What do you think would happen? A lot of people seem to think it would be hard for TCQ to be DH. I think he would be just fine though, and it would probably improve our defense.

I'm pretty confident in choice #3. Although if we invested properly in straight jackets and orderlies, the damage could be minimized.

 

Seriously, though, I do think his offense would suffer somewhat. If Ozzie put him at DH, I wouldn't complain too loudly or anything, though, because really I don't have the expertise nor the inside knowledge to say anything firmly about Q's psychology.

Carlos would be Carlos. A guy who takes failure hard whether he's playing the field or not. Regardless, he'd continue to hit the s*** out of the ball, and that's all that matters.

What do you think would happen? A lot of people seem to think it would be hard for TCQ to be DH. I think he would be just fine though, and it would probably improve our defense.

 

They could move AJ to the outfield.

They could move AJ to the outfield.

"AJ's in the Outfield" sounds like a solid movie to me.

He will commit suicide at the idea, but before that, he will go on a huge massacre, killing 15, all of which are on the team, including Juan Pierre, Mark Kotsay, and everybody that sucks.

 

Then after this, he will commit suicide.

 

At least this is what some say will happen if he is ever DH'd for more than one game.

Edited April 12, 201015 yr by chw42

He will be fine. Our best defense (and best protection of Q's health) is with him at DH. Jones in CF, Rios in RF, and Pierre in LF with Q DHing is better defense, and a better hitting lineup than one with Kotsay in it.

Nobody knows and that's the problem. His offense is too damn important to our team to f*** around with him. If someone can find me just one quote from a player saying they like to dh or that it helps their swing then I'll change my opinion but I guarantee you can't find one, cause they don't exist. He's not a liability in rf and until that happens he needs to remain out there.

Nobody knows and that's the problem. His offense is too damn important to our team to f*** around with him. If someone can find me just one quote from a player saying they like to dh or that it helps their swing then I'll change my opinion but I guarantee you can't find one, cause they don't exist. He's not a liability in rf and until that happens he needs to remain out there.

 

Jim Thome?