Everything posted by southsider2k5
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Feb 10, 2014 -> 12:48 PM) You do realize you become high spending when you pick in the top 5 every year don't you? There was one team worse than the White Sox. One. And of course when asked to name a few over slot guys that would have propelled the White Sox to at least average, crickets. Teams like the Red Sox and Yankees were in the top five every year?
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Feb 10, 2014 -> 12:26 PM) Name these over slot guys that the White Sox refusal to sign made their collective draft WAR less than half the average major league team. You always ask for examples and say the poster won't provide them. Here is a chance to practice what you preach. I haven't moved the goalposts at all. You are ignoring the White Sox passed on several players who were quickly snatched up and who became stars when they picked their busts. And for some reason think if they had spent more money, that would have automatically made them pick the best players when the evidence shows that to be unrealistic. So it is just coincidence that the highest spending teams from 2007 to 2011 have the best farm systems today? lol, ok.
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Feb 10, 2014 -> 12:05 PM) You are the one doing all of the ignoring. I have given examples of players selected near the Sox selections that were much better players than the ones the White Sox selected, and they didn't cost more money. We all know KW has thrown money at things on the major league level and it didn't make the team better. You have provided exactly zero examples of if the Sox spent more they automatically draft better. I showed you a couple of times they did spend, and it didn't work out. If spending money was a guarantee that the White Sox would be able to select the best player on the board, I just wonder when all it cost was what they were willing to pay, why they didn't choose a better player? Just answer that question. You have changed the goalposts about 50 times in the scope of this discussion to make some point that actually sort of works for you. You completely ignored anything that didn't work, including exactly what the former and current GM had to say on this subject, which is better than a couple of anecdotal pieces of made up "evidence" that don't even relate to the original discussion. There are also plenty of times that teams went overslot drafting after the Sox to pick higher ceiling-ed players, which even casts doubt on your latest non sequitor.
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Feb 10, 2014 -> 10:52 AM) How does that prove that KW could have had a top minor league system if he wanted one? His drafts were epically bad. He passed on players who became really good players and paid bad ones the same or more money. Ignore it if you want. I don't care. Everyone else sees it. For the last time, no matter how much money you spend, you still have to spend it on the correct players. You are honestly saying that money has nothing to do with a farm system? Speaking of ignoring...
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Feb 10, 2014 -> 10:22 AM) Wasn't the argument always draft position? Now it is spending. The fact is, if they are picking top 5 every year, they would have spent more. When they did spend, over $5 million for Borchard, the biggest bonus ever at the time I believe, and almost $2.5 million for Josh Fields, those guys sucked. Money wasn't the cure all. THEY NEEDED TO SELECT BETTER PLAYERS. One last time, I gave examples of guys who were available for slot money and were selected around the White Sox picks. There has been one example of going over slot, Porcello vs. Poreda which would have netted a better player. The White Sox paid slot. Current stars signed for slot. The White Sox from 2001-2007 had less than half the cumulative WAR of the average MLB team. KW threw money at the Major League team? Did it make the team better? Why would it have automatically made the minor league system better? And we haven't even mentioned the guy KW actually gave a promotion, and then wound up in jail. No matter how you spin it or change the argument, the point has been made over and over again. The Sox spent less than anyone else on the minor league system than anyone else in baseball, and they did it on purpose, to funnel money to the major league club.
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 07:59 PM) I am not denying anything. Google mlb signing bonus. Click on the angelfire link. They have the bonuses for this decade. I have researched and shown you just some of the stars the Sox passed on to pay inferior players more money. Maybe you can show me the players they would have selected had they allocated more money. I am sure you will not. I suppose if KW wanted a good farm system he would have drafted guys like Ellbury, Pedroia, Wright, Jones, Trout, Cain, but he didn't so we get Fields, Lucy, Ring, Honel, Broadway, for MORE money.My examples are guys that were drafted soon after they White Sox made a dud of a pick and were signed for slot money. Pretty straight forward. Besides, if you look at the guys who were paid way over slot, many didn't work out. The guy thought Jeff Marquez was Jon Garland. He thought Tyler Flowers was a stud. He compared Jon Gilmore to Joe Crede. Traded a pretty valuable trading piece for a bust of a prospect in Nestor Molina who he thought was starring in Winter Ball when he wasn't. The reason the minor league system was bad was certainly not money. Exactly what I stated from the beginning is 100% true. The White Sox spent 15% less than any other team in all of baseball from 2007 to 2011. They spent about 1/3 of what the top team spent. Both Hahn and Williams have clearly stated that they took money from development and put it into the major league team. Spin all you like, the facts are the facts. They flat our sacrificed the minors for the majors. If you want to stay in denial, by all means, do so.
-
NBA Thread 2013-2014
QUOTE (Jordan4life @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 07:39 PM) I've seen those dumb sites. They're making fun of his lazy eye as much as anything. 40.1 38.3 39.4 40.0 40.8 Those were his minutes played from '01 to '05, his best ball. Those minutes at that level, yeah, lazy is not the word that comes to mind. T-mac is an easy target because he never got out the first round. But dude was great. There were plenty there, including McGrady talking about how he didn't practice hard, and another putting him on the list of the laziest players in the NBA.
