Everything posted by southsider2k5
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 04:57 PM) How can I be wrong? You are literally just quoting a pr piece and saying "The NBPA is honest and they have no incentive to lie" Give me a break, at least be honest that we dont know their true motivation. Common sense here. If it didn't matter, they would have given it away totally in exchange for something else.
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 04:54 PM) I could be wrong there is certainly that possibility as Im not affiliated with the NBPA. But (imo) this is just a negotiating ploy. Where you argue for something you dont really care about so you can exchange it for something you do want. This happens all the time, so Im assuming that is what the NBPA is doing. But you are right, its just an assumption. You are wrong. It was a major issue in the last bargaining. http://sports.espn.go.com/nba/news/story?id=5899152
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 04:48 PM) This didn't happen prior to the age restriction. Because they didn't want to miss out on players and/or get sued if they all did it. Instead the NBA's product was seriously harmed.
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 04:50 PM) Right they are smart at negotiating. I fight for things my clients dont really care about all the time (well call them X), if it means I can say "oh ill give you X if you give me Y" You dont give away a negotiating chip for free, even if you dont care about it. Thats just dumb. (edit) Ill use a quick example, divorce which is something most are familiar with. Husband loves dog more than anything Wife hates dog. Wife says she wants dog and that she is going to fight for it. Husband offers money if wife gives up dog. Wife gives up dog. The example is irrelevant. In practice the NBAPA is fighting this. What you make up doesn't really matter.
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 04:47 PM) No its because they are worried if they make a rule that is to prohibitive a court will overturn it and then they lose everything. NBPA has no incentive to lower the age, its a good bargaining chip that they dont care about. But they are fighting it. You are completely wrong here. The logic states one thing, but in practice the complete opposite is true.
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 04:23 PM) Because there is an inherent conflict of interest between the NBPA and players not currently in the NBA. The NBPA has very little reason or incentive to look out for non-NBA players. So if they can bargain more for current NBA players at the expense of future NBA players, they take that all the time. This is why the 1 year rule is fundamentally flawed. The NBPA has no reason to fight it, especially if the NBA says "If you fight the 1 year rule we are going to lower salary cap and hurt players already in the NBA." But they did.
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 02:49 PM) Are NBA GM's so bad that they need a hard rule to prevent them from being bad at their jobs and prevent the occasional pro-ready HS grad from playing, though? Yet if all 29 NBA GMs decided not to draft an 18 year old at the same time, they would get sued for collusion, even if they were all acting in their individual team best intersts.
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (ZoomSlowik @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 02:46 PM) Um, that's pretty much what they did. Do you think David Stern just randomly pulled this out of his ass at the negotiating table? The owners, which make up the league, wanted it. Really if it were up to the NBA alone, they would have a three or four year rule. The only reason it takes this watered down form is because of the NBA players forcing it lower.
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 02:30 PM) The value of their scholarship does not come near to the value they generate for the team or the value of the external contracts they're forbidden from signing. Nor do most people generate income comiserate to the value they generate for their company. But the other side of it is that it isn't their capital at risk. If the NBA fails the only thing the players lose is future salary.
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 02:27 PM) Ok, so what else do we need to know to determine if schools could afford to compensate athletes? They are getting a free education. Even at face value that is a lot of money.
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 02:23 PM) Well, if your business model is reliant on the bulk of your labor force going unpaid (and, on top of that, actively forbidding them from getting outside revenue streams), something's inherently flawed. If you could show me that there's a net benefit for NCAA colleges on the academic side (don't a lot of athletics programs lose money?), that would be a point in the NCAA's favor. But you'd still need to explain why you would lose that benefit if student-athletes were compensated. The kids are getting a 20k or more a year free education. Would it be different if they paid them $25,000 a year and then charged them full price for their education?
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 02:15 PM) You're missing the part where someone in the NBA still has to decide to draft and pay that 15 year old. I still haven't heard a good reason why the NBA has to allow complete chaos in their draft process.
