QUOTE(BearSox @ Mar 30, 2008 -> 10:24 AM)
It surprises me to see how many people think Thome should be benched vs. lefties... maybe once in a while, but Thome is NOT a platoon player. Sure, he's better vs. righties, but he has one of the best eye's in the league, can draw walks, and at any moment, vs. any pitcher, he can go yard. And you don't bench especially when he is getting hot, as evident of his 4 or 5(?) homers and 10+ rbi's in the least week and a half of spring training games.
But, he shouldn't bat 3rd vs. lefties. Swisher should bat 3rd with Thome 5th...
Here are the FACTS re. Thome vs. LHP his last 3 full, healthy seasons.
'04 .239/.324/.479 OPS .803 in 213 PA
'06 .236/.354/.361 OPS .715 in 229 PA
'07 .196/.314/.350 OPS .663 in 169 PA
I'm a Thome fan, but the reality is he's PATHETIC against LHP and GETTING WORSE. And his playing against lefties hurts the team. The Sox have many alternatives to Thome this year.