ballpark was. But that idea was nixed by JR, who also nixed Thompson's request to share profits for the "Bacardi in the Park" restaurant that the state/taxpayers built for the team back in 2011: https://www.dnainfo.com/chicago/20160825/bridgeport/sweetheart-deal-on-ballpark-naming-rights-nothing-new-for-white-sox/
I disagree. There are other accessible places such as The 78 in South Loop which would be more central if anything.
-
1
-
-
19 minutes ago, Quin said:
The fun thing is most of the "tankies" likely know this and it's why we (at least I, personally) wanted to bottom it out sans Robert and just let the young guys get their development in now and do the FA spending this offseason.
But Pedro is doing his weird "we must compete with the old guys" dance, so here we are.
Edit: In the absolute miserable situation that the Sox are a league-worst team again next year, it's only for the first round and I think Shirley has hit on Crochet (ruined to this point by Hahn, player dev and coaching), Montgomery and Schultz, while reserving judgement on a freshly drafted Gonzalez. Those were all outside the top 10.
I don't think you can say they've hit on anything outside of Robert. Crochet is in incomplete at best. And availability is an ability. Montgomery and Schultz have shown nothing in the majors. If Montgomery is as good as TA, you lucked out. But you absolutely don't know what you have minus a prospect, certainly nothing to say "Sox hit"
-
1
-
-
The problem is, they simply lack the infrastructure to do what they need to do. The personnel up top simply is out of touch with baseball, but more importantly, with their own team. Their scouting is looking at your favorite ranking system and going after them. I don't know if they actually do any scouting. Even those they're taking fliers on, are just former 1st rounders who were failures. They simply don't invest in Latin America other than trying to sign the next Cuban connection. Anytime they have to develop one of those players, they bust.
Draft wise, they've simply missed. Madrigal looks good, but not godly like some predicted. Tough thing is, maybe their amateur "scouting" is good, but their player development is that poor. You can't tell with this team because they seem to suck as everything other than making the fanbase upset.
They wanted to retool, but didn't get the pieces necessary to successfully compete next year unless they spend the money. They're not going to spend the money. Don't tell them they need bullpen help, because Hahn will give away whatever budget he has to that position. It's stupid to spend money on a bullpen since it's volatile from year to year. Even an elite closer is usually only elite for 3 years.
They need a starting 2B, 3B, RF, C and at least two SP if you think Kopech can hold up. My guess is, they're going to try to resign Clevinger. They need locker room leaders and need to be accepting of that.
Seems like the only good position players are the ones that the team isn't spending time on developing or those who have tuned out Sox coaching.
Grifol couldn't manage his way out of a paper bag. But they're going to bank on the division being poor. Hahn is going to say they knew they would be taking a step back as if he never said they expect to compete next year, reminiscent of Gar Forman with the Bulls saying they fired Thibs for underachieving with what they thought was a championship team, then the next year saying he didn't say that when Hoiberg was trash.
The whole organization is rotten to the core. The only entertainment value you have is Luis Robert, Dylan Cease once every 5 days and to watch the other team in 2024.
-
1
-
-
1 hour ago, TheBooneLoganEra said:
My God, I had forgotten we had traded both Bassitt and Semien for one year of Jeff Samardzija. Guh.
Yep, could've had your middle INF as Tatis Jr and Semien who is quietly the most underrated 2B in probably the history of the game.
Don't get me wrong, TA is okay, but the Sock have been cheap for awhile, and pretty dumb to add to it.
-
Awful deal the moment it was announced. Hahn bid against himself, similar to Ryan Pace when he did that draft day deal. No one was going to give Benintendi that. The team had so many glaring holes too and he blew it all in one spot for someone you could've paid league minimum to do the same job for. If you liked the deal, it's only because you liked the name.
Don't get me wrong, Andrew could be a serviceable player, but you don't give the richest contract in your team's history to a serviceable player when they already count enough pennies as it is.
-
1
-
1
-
-
1 minute ago, Polar Bear said:
My personal opinion these transactions should be made today
DFA or suspend TA for the remainder of the season (he will never play for the Sox again, exercise the $1m buyout for 2024) and call up Sosa to play SS
DFA Andrus and call up Rodriguez to split time at 2B with ZR and SS with Sosa
DFA Grandal and call up Lee
Team meeting where the law is laid down with clear expectations and punishments are set forth
Some player better step up and get this s%*# corrected (Eloy, Robert, Cease, and Kopech would be my hope)
But nothing for the manager or FO who put the team together? That's where you have to start
-
1
-
1
-
-
Don't want anyone making a decision on this squad any further. It's pretty clear to see how come development of all these stud prospects has failed with no accountability after Renteria left. It's possible to have fun while holding people accountable. Maddon did it. Dusty does it. It's okay for Eloy to wear his shirt loose, pop the chest hair with the gold around his neck. It's ok for Anderson to be outspoken as well as defend himself. It's not okay that each individual team member is just that, an individual on an island by themselves forced to figure it out themselves.
This team needs a FO that's held accountable, that holds their subordinates accountable and let that flow down to the minors. They need to teach analytics like launch angles. Stop suppressing pitchers and give them the role that fits them, like Kopech and closing.
