Everything posted by southsider2k5
-
Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 09:30 AM) Because it's very convenient to hide behind the law if no one points out that the law itself is racist. That can be done, without using racist terminology.
-
Happy Birthday SnB!
- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 09:02 AM) So I can't go back and find 15 posts saying that the current 10 million+ illegal immigrants who are here are breaking the law? No one else here is using racism as a motivator.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 09:04 AM) Don't we offer political assylum separate from our immigration quota system now? And how does this address the millions of Mexicans, Guatemalans, Hondurans, Costa Ricans, etc. who will want to come here to escape poverty, would prefer to do so legally but will do so illegally if there is no other choice, literally risking life and limb in many cases to do so? How is this much different from arguments that were used in favor of excluding southern and eastern Europeans that claimed they were poor, sickly, unskilled and unable to adapt or contribute to American society? There are going to be choices in any system. We literally can't support the world.- Roger Clemens indicted for perjury, obstruction
QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 09:08 AM) I dont agree with this. There have been stories of players in the 60s-70s-80s using greenies and amphetimines and all kinds of crap to get an edge. Hell, the Doc Gooden mets was one big 8 ball. Clemens and Bonds probably both will get in, I dont like it, but they will Steroids is a whole different ballgame than uppers. They are being treated totally differently.- 2012 White Sox draft picks
http://www.southsidesox.com/2012/6/19/3096...-spending-trend- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 08:55 AM) It's much easier to insist "They're breaking the law, we can't support that!" when you don't have to confront the racist past and present of the law. Except no one here is doing that, but OK.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 08:53 AM) Right, that's exactly what those laws did when they establish quotas. They used racist and inflammatory terminology to degrade and dehumanize immigrant groups. I'm glad we can all agree on that. So if I am talking about Jim Crow laws, I can just drop the N-bomb because someone did 150 years ago? Uh, ok.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 08:52 AM) So you don't really have any solution at all to address the millions already here or the millions who will want to come in the future. Just a tweaking of the quota system to let in less poors from latin america legally, which seems to me would only exacerbate the problem. Its a system that matches people to needs in this country. It is also a system that benefits the people who need it the most in the world. It gets rid of the geographic and de facto religious protections built into the system that rewards you today for "being here". In a system where you are going to have to make choices about who you let immigrate, I'd rather save the victims of a genocide or war first. For example, I'd rather save people fleeing from their government bombing them in Syria, versus someone just trying to make a bit more money from anywhere else. The system would be flexible in that it would be easy to adjust to changes in geo-political changes around the world as they happen. It would also aid immigrants as they would be coming over with skills in demand in the US, which would aid their transition into economic stability here.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 08:48 AM) It's a law with a racist foundation and he was pointing out the original and explicit reasoning behind those laws. By using racist and intentionally inflammatory terminology to do so.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 08:47 AM) So what do you do with the 10+ million here now? This has adverse affects on minority populations, legal or not. There are serious unintended consequences to consider. How does that actually address the problem of millions coming here illegally to escape poverty? No amnesty. The people who are here can decide what they want to do. The last one actually matches people to jobs. It keeps a control on the system as to not overburden it with people we can't support. Our social networks are already strained to the breaking point. That is reality.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 08:45 AM) And of course you object when the racist thread running through the current quota system gets pointed out, because then the heroic stand of "How dare they not follow the laws!" suddenly gets that nasty, dirty connection to defending where those laws came from. Did I miss someone else using yellow, or something similar, to describe immigrants?- Brent Morel rehabbing back in southern Cali
