southsider2k5
Admin
-
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Currently
Viewing Topic: White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal
Everything posted by southsider2k5
-
Financial News
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:43 AM) I have yet to talk to anyone who has had something like this come out profitable on a scale like this. It is also worth pointing out that regulatory oversight is not done internally, at least in the US. ROC's have to be filled with people who are not employed by the firm, and they have a fiduciary duty to catch this stuff. If they intentionally ignored something like this, they would go to jail too.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:40 AM) ..so if they never face problems if they turn a blind eye to these trades that eventually wind up positive after enough bets, how do you get to this: Or are you saying that what this guy did never ends up profitable? I have yet to talk to anyone who has had something like this come out profitable on a scale like this.
-
Cooper and/or Ozzie status could affect MB coming back next year
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:16 AM) Ozzie Guillen was the one who put Rob ****ing Mackowiak and Darin Erstad in as his CF starters!!!! He is also the one who kept running Jenks out there...
-
Financial News
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:18 AM) This was "discovered" because the trader came forward. How many times have banks faced problems from similar actions that eventually wound up profitable? Talking to my boss who has been doing this for 25 years, never.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:17 AM) I'm still lost here, since to me, post 3 in this list sounds like it completely contradicts posts 1 and 2. In the first couple of posts I am saying that you really don't need to make up fake hedges to cover winners. In the third post I am saying if you did, you would be in just as much trouble as if you faked winners or losers.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:14 AM) I'm phrasing these all as questions because I simply do not know how this functions and you guys do. But how do we know that "rogue" traders haven't made similar moves and netted billions in profits in the past? Because from a regulatory standpoint, they would have been just as in trouble as if they lost billions. It still would have been front page news, and it would have created more rules because of it.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:12 AM) You can't be serious with this. Again, paranoia not connected to reality. UBS already makes money, and takes risks. If they wanted a trader to take a $2B risk, then they would have DONE THAT. No need for the illegal covers, just make the bet - if they actually thought the way you think they do (which they don't, but I am playing along). And we are seeing the downside for UBS. How can you say there is no downside? They just lost $2B, in addition to who knows what sort of fines, levies, job losses, reputation, etc. Exactly. It just proves that this stuff does have consequence.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:10 AM) And it worked so well when it happened to Lehman Brothers. Come on man. I have a right to be skeptical on this one. You can feed whatever agenda you want, it doesn't mean it is right. A company in this day an age is not going to be stupid enough to systematically risk their existence for one trader. That doesn't even make any sense.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:08 AM) I know I said I give...but come on man...I'm really supposed to expect that the governments out there will allow UBS to "go under"? If the losses get to the point where they affect capital reserves and legal status? It has happened before.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:07 AM) You hide the losses long enough until you turn that profit. Those things end up coming out in the wash. Even if it isn't immediate. It still gets everyone fired and the bank in assloads of regulatory problems.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:06 AM) And as long as that pays off eventually for enough traders, what incentive does UBS have to actually stopping this practice? If it goes to s***, they'll just throw the trader under the bus. This is assuming that this sort of gambling pays off more often than not, which may not be the case. Lets say this guy had accumulated $2B in losses but hit it big in his next trade, resulting in a net gain for the bank. Where's the downside for UBS? Because the entire company can go under, aka Bearings Bank or Refco?
-
Financial News
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:03 AM) don't you "hedge your bets" at the time you make your bet? That doesn't sound at all like what happened here, nor what type of business these guy was in.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:01 AM) Ok, either I'm totally lost in the the language or there's some time travel involved here. I give. Very simply, you don't have to "hide" a profit. Why would you?