Lastly, this team needs to accept leadership and it's not just one guy, it needs to be multiple folks. Never thought I'd say it, but yes, this team needed Ozzie or his type to check players when they're out of line. To get on Eloy for not training properly, etc.
-
5 minutes ago, Eminor3rd said:
I know I keep saying this, but I just don’t see any indication at all that this org is intending to rebuild. The only thing theyve done is concede 2023. All the players they traded are pending free agents.
I don’t think they have the nuts for another rebuild. There’s no argument that could possibly justify NOT cleaning out the FO first, and there’s nothing the current FO can say about how they’d do it differently this time around. I truly don’t see any other path than “half-ass contend every season” ad nauseam until the firing squad finally comes.
I think RH is going to get one more chance and a $30M offseason budget to make it work, business as usual. It’s unquestionably the right baseball move to rebuild, but there’s zero incentive for the current leadership to do it. They’ll roll the dice again and deal with the outcome when it happens.
It's the right baseball move to pick a direction and go all in on that direction. The problem is, the Sox FO, which includes ownership, are all in on half measures. The path to contend next year is going to require spending money and making ballsy trades (now that they traded some pieces off). If you rebuild, it also requires ballsy trades, but a lot less money. They're not going to do either. And they'll continue to cite something that happened 15-20 years ago to justify decisions.
The Sox are doing exactly what JR stated is always the plan - just give your fans some hope, enough to think there is effort made. For as many die hards as there are, there's a million more casuals who won't see what the sham really is.
It really is a classless organization.
-
4
-
1
-
-
17 minutes ago, caulfield12 said:
Let’s say they lose tonight in Colorado to go back to three games under .500.
It’s going to be fascinating to see if Preller is ready to trade Snell (as good pitching the last 6 weeks as Bellinger hitting), Soto, Hader and even Seth Lugo in less than 24 hours.
Nobody realistically believes they’re going to sign Juan Soto to a massive extension…but there’s something of an Ohtani thing going on where trading him after dealing so many minor league Top 100 guys (and Gore) just over a year ago isn’t going to be well received at all unless he can “win the trade” in the eyes of the fanbase and get their MiLB system back to Top 5ish.
And they’re just 1 1/2 behind the Cubs…AZ and Miami falling back, etc.
Also, Darvish isn’t having the type of year where selling him makes any sense.
Darvish isn't great, but better than many starters that are available. In addition, how much does he cost? I think the Padres are going to cut some type of salary if I had to guess.
-
Momentum is not there for anyone in the FO to be held accountable is the biggest thing he said. He admitted to being the least plugged in now than he's ever been in the past 7 years. Agreed that the Sox have had the most success when there seemingly has been a plan, everyone on the interview didn't feel like there is a direction. Hard to give up Cease while also trying to sell fanbase that they're competing next year. Brought up Sox also don't believe in spending on starting pitching, so that's why they're not giving up on Kopech being a starter. Stated they had given Keuchel the most money to a FA starting pitcher in team's history and that also didn't work out well. For the Sox to contend next year, they'll need SP, not less.
Sparknotes:
Sox are as dumb as we all believe or afraid to believe they are being.
-
3
-
2
-
-
6 minutes ago, caulfield12 said:
They're highly unlikely to trade 1 1/2 years of Soto for 2 1/2 of Cease.
That would be one sure way to create a fan rebellion after what they gave up to acquire him last year.
The White Sox would least need Soto from August and October, 2024. And they're not the kind of fans who show up JUST to see Juan Soto on their team....Bryce Harper, sure, even with Soto being the more consistent producer.
I think it has more to do with money, if anything else. And yes, it would be a little more than Cease, such as some smaller prospects. It would represent a large cost savings as well as address SP as well as open up other trades such as trading away Yu Darvish and Blake Snell.
-
When did Heyman say anything is on the table?
In my eyes, it should be. With that stated, if the Sox are truly trying to contend by next year, I think they should look at getting solid available everyday players. And to make it quick, they will have to eat some cash. But without them willing to pay anyone, I don't forsee it.
For example, I wouldn't mind a Cease for Soto swap with the Padres. Sox are too cheap and not creative enough for that, however.
-
Ozinga already has a field, right? Since the team is constantly a construction site and never finished, maybe Illinois Toll Authority or Local 123 will have to do. I could see the slogan now "Always Improving, Never Done". You know Hahn will run with it.
Meanwhile, Chicagoans know better, "Hard Hat Area: Under constant construction. Estimated completion date: Never"
-
I'm in the belief that if you're going to pay for players, you pay the position players who play everyday, not pitchers unless they're HoF-potential or you're a true contender. Cease still has that. Giolito, as much as I like him, does not have that ability. So dealing him makes all of the sense.
The Sox problems, as everyone has stated, are so deeply rooted, it's ridiculous. Their drafting has been terrible under Hahn. Their analysis of players in-house, has sucked. They made a few decent trades for flawed prospects. The ones that don't appear to be flawed have an in-ept coaching staff that couldn't teach 1st grade math. Their analytics, suck. The only thing that has kept them from not being moved to North Dakota and changing their name to the Flying Purple People Eaters is the fact that they've been able to attract some Cuban players who are older. They also either refuse or are incapable of developing a system for amateur ball players so they'll never end up getting someone like Elly De La Cruz.
