I think in the long scheme of things getz with be more valuable becuase of his versatility. Even if he's reduced to a bench role he'll be more valauable than fields because he's a left handed hitter coming off the bench that can play different positions. He has good speed, decent contact, and plays solid defense (at times). I'm just not sold on Fields at all right now. It's pathetic that he can get absolutely dominated by any pitcher that throws over 92mph, and with 3b being a power position thats unacceptable. Also, with that hitch in his swing the chances he hits for a high average isn't good either and throw in his shaky defense on top of that - i just don't see any reason to get excited about him right now.