July 1, 200520 yr 8-3 3.29 era . I say he has a shot. On top of that, with kenny rogers possibly not participating in the game, that will leave a pitcher slot open. Seems like Freddy got lost in the All-star game talk. With his last few starts being nothing short of dominant , I say he has a shot. Thoughts?
July 1, 200520 yr I think after his past month, he's very deserving of a spot. Getting one, however, is an entirely different matter.
July 1, 200520 yr Author How many pitchers go? anyway, here are my locks to go: Buehrle Garland Halladay colon clement guardado Rivera santana Players with a good shot IMO Cliff Lee Miguel Bautista BJ Ryan Chris young Freddy Garcia
July 1, 200520 yr Not going to have 3 guys on the same starting staff get into the game, not going to happen, and IMHO, It's better that way. <{POST_SNAPBACK}> Cleveland.
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(rangercal @ Jun 30, 2005 -> 09:38 PM) How many pitchers go? anyway, here are my locks to go: Buehrle Garland Halladay colon clement guardado Rivera santana Players with a good shot IMO Cliff Lee Miguel Bautista BJ Ryan Chris young Freddy Garcia wow, you didn't put cliff politte on there? prepare to meet your maker!
July 1, 200520 yr I guarantee someone with worse numbers than Garcia makes it. Edited July 1, 200520 yr by WHarris1
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(Tony82087 @ Jun 30, 2005 -> 09:29 PM) Not going to have 3 guys on the same starting staff get into the game, not going to happen, and IMHO, It's better that way. Normally I would agree, but we have a case where the team playing near .700 ball may very only have one position player in the game, and a reserve at that. The team deserves strong representation - somewhere. To be honest, though, I would rather have no Sox players in the all star game. This season holds far too much promise for anyone to be getting hurt in a "popularity contest". SFF
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(SpringfieldFan @ Jul 1, 2005 -> 03:35 AM) To be honest, though, I would rather have no Sox players in the all star game. This season holds far too much promise for anyone to be getting hurt in a "popularity contest". SFF yeah, but this popularity contest will determine whether there will be 3 or 4 World Series games at The Cell in November.
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(UofIChiSox @ Jun 30, 2005 -> 10:41 PM) yeah, but this popularity contest will determine whether there will be 3 or 4 World Series games at The Cell in November. IF they make it.
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(Dam8610 @ Jun 30, 2005 -> 10:14 PM) IF they make it. No ifs ands or buts about it
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(WHarris1 @ Jun 30, 2005 -> 08:02 PM) I guarantee someone with worse numbers than Garcia makes it. Of course someone will...there's got to be some team who's only All Star will be a pitcher. Tampa Bay, or K.C., or Detroit, or Cleveland, someone like that. Edited July 1, 200520 yr by Balta1701
July 1, 200520 yr Freddy's numbers warrant consideration but it won't happen. I'd love to see him there but as I've said for Mark and Jon I'd prefer they don't pitch.
July 1, 200520 yr Detroit could send White, Guillen, Young, or Bonderman (listed in order I'd take them) Cleveland will probably send Hafner, but could also send Cliff Lee (#s are close to Garcia's, but slightly worse) Tampa Bay should send Cantu Kansas City doesn't deserve an all-star, but the closest thing they have is Emil Brown.
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(Dam8610 @ Jul 1, 2005 -> 12:03 AM) Detroit could send White, Guillen, Young, or Bonderman (listed in order I'd take them) Cleveland will probably send Hafner, but could also send Cliff Lee (#s are close to Garcia's, but slightly worse) Tampa Bay should send Cantu Kansas City doesn't deserve an all-star, but the closest thing they have is Emil Brown. Umm. Detroit = I Rod.
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(Kalapse @ Jul 1, 2005 -> 12:05 AM) Umm. Detroit = I Rod. Not really. He's not having a great season, even by normal standards, plus the AL East will probably supply the two catchers.
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(Dam8610 @ Jul 1, 2005 -> 12:06 AM) Not really. He's not having a great season, even by normal standards, plus the AL East will probably supply the two catchers. I'm gauranteeing right now that IRod makes the AS game.
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(Kalapse @ Jul 1, 2005 -> 12:08 AM) I'm gauranteeing right now that IRod makes the AS game. I doubt it. The Yankee fans would scream bloody murder if I-Rod got in ahead of Posada, and I think Tek is winning the vote right now.
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(Dam8610 @ Jul 1, 2005 -> 12:14 AM) I doubt it. The Yankee fans would scream bloody murder if I-Rod got in ahead of Posada, and I think Tek is winning the vote right now. Who give a s*** what Yankee fans think? This isn't Joe Torre this is Terry Francona we're talking about. And besides. I believe the players would vote for IRod just based on his reputation around the league alone.
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(WHarris1 @ Jul 1, 2005 -> 12:17 AM) Posada>>>IRod this year Exactly. Add to that the fact that he's a Yankee, and it's pretty much a lock that he's going.
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(WHarris1 @ Jul 1, 2005 -> 12:17 AM) Posada>>>IRod this year I don't think that matters. Remember this is all IMO. I could be totally wrong (this would be the first time) I just think he gets in despite the numbers.
July 1, 200520 yr QUOTE(Kalapse @ Jul 1, 2005 -> 12:21 AM) I don't think that matters. Remember this is all IMO. I could be totally wrong (this would be the first time) I just think he gets in despite the numbers. Haha. Anyway - gotcha. But really the disparity in numbers is ridiculous and it would be a joke if IRod made it over Jorge.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.