QUOTE (justBLAZE @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 08:17 AM) Is there anything wrong with US Cellular infield? I mean any other teams 3B have similar issues or just coincidence? Kevin Youkilis is having the same problems I believe.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 08:38 AM) The quota system you're defending exists solely because of race. The reason why we have quotas on immigration that are too low to satisfy demand for immigrants in the first place is race. At least I got you to notice it. Of course I noticed you throwing around racist terminology. It seems to be a favorite tactic.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 08:37 AM) He's describing what those laws were and why they were enacted. They were racist laws to keep out undesirables. And using racist terminology to do so.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 08:31 AM) Amnesty is patching a hole left by unworkable laws. Amnesty without reform is a bad idea. Deportation without reform is a dumb, expensive, unrealistic idea. History bears both of those statements out. -The first law passed needs to be that any caught in the country willfully illegally (or aiding someone to do so) is barred from ever becoming a citizen. -The second is massive fines for hiring illegal labor. -The third is to get rid of all nationality quota, and replace it with a system based on needs of families to escape hardships (things like war and genocide would get preferencial treatment vs things like poverty) and have them matched to industries and companies looking for specific skill sets in employees. Instead of playing this game of waiting out the next amnesty period, you bring people to the country who actually have the greatest needs, and you provide them with a much clearer path to becoming contributing members of society.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 08:34 AM) Carnegie immigrated to the U.S. when the U.S. immigration laws required: The first quota based immigration law didn't appear until the 1880's when the U.S. realized too many yellow Chinese people were coming in to the country and we had to do something about that. If he didn't already have family here, there's a decent chance Carnegie would have been unable to immigrate to the U.S. under current law, or if he did, he'd have a 10 year waiting period. I'm glad you get to throw around racist terms. It really helps the discussion.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jun 19, 2012 -> 08:31 AM) And it's been 25 years since the last major amnesty, which is why the laws are working great right now. Exactly. The system we have no is a disaster, and an amnesty program will only reinforce the next wave to anchor away.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Jun 18, 2012 -> 11:30 PM) Because Ill be making more money, just like most other Americans when the new immigrants create middle level opportunities for American citizens, so the govt will get more money from me to pay for them. Also some of these immigrants will become rich and pay far more than their fair sure. Its a lot better than an illegal immigrant making money in the US to send back to his family in Mexico, instead of spending that money in the US. Well except those in low income areas who will be directly competing for blue collar work and see their wages plummet as they get undercut by those willing to work cheaper.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (BigSqwert @ Jun 18, 2012 -> 11:23 PM) Mandating a portion of the populace to purchase health care is the equivalent to "free" in your eyes? It is when it is "paid for".- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (BigSqwert @ Jun 18, 2012 -> 10:57 PM) They won't come if there aren't jobs for them. Which is what has happened in the last few years.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Jun 18, 2012 -> 08:12 PM) Andrew Carnegie, immigrant. What makes you think that immigrants wont make up lower, middle and upper class. US history is filled with immigrant success stories. http://images.businessweek.com/ss/09/08/08...mmigrants/1.htm LEGAL immigrant. But nice spin to something irrelevant.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Jun 18, 2012 -> 04:38 PM) Not when you don't do anything to fix your broken system that led to the problem in the first place. My feeling has always been to remove all racial biases in immigration, including the inherently racist system we have now that favors just the groups that are geographically close, versus those who really need to immigrate to the US for actual life and death situations.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Jun 18, 2012 -> 04:11 PM) Man you are just killing your own argument. So if the law doesnt work and there is no incentive to follow the law, should you: A) Blindly keep believing the law will work. B) Change the law. You are exactly right there. There is no incentive to follow the law, which is the whole problem here. That is why you have to actually have a law that works. Amnesty is just making sure the laws don't work.- Obamanation Re-election MegaThread
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Jun 18, 2012 -> 04:00 PM) But they didnt change immigration, so its not comparable. You both have to offer amnesty and change immigration law, so once again, I ask you to show me where that has happened and failed, as you said I could read a history book and find it, so Im waiting. I really want that information because if you have it, it could change my entire argument. So once again, thanks in advance. How do I plan for paying for it? By collecting taxes from people that previously were getting benefits and not paying taxes. Right now they are in the US, getting services, costing money, and many of them pay $0. How would it be a bad thing if they are in the US, getting services, costing money and paying something? Amnesty would force some people who get benefits to actually pay something. If anything it should immediately reduce the debt. That is not even considering the cost of keeping people out, and the benefit of saving that money. I just got told that problem didn't exist. You guys probably should get your talking points straight. Also even if the other side is right, and there is a major tax deficit, most illegals aren't going to be working the types of jobs that make them taxpayers enough to cover the benefits they use over a life time. Do that times however many illegals there are here... not pretty. - Obamanation Re-election MegaThread