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 07:40 PM) Once again nothing. They missed on a ton of players. I pointed that out. Go back to the drafts and look at the bonuses. Google it. Angelfire has a link for every year. Overall, they may have spent little, but that is because they signed guys for slot. The first few rounds, the spending wasn't that different from other teams. They actually had 4 picks before Dustin Pedroia and Clay Bucholtz. They gave Fields, Lumsten. Whisler, All more money than Boston gave future MVP Pedroia. was selected in the second round. Ellsbury and Garcia were pick in the first round after Broadway and signed for less money. Mike Trout was $15,000 more expensive than jared Mitchell. Adam Jones was available and signed for less than Brian Anderson. Matt Cain was picked just after Royce Ring. Dan Haren and David Wright together got less bonus money than the Sox paid Kris Honel. Don't let the facts stop you.they pick a couple of the alternitives, just a couple, a lot is different. But it was miss, miss, miss. They scary thing is some people think these guys are going to pick a stud in the second round. History says probably not. I'll give you one thing. Even when it is there in print, you never admit you are wrong. Even when the GM himself said it, it didn't matter, let alone all of the sources. deny, deny, deny.
-
NBA Thread 2013-2014
QUOTE (Jordan4life @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 07:30 PM) lmao. If you say so. Shaq coming into every season, outside of his mvp one, fat and out of shape got wayyyyyyyyy more pub than T-mac's so-called lack of work ethic. Google "Tracy McGrady lazy"
-
NBA Thread 2013-2014
I don't know who strange theme poster-dude is, but McGrady's lack of work ethic is the stuff of legends
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (ptatc @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 06:41 PM) This is true. I know we disagree but I think the draft was sacrificed at the expense of the MLB. BUT THERE WAS THE ONE PICK IN THE ONE DRAFT!!!
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 06:38 PM) That is for the entire draft because they didn't spend $2-3 million on a 3rd round or later pick. They were usually right around slot I have examples of poor selections and proof there were plenty of other better players that they could have signed even cheaper.Please provide me a link of the White Sox saying they were just selecting guys to trade. There is a reason a 35 year employee lost his job in 2007, and your boy KW, didn't think it had to do with bonuses. I know you won't provide any links or proof of your position. You never do. The only thing I expect is some smart ass answer, but the proof is in the pudding. The White Sox minor league system was epically bad. No one wanted that. Not for one year. For years. Again, go ahead and look up their draft spending totals. Tell me where they ranked on minor league spending vs the rest of baseball during those years. Just like always, when proven wrong, you change the subject, hence all of the single examples trying to act like the truth isn't the truth. The Sox didn't spend on the draft, and instead put the money into the major league team. Example? How about this article for one, which incidentally was the first google hit under "white sox draft spending" SOX RANKED LAST IN DRAFT SPENDING FROM 2007-2011 http://taurussports.net/davids-blog/2014/1...t-spending.html Also the White Sox spent $34 million less on the draft than the Pirates from 2007 to 2011 http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2012-06...-baseball-draft graphic of draft spending in 2011 from fangraphs http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/visualizing...draft-spending/ From 2007 to 2011, the Sox spent $3 million less than any other team in baseball on the draft. http://hardballtalk.nbcsports.com/2011/08/...and-51-million/ 2008 saw the Sox spending only $300,000 in the international market, good for 22nd overall http://sonsofsamhorn.net/topic/38782-2008-...-international/ Now, what was that you were saying?
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 04:58 PM) Says they guy who thinks KW can do no wrong. HIS DRAFTS WERE AWFUL, AND THE SOX PAID THE PRICE. Jared Mitchell was $15,000 cheaper than Mike Trout. If you go back to that draft, there were a lot of scouts who thought the Sox would take Trout. That is one example. This isn't about being cheap. This was about poor selection. There were players who received smaller bonuses that guys like Broadway and have had decent careers. 3 consectutive years without a 7 collective WAR? If that is what he had in mind, if that was the plan, it was a dumb plan. No team that cannot spend $1 if they only have $.50 can not let that eventually get them. Wes Whistler and Josh Fields and Tyler Lundsen got a lot more money than Dustin Pedroia. Donny Lucy taken a couple of picks before Dustin got $50k less. Lanc Broadway signing bonus $1.57 million Jacoby Ellsbury drafted later that round $1.4 million bonus. Matt Garza had eve a smaller bonus. Every player draft after McCoullough who made the major leagues received a smaller bonus than the $1 million he was paid. It wasn't about the money. Excuses are for failure. The draft this century with very few exceptions, has been a rather large failure.the White Sox knew it wasn't about money. It is why they fired Duane Schaefer in 2007. The players being selected were not good enough.it is improved some since that happened, but that improvement really is one player, Chris Sale. These discussions all happened while these players were being drafted. Nitpicking an example here or there doesn't change the spending realities. Go look up the White Sox spending numbers for their drafts and get back to me as to where they compared to the rest of MLB. Go ahead.
-
2014 Winter Olympics
QUOTE (LittleHurt05 @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 02:02 PM) Poland with a gold medal! That skijumper guy was awesome.