-
Financial News
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:00 AM) There are limits on how much you can leverage yourself, no? Isn't the issue that these "rogue" traders leveraged themselves too much and their bet at the casino didn't pay off? Partially. The problem is that when their first bet doesn't pay off, they make a second larger bet, that covers the first one. Then when the second one doesn't pay off, they make a third larger one. In these cases, he was showing that his losses from the first bets didn't exist, because he had already sold and "covered" those losses. Because he didn't have any negatives, he was allowed to keep going.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 10:00 AM) But how do you know something is going to be a massive winner when you make the initial trade? The hedges came after the losses. Otherwise there was no point to making the trades.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 09:56 AM) ...so wouldn't UBS be incentivized to turn a blind eye to this type of behavior, as long as enough "unauthorized" trades wind up on the plus side? Very clearly what I am trying to say is that you don't need "unauthorized" trades against winning positions. You cover losing trades because there is the risk of losing money.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 09:55 AM) But 2k5 just said "if he is making money, no illegal covers ever take place." Can the 2 of you square these statements? I don't think you understand the terminology here. There is no sale of securities needed if they are up a sizable amount. They don't have the need to make up illegal trades to "hedge" something that is a massive winner. That's doesn't really make sense.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 09:53 AM) If they were UBS to UBS, as a self-clearing entity, I don't think that exactly works either. If they are exchange-traded, then either the trades have to hit the tape (so there is still clearing data), or it is a bulk transfer (in which case it isn't a trade at all, and someone who is supposed to actually hold the security would have to notice). If it is OTC internal, then again, it isn't possible for UBS to take a realized $2B loss on it anyway, as it is just an internal transfer of already-held assets. And an ETF is still real in the sense that a trade on said exchange still hits the tape. Dark or grey pools are broker-checked for clearing purposes, and I suspect that may be the culprit here - if he had help on the other/broker side. If he didn't, then someone had to be either actively ignoring or intentionally manipulating data to make the process appear whole for these fake trades. The latter is just not the case. Has to be some version of one of the former, combined probably with intentional manipulation of some kind. I have no doubt he had help. If he didn't, he had access to an incredible amount of different sectors of the company, which i can't see being true.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 09:52 AM) So...if the guy makes highly risky trades, logs somewhere in the system that he's hedged against possible losses from those trades, doesn't actually hedge against those losses, but then reaps big wins on the highly risky trades, it's no problem? The scenario isn't really likely to happen, but yes, people would hear about it. I know I would.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 09:53 AM) maybe "outside the bounds of institutional controls" would be better. If this guy made $2B making unauthorized trades, would we ever hear about it? Like I said earlier, if he is making money, no illegal covers ever take place.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 09:51 AM) Of course, my personal reaction to that statement would be..."that tells me that either the regulations aren't strong enough to prevent that from happening, the regulations are strong enough but they're systematically not enforced, or they are enforced but the bank as a whole deliberately turns a blind eye to systematic violations." Honestly, I have no idea what the English and Swiss regulatory systems look like.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 09:48 AM) That's my point...if there are guys conducting trades that should be illegal, but they wind up making a profit and the bank turns a blind eye... Your assumption is wrong. If they are winning trades, they don't need to make up stuff to cover them, and an illegal act is never committed.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 09:47 AM) So the 2 possibilities here are that one of the world's biggest banks is "Institutionally stupid"/"Severely lacking", or sadistic/gambling addicted in a way that you find hard to believe. The most realistic scenario is that this guy and a few people in the right places broke a bunch of laws, while the company put too much trust in the fact that these few people wouldn't get together to manipulate the system.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 09:40 AM) Anyone want to step up to the plate and tell me why this isn't deliberate? The guy just took a Two Billion Dollar Loss. The idea is to prevent just that. If the guy was winning, the controls wouldn't matter.
-
Financial News
QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Sep 19, 2011 -> 09:38 AM) I agree. And this doesn't appear to be similar to SocGen either, in that it does not have a very important "feature" of SocGen... specifically, that trader had worked in the back office before, and was able to access and manipulate the BO data directly (or through cohorts), distoring how the trades and positions appeared. No mention of that in the UBS case, and without that, it is really hard to imagine how it was done. I mean, if the trades were fictitious, why was there no clearing side reconciled? If they were exchange-traded instruments, the data from the clearing house(s) would have shown breaks, which would have been immediately obvious. If they are OTC, then the broker data should have shown the trades, or again, shown breaks. The only way to make these look like real trades when they weren't, is either he had help (on the broker, clearing house or back office operations sides), or he manipulated data that he should never have had direct access to. Either way, the internal checks and balances at UBS must have been severely lacking for this to occur. I'm trying to figure it out myself. I am guessing that these were UBS to UBS, who clears their own trades. So there isn't any outside trades missing. The only thing I can guess is that the guy was making up these products at the underwriting level, because ETF's aren't a "real" security. Especially if he found stuff that UBS That was underwriting themselves, that way if they are showing them as being there, they don't know any different? I don't know. I am still trying to wrap my head around it. The one thing I am sure of is that he couldn't have done this alone. If he could, that means he had access to WAY too many different departments, which defeats every single control mechanism there is. Chinese Wall stuff alone should tell you that no person should have access to that many levels at that stage of management.