Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

southsider2k5

Admin

Everything posted by southsider2k5

  1. QUOTE (Harry Chappas @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 03:26 PM) kaner is no genius Good point. If he had a big boobed blonde with bottles of alcohol talking for the other side, he might be there forever.
  2. QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 03:16 PM) Oney Guillen ‏@Oneyguillen oh well
  3. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 03:12 PM) Can you expand on this? As I have said a million times, there still won't be equal weight to votes for many reasons. Go back and read the thread.
  4. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 03:11 PM) Will a Republican living in Illinois have a meaningful vote in this year's Presidential election? Would they in a national election system? Would a fiscal conservative and social liberal have a voice in the one vote system? No. So what changes for them? In your world view, their vote has no meaning.
  5. And laughing all of the way to the bank...
  6. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 03:08 PM) It will change to "where actual people actually vote because they're people." Your vote will have the exact same impact regardless of where you live. That more people live in urban areas than rural areas is a tautology and doesn't change the actual impact of your individual vote. If your actual vote isn't for a majority population theory, then yes, your impact would be just at muted.
  7. QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 03:06 PM) How people are "distributed" is irrelevant for a single, national office. The best and only way to give every person the same rights and same weight is to have one vote equal one vote. All the other arguments about urban vs rural, etc., are just political plays. In theory, sure. In reality, never.
  8. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 02:59 PM) That boundary will change from state to nation. That's an important distinction for a national office. What actual benefit does the EC provide here? Rural states are still mostly ignored because they're solidly Republican. Rural areas in strongly-democratic states are largely ignored because it doesn't matter if you get 49.9% and your opponent gets 50.1%, they win every EC vote. Urban areas in strongly-Republican states are ignored for the same reason. Focus is instead given to states that just happen to have a close split politically in this particular race. It will change from state to region/urban area. It won't be "national" because we do not have a uniform population distribution.
  9. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 02:53 PM) A handful, but it shows that the underpinnings of the system are rotten. You aren't voting for Obama or Romney, you're voting for designated electors who may or may not follow your preference. How does that make any sense? It shows the system has flaws, not that the system is rotten. If the system saw wholesale changes of votes that legitimately didn't represent what people voted for, then we could talk. It also ignores that a true one vote system without any built in protections would have its flaws as well. It wouldn't mean the whole system was "rotten". In the last 20 (1992-2008, or five elections) years exactly one electoral college vote wasn't cast for the person it was supposed to be cast for. That is one out of 2675 votes. As far as I can tell 156 votes have been changed in the entire history of the electoral college. 30 of them were because of a Vice President, which is no longer separately contested as it used to be. Since 1900 all of 16 votes have been unfaithfully cast.
  10. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 02:43 PM) That's not really analogous to what I said. Why should individual Ohio voters (in both rural and urban areas) have the power of being in what's most likely to be the deciding state while rural voters in Illinois will essentially have no voice? edit: It's also not a "select group" but a "majority of the citizens of the country" who, generally speaking, choose where they want to live. I can decide if I want to live in Chicago or Strawn and which issues I care about regardless of where I live. What I can't do is choose that my state is close enough that my vote will have any meaningful impact on the race. On one hand you equate the ability to vote how you want, but because most of the state has a specific opinion that doesn't change it somehow negates that voice. That won't change if you get rid of the electoral college. Blocks of people will still hold over-representation based on certain specialized demographics. Just the boundaries of how those inequities get expressed will change.
  11. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 02:38 PM) How will geography be playing a part? Your vote will be exactly as impactful regardless of where you live, unlike now. Rural Illinoisians essentially have no say in how the states' EC votes will go*. *EC voters aren't bound to their states' votes anyway, which is a whole separate problem with the EC. How many times in history has this actually happened? It isn't even worth mentioning honestly.
  12. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 02:28 PM) Only if we're concerned about chunks of land or "settings" getting representation and not actual citizens. How much would Romney really campaign in NYC, anyway? Except that there isn't an even distribution of people of actual citizens across the country, so geography is going to be playing a part.
  13. QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 02:25 PM) Not in the slightest - one vote means no one cares about the land, or the where. I will be choosing individuals over groups - which I thought was a core principle of the Republican Party. One vote means areas of higher population concentration get more representation. Ohio gets traded in for NYC.
  14. QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 02:19 PM) Well yeah, Congress is intended to be a representative body - of both individuals, and states, in a federation. And the President is to represent everyone, not just highly populated areas.
