ESPNews is reporting that the holdup to the trade is that the Orioles want Zambrano instead of Prior but the Cubs won't do that. This stuff is getting hilarious.
Considering the fact that Furcal gave the Cubs every opportunity to match the Dodgers' offer and they didn't, but are now looking to trade Prior for another shortstop makes them look really, really stupid. They should have just ponied up the cash for Furcal. Afterall, they have the money available. And they wouldn't even need to be thinking about trading Prior right now.
Tejada has 4 years and $54 million left on his contract. He can also demand a trade one year after being traded.
Mark Prior & Rafael Furcal (even at what the Dodgers signed him for) > Erik Bedard & Miguel Tejada
The Cubs would have also won more games with Prior and Furcal than with Bedard and Tejada.
I know. I'm just surprised that they would want to add Willie.
Mark Loretta
Tony Graffanino
Alex Cora
They seem to have more than enough guys who can play 2B. They need a good SS.
Haha. Your sources were interesting. The second one sounds like a rumor someone from an MLB.com message board would make up though. But it's interesting that the White Sox offered Garland for Bedard. Would he have been in our bullpen?
Well, Jacque Jones can play all 3 outfield positions, is a better hitter than Encarnacion, and signed for 3-years, $16 million. That's a better deal than Encarnacion for 3-years, $15 million even though both signings are really bad, IMO.
He could just as easily have a bad season. Look at the various inconsistent seasons he has put up.
http://mlb.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/mlb/stats/ml...3845&statType=1
Encarnacion's career #'s
.268 AVG
.316 OPS
.440 SLG
.756 OPS
A .756 career OPS from a starting right fielder is pretty bad and that's where the Cardinals will be playing him. Last year was the best season of his career (.796 OPS). He isn't a good option as a starting right fielder and the fact that he will be earning $15 million over 3 years makes it even worse.
Fluke injuries like getting run over by Marcus Giles or getting hit by a line drive don't make you injury-prone. Kerry Wood is injury-prone. But I guess you could argue that Prior's unwillingness to pitch through pain does.
And you also have to question whether or not Tejada was on roids. Will he continue to produce like he did in the past before the harsher steroid testing was instituted?
You don't trade a 25 year old pitcher with ace potential for a shortstop with a .815 career OPS and who has never even put up a .900 OPS in his career. And Bedard is good but he isn't great. Jerome Williams could match his numbers in 2006.
Think about Prior pitching under Leo Mazzone for a second...
My point exactly. They would have been better off giving Furcal the money he wanted and keeping Prior.
Pierre
Furcal
Lee
Ramirez
Jones
Walker
Murton
Barrett
Prior and Furcal would have won the Cubs more games than Bedard and Tejada.