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (ptatc @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 04:33 PM) I think some of this is true. He elected to put most of his budget to the MLB team so he took chances on guys he could sign for a low price. So in essence I think he did draft if not bad at least lower talented guys on purpose. He knew he couldn't afford the top tier. This is part of the reason I think the drafts will change as everyone will be limited in budget with slotting so the Sox will not be hurt as much. QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 04:36 PM) On top of that, I think they also specifically targeted guys based on "people that we'll be able to trade in the next year" like Broadway and McCullough even if they weren't the highest-rated guys on their board. I think they admitted that one too. Then throw in a couple of talented busts...Fields and Anderson and Poreda, and you've got quite a mess. Both also well stated points.
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 03:20 PM) Here is where KW f***ed up. It had nothing to do with trading prospects, it had everything to do with the prospects he drafted: WArR by draft class Year. White Sox Avg. Per team 2001 10.4. 17.0 2002 5.1. 19.0 2003 8.4. 14.2 2004 14.2 12.8 2005. 2.3. 15.5 2006. 2.5. 10.5 2007. 2.0. 5.7 2008. 8.9. 4.3 2009. -0.7. 4.4 2010. 12.1. 1.6 2011. 0.1. 0.4 2012. 0.0. 0.1 2004 although the Sox had 7 picks in the first 89, the WAR is all Gio. 2008 is Beckham and Hudson, 2010 is Sale and Reed. Other than those years, the Sox entire draft has been below average. Also Joe Crede in 2006 was the last home grown hitter to post a 3.0 WAR for the White Sox. Since then, they average team has had 7 of those players. No hitter from the White Sox 2001-7 draft classes has ever posted a 2 WAR season for the Sox. KW's claim that he could have had a top farm system if he wanted is ludicrous, unless he was drafting bad players on purpose. I'm sure you will ignore it again, but you damned well know that Williams went cheap on the drafts to put money into the major league team for quite a long time.
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (The Ultimate Champion @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 01:54 PM) If anyone at all ever wanted a stocked farm system it was Kenny Williams. Kenny understands the value of flipping probable future busts for MLB pieces and he's done it a thousand times over. He's also kept some guys who haven't turned out, showing that he does also believe that there is a time for investing in what your farm system produces at the MLB level. We're operating in a completely different era, thanks not to Rick Hahn who was always a part of this process, but thanks to the new CBA. It is nothing more than a coincidence that Hahn took over at a point where the Sox were ready to rebuild and that the new CBA put the Sox in position to be competitive in the amateur siginging process. If Kenny Williams worked for the Red Sox or Yankees he'd have done the same things they did, i.e. spend, spend, spend, take advantage of the system, even if for no other reason than to trade prospects for MLB value during times of need. And I'm drunk. But Kenny Williams is the s***. He's happy about where we are & he's the f***in guy who was in charge the last time the Sox had a truly respectable system. For about the 2985763985 time, Kenny Williams wanted to spend the money on the major league team, and not spend money on prospects who might pan out in years. I know why a few people take the quote completely out of context and turn it into something it isn't, but no matter how many times people repeat the same lie, it still isn't true.
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Marty34 @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 01:37 PM) Why do you always make it about the person posting. How do you argue with someone who ignores both history and reality?
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Marty34 @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 12:20 PM) Who brings it up? So they are sensitive to fans opinions when it comes the white flag trade and ignore them when it comes to Dunn? BS. lol. You are just flat out trolling.
-
Pressing Questions Yahoo Articles
QUOTE (raBBit @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 02:12 AM) Yeah, I am with scs here. No need for personal attacks. It is what he substitutes for intelligent thought now adays.
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Marty34 @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 10:37 AM) I disagree. It's hilarious the spin Kenny and this organization gets away with since they won in '05. The quote in the first post in this thread is one example, another is Kenny could have built a top notch farm system if he wanted to!! ha. Spin? Because people twenty years later STILL don't bring up White Flag at the trade deadline? Because we haven't turned vets into prospects over the last six months? No part of what you just said is actually true, no matter how many times you say it.
-
Hahn's next move?
QUOTE (greg775 @ Feb 9, 2014 -> 12:08 AM) I just thought of a great trade. Straight up DeAza for Buehrle. Or Danks for buehrle. BAHAHAHAHAHAHA
-
Kenny never wanted to rebuild, he's always hated young players &am
QUOTE (Marty34 @ Feb 8, 2014 -> 05:13 PM) Yes, like they are to be credited for putting off the rebuild. Because fans like you hold grudges for decades.
-
ARod suspended for entire 2014 season
At this point he probably just gave away getting his contract voided, unless there was a backroom deal we don't know about.
-
The Next Wave - White Sox prospects to watch outside the T25
QUOTE (floridafan @ Feb 8, 2014 -> 11:48 AM) He was on the on deck circle and took a hard line drive, that would have the distance for a home run, in a very painful area without the aid of a cup. Required surgery to remove a body part that was the size of a grape fruit. The rest of the team began wearing cups after that, even the Catcher, lol! Yikes. Hopefully things are better for him!