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 02:14 PM) Revenue means how much the team brings in. If some of that revenue is diverted towards student-athletes, then it comes from somewhere else. Maybe the seven-figure salaries of the coaches and administrators. Or do you want to cry poor on behalf of the NCAA colleges now and tell me that, despite being a multi-billion dollar entity, they couldn't possible afford to actually pay the athletes? I'm telling you revenue by itself is a meaningless number, much like net worth.
-
Marlins trade Buehrle, Josh Johnson, Reyes plus others to Blue Jays
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 02:06 PM) Well yeah...he did get a team offering him 4/$60 on the open market. That wasn't happening in extension talks either. He wouldn't have know that was out there either.
-
2012-2013 MLB off season tracker thread
Jon Morosi @jonmorosi Rockies acquire Reid Brignac from Rays for cash considerations and a player to be named later.
-
2013 Spring Training catch all thread
Random factoid of the day Baseball Reference @baseball_ref Konerko has the most games in any one park of all AL players.
-
2013 Spring Training catch all thread
Meghan Montemurro @M_Montemurro Cooper on Danks: "If you lined up 10 pitchers on the mounds out there & said pick out the guy who had surgery, you couldn't have did it." Daryl Van Schouwen @CST_soxvan Cooper: Longer spring will benefit Danks. Most pleased with Danks' changeup. Dan Hayes @DanHayesCSN Don Cooper described it as a "really good day 4 John (Danks)." Tyler Flowers impressed by curveball, change & cutter. Said velo down a bit. Daryl Van Schouwen @CST_soxvan Flowers, who caught Danks, said the lefty's curve was better than he's ever seen. Changeup good. Velocity down a little, which was expected
-
Marlins trade Buehrle, Josh Johnson, Reyes plus others to Blue Jays
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 02:04 PM) Didn't he specifically tell them he wanted to test free agency? They had him locked up for years before free agency. There was plenty of time for extension talks. Again, this was a way to let Mark walk away, and have it be Mark's fault, not the White Sox.
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 01:17 PM) And the other part that is being lost, is that its more about having a legitimate justification. At least in the NFL they are saying its for the safety of the players, most of those guys are staying in college 3+ years. That is a legitimate time commitment. That being said, I do think there should be at minimum some sort of insurance for college athletes in case of injury. That isnt just exclusive basketball or football. The protection of the overall product and business is a legitimate justification. There is no reason the NBA should have to suffer just because a 15 year old wants to strike it rich.
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 01:41 PM) http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2009/03/is-ncaa-evil.html There's plenty of revenue to go around. Revenue is a garbage number. It means nothing. You might as well use net worth
-
Marlins trade Buehrle, Josh Johnson, Reyes plus others to Blue Jays
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 01:17 PM) When Mark came back to the Sox and said that their offer was $60 million, there was nothing the Sox were going to be able to offer that was worth $24 million. If Mark had come back and said "I have an enormous offer from Florida but I would be willing to go for a much smaller deal in exchange for no-trade protection, which I already have in Chicago", the Sox would have jumped right back. That $24 million was worth more than no trade protection. If they really wanted him, they would have made him an offer before free agency, like they did with Jake Peavy.
-
Ventura declines extension
QUOTE (flavum @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 12:07 PM) It's kind of a nothing story, but truthfully I'd rather have a manager that really aspired to be a manager after his playing career. This is rebuilding without saying it, so they'll put a decent team on the field and a likable manager in the dugout and in front of the microphones, and try to get the farm system rebuilt on the fly without doing a complete tear down, because economically the Sox can't afford to do it. Ventura is likable? I wouldn't say that at all. Especially with all the complaints about how boring he is.
-
2012-2013 NCAA Basketball thread
Somebody is getting fired for Valentines Day...
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 12:47 PM) I don't really know that I matured all that much during my freshman year, certainly not enough to matter if I was suddenly going to be handed $10M+ at 18 instead of 19. I was 18 at the start of my sophomore year, too, so I would have been forced to play two years of college basketball. No. One year past high school is the rule.
-
NBA/NFL age limits
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Feb 14, 2013 -> 12:42 PM) Nah, how about we cut the people generating all of that money in on the revenue stream? Why should the coaches and administration and everyone else involved who isn't an athlete get access to all of that money, but the people actually playing the games shouldn't? Then go to the D league or Europe.