  15. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 02:12 PM) It would change it in a manner such that every single vote has exactly equal impact instead of the situation we have now. "Urban settings" would be over-represented only in the sense that that's where most people actually live. Plus, I don't even know how true the charge that they'd focus on big cities even holds. Would they really spend significant time campaigning in LA, NY or Chicago? Don't they focus on the urban areas in swing states (which change election-by-election and don't necessarily represent any particular setting) already? In that sense, urban areas are already have their higher impact by having the lions share of the electoral college votes going to the polls for them.
  16. QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 02:16 PM) I don't at all understand the idea of choosing land over people when it comes to voting. One person, one vote - when you are talking about the Presidency, which is a national office. Anything else you do is disenfranchising people. You'll just be choosing different patches of land to over represent.
  17. QUOTE (Steve9347 @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 02:15 PM) Unless they have Forrest Gump as their agent, there will be an out clause. Some NBA players goofed that up last year. Not to mention some NBA players are pretty damned dumb.
  18. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 01:49 PM) They are, but there are a lot less of them. It's more a response to caring "only" about the coasts and not the vast, mostly-empty spaces in between. Well, in an election for a national office, shouldn't we care about citizens and not where they happen to live? Plus the EC doesn't actually tie our votes to anything. It's an antiquated 18th century aristocratic relic. A true "one vote" system would just lead to an over-representation of the people living in urban settings. Instead of caring mostly about people in one specific setting, it would be traded for another. It wouldn't really fix anything, it would just change the "chosen" people.
  19. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 01:43 PM) So wouldn't it be better for them to concentrate on actual US citizens instead of arbitrary boundaries? Why shouldn't they campaign for the tens of millions of Californians, Illinoisans and New Yorkers? People in swing states aren't actual citizens?
  20. QUOTE (bmags @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 01:37 PM) They also started out with chattel slavery. If these places have a voice in congress, then they are being heard. They could make their own farmers party that sells their votes to whoever gives them the most goodies to their areas. Just because something is done some way doesn't mean it's the best way of doing things. Just having a vote isn't always being heard. If so, why do we need anti-discrimination laws? After all they could just make their own (insert minority group here) party.
  21. QUOTE (bmags @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 01:17 PM) Do we need to overrepresent rural areas in every branch of government? Historically, it is how we have done business.
  22. QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 01:16 PM) No... instead of 80% of the country's votes being meaningless, each one has the same value. For the purpose of POTUS, I don't care if somoene lives in a city or a suburb or on a farm, nor do I can what state they live in. Not at all. In this scenario there is no need to contest lower populated areas. The payoff isn't worth it. Just like today campaigning in California isn't worth it.
  23. QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 12:59 PM) He did fall off after that. Which is not the same as being sharp decline. Now, if you want to say you are worried about his health as he goes forward, that makes sense. But when healthy, he has no problem whatsoever catching up to strong fastballs. I was agreeing with you, if not very clearly.
  24. QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 01:09 PM) Yes, in theory that is true, you are right. I just worry that the already sue-happy culture in the US will continue to attempt to chink the armor, and eventually may find a weakness somewhere. Perhaps I'm just being paranoid. Unless the government is willing to intentionally weaken its own powerbase (L-freaking-O-L) it isn't going to happen.
  25. QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Oct 23, 2012 -> 01:07 PM) Congress is a representative body. One chamber is purely population-based, the other is state-based. That works as well now as it did then, model-wise. A President is not representative, because he/she cannot be. It is one person. Well, two, if you include the VP. Your statement that you disenfranchise another sector of the country is entirely unfounded in reality. One vote equals one vote - that is the ONLY way to give equal power to each INDIVIDUAL, regardless of where they live in the country. Also, this idea that the electoral college was set in place to help protect rural areas simply isn't true. There was no significant imbalance of that kind when the Constitutional text regarding this was set up, and then amended for. It was set up for multiple reasons, primarily that they wanted representatives to vote for the President because they didn't trust the individuals in the country to be able to do so. There were also simple logistical reasons why it wouldn't have worked well. One thing you argue that IS true, is that it was there to protect small states from large ones - but remember, this was done at the time that there were 13 colonies, and they were trying to build consensus for the Constitution itself by giving those privileges to smaller states, in order to get buy-in. Simply put, none of these factors are in play now. It no longer makes sense as a model, and should be thrown out. Unfortunately, to do so requires a Constitutional amendment, and that ain't happenin'. Instead of swing states, the election will be concentrated in higher populated areas.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.