And now, the outcome.
The five beers that Mrs. Flaxx graciously set up for a blind tasting:
• Hoegarden
• Witte (Ommegang)
• Allagash White
• Avery White Rascal
• Unibroeu Chambly
Coming in at number 5. . . Surprisingly, Witte. Just had nowhere near the complexity of any of the other wits on the table. Looked good in the glass, but the nose and flavor knocked this one out in the first pass. And I really was surprised that I didn't think better of this one when the Mrs. revealed the identity of the beer.
Number 4. . . Unibroue Chambly. I was honestly surprised I couldn't 100% spot the Unibroue beer in the mix on first tasting. In my mind's memory I had a lot more left-field stuff going on in this beer that wasn't evident in the blind tasting. Obviously, I'm projecting all the 9% Unibroue beers onto this moderate 5% offering. Not saying Chambly isn't a nice beer, jsut didn't make the final table.
Number 3 – Genuinely shocked that it's my near and dear Alagash. I assumed Hoegarden might edge it out, but I didn't anticipate I'd rate another domestic interpretation higher,
Two-Way Tie for top spot. . . Hoegaden (no real surprise) and . . . Avery White Rascal. Wow. I think I noted here before that one of my favorite beer cafes features White Rascal on tap, and it's typically the beer I'll start a session with there (typically ending with Old Rasputin and hitting random points in between). But, as much as I liked teh Rascal, I assumed in a side-by-side comparison Allagash would have scored well above this. In terms of fresh flavor POP, I have to give the night to White Rascal. In terms of the totality of flavor complexity and style nuances going on, it's Hoegarden, but Pierre's baby really did lose out in terms of peak fresh beer explosiveness,
And there it is. Not a beer in the bunch I would hesiate to order if I found it in a menu, But I'll move forward with a higher opinion of Averys' white which I've enjoyed for quite a while but did not think could hold its gtound against the other heavy hitters.
Maybe the real lesson is that I should not be surprised that Avery is turning out a top notch wit, given the fact that the more I drink their beers the more I like them.