They don't know how to develop anyone. It is to the point in which if I were a GM in baseball, I would fade everything the White Sox FO does, their philosophy in terms of spending, analytics, signings, trading, evaluation of their own players, etc. They've been a bucket of suck for far too long.
-
1
-
-
When did I miss KW taking over?
-
A few things:
In recent memory, I would agree. I said this when he was signed, as I followed the Dodgers as my NL team when Torre became their manager: Grandal is a good player to have in a great lineup, but for the most part, he only does well when everyone else is hot. If they're not, he typically will give you two good weeks with the bat before he slumps hard. For the amount of money, I hated it.
It's clear the locker room has no leader and when you try to be a leader, you get nuked/blackballed. I hated the Keuchel signing (said that back then too) because even in his good starts with Atlanta, he was laboring through them and you could tell he was done. He spoke the truth and no one wanted to hear it. TA is dealing with his own mess. Jose Abreu, a guy who never throws anyone under the bus, spoke his mind and got blasted for it as if he was a salty player. Seems like the only shot you have is being quiet and hope other players take to it. The Sox need a rowdy ass guy who's going to get on players, like a Harper or Machado to a lesser extent. The problem is, the clubhouse, and maybe the organization as a whole rejects that. And that's a huge problem. Only oh so much a manager can do in that regard. Funny thing is, I see a lot of fans who also get upset at the vocal leaders too. It's weird to me.
Moncada, who I had high hopes for, is a failure. Kopech is the same. Your best bet for Kopech is for him to be that dominant high stress relief guy or a closer. Moncada is a defensive replacement type guy. Sad thing is, if he gets with a team that develops hitters, I feel like we're going to be upset that we gave up on him. Vaughn is a guy who just isn't it. League average at best. He has the look, but not much else. Eloy is always hurt. TA has regressed and right now his mind seems to be off baseball as a whole. Our bullpen is too expensive and worst of all, our GM flat out doesn't know how to fix it. The owner doesn't care to fix it. We have no one in the pipeline worth mentioning at this time IMO. Our drafts are rather poor. Chances are, we will sell off the team and take lesser prospects so we can get money back or have to pitch in less money on our end.
This is what apathy with your baseball team is. Oakland is in Oakland and doesn't have the resources. We're in Chicago, and we just choose to operate this way. Won't spend big bucks on the players, farm system, scouting or the front office.
-
2
-
1
-
-
Also not a fan of Kap and JHood in the morning. They get too off track with each other. I hear too much about each other's wife.
I like Carm and Jurko. Waddle and Silvy is another one that gets too involved with family. Silvy is too much of a meatball fan. Also, the segment with Wilbon might be the worst weekly segment in Chicago Sports Radio. Wilbon clearly doesn't like being called out, and contradicts himself quite a bit to the point where it cannot be ignored.
Mully and Haugh talk quite a bit of Sox in the morning.
-
1
-
-
I think he needs to play everyday as well. I think we've gotten spoiled by thinking once players get promoted, they should be ready to go immediately. While some players can do that, not all can. Doesn't mean it's useless to have them play and give up on them so easily. There are countless examples of it working.
Jarred Kelenic looked awful up until this year. Now, he's one of the best OFers in baseball this year.
The Sox suck, might as well play him everyday so he could develop.
-
2
-
-
Bring back Leury as he was great for clubhouse chemistry on a 4 year, 75 million contract
Blame the other teams in baseball for not wanting to do business with the White Sox, then suggest how there's no one more upset than yourself
Talk more about negative fans (though with the amount of fans left, any fan should be considered good)
Throw Eloy at SS then talk about how playing SS is less load on the joints and muscles than DHing
Bad talk Jose Abreu because "he didn't want to be here anymore and any conjecture otherwise doesn't have the full story"
Give an open ended deadline about when negative fans will eat their crow - "Jump on the bandwagon now because in a few months, you're going to regret it, take that to the bank"
Summarize your points by talking about a "Us against the world" mentality that no one in the clubhouse cares about anymore
-
2
-
After an exhaustive search, Getz named GM/VP
in Pale Hose Talk
Posted
Disagree on the Bulls being worse off than they were with GarPax. GarPax had no one who wanted to come to Chicago, fired a coach over power, and had no prospects. Citing Lauri after he made two more stops is hindsight or Wendell Carter on another bad team. Bulls most definitely are better off for changing their FO. Demar is a legit player and helped legitimize. With that stated, Paxson quit, he wasn't fired. He flat out told the Reinsdorfs, he wasn't the man to do the job anymore and he helped look at other organizations and was heavily involved in the hiring process.
Bulls stench was so bad they couldn't get frontrunners to interview, such as Miami's 2nd in command. Also, at that point, Michael had taken over the day to day for the Bulls as chairman. Many thought he wouldn't ever fire Gar because their wives are best friends.