June 12, 200916 yr I'd go with: Hanley Ramirez Evan Longoria Albert Pujols Ian Kinsler Joe Mauer Zack Greinke Roy Halladay Cole Hamels Tim Lincecum Dan Harden
June 12, 200916 yr QUOTE (whitesoxbrian @ Jun 12, 2009 -> 05:58 PM) I'd go with: Hanley Ramirez Evan Longoria Albert Pujols Ian Kinsler Joe Mauer Zack Greinke Roy Halladay Cole Hamels Tim Lincecum Dan Harden Replace Dan Haren with Santana and Mcab for Longoria. Edited June 12, 200916 yr by rangercal
June 12, 200916 yr Albert Pujols Evan Longoria Hanley Ramirez Chase Utley Ryan Braun Roy Halladay Johan Santana Tim Lincecum Brandon Webb CC Sabathia
June 12, 200916 yr QUOTE (whitesoxbrian @ Jun 12, 2009 -> 04:58 PM) I'd go with: Hanley Ramirez Evan Longoria Albert Pujols Ian Kinsler Joe Mauer Zack Greinke Roy Halladay Cole Hamels Tim Lincecum Dan Harden I'll assume you mean Dan Haren. I'd replace Haren with Doc Halladay. I'm not entirely sold on Greinke yet, so I'd go with Felix Hernandez over him (for the time being, until Greinke performs like he has over the course of a whole season). Edited June 12, 200916 yr by jenks45monster
June 12, 200916 yr I'm seeing waaaay too many national league players on those lists guys. We all know they can't compete in a real game (in the AL)
June 12, 200916 yr Hmmm... Now - 3 years C- McCann - Wieters 1B- Pujols - LaPorta 2B- Kinsler - Beckham SS- Hanley Ramirez - Hanley Ramirez 3B- Longoria - Longoria OF- Markakis - Markakis OF- Braun - Adam Jones OF- Sizemore - Justin Upton P- Grienke - Grienke P- Santana - Billingsley P- Beckett - Strasburg P- Halladay - Price P- Sabathia - Aumont
June 12, 200916 yr Albert Pujols Joe Mauer Hanley Ramirez Jacoby Ellsbury Ichiro Roy Halladay Justin Verlander Johan Santana Clayton Kershaw Jonathan Papelbon
June 12, 200916 yr QUOTE (knightni @ Jun 12, 2009 -> 03:43 PM) Hmmm... Now - 3 years C- McCann - Wieters 1B- Pujols - LaPorta 2B- Kinsler - Beckham SS- Hanley Ramirez - Hanley Ramirez 3B- Longoria - Longoria OF- Markakis - Markakis OF- Braun - Adam Jones OF- Sizemore - Justin Upton P- Grienke - Grienke P- Santana - Billingsley P- Beckett - Strasburg P- Halladay - Price P- Sabathia - Aumont What part of FIVE dont you understand?
June 12, 200916 yr QUOTE (Cali @ Jun 12, 2009 -> 06:50 PM) What part of FIVE dont you understand? I thought about that, but decided to do my own thing instead.
June 13, 200916 yr Hanley Ramirez B.J. Upton Evan Longoria Joe Mauer Justin Upton Felix Hernandez Tim Lincecum Zack Grienke Justin Verlander Chad Billingsley
June 13, 200916 yr Hanley Ramirez Albert Pujols David Wright Grady Sizemore Ryan Braun Tim Lincecum CC Sabathia Jake Peavy Cole Hamels Dan Haren
June 13, 200916 yr Hanley Ramirez Justin Upton Evan Longoria Adam Jones Albert Pujols Tim Lincecum Chad Billingsly Felix Hernandez Stephen Strasburg Roy Halladay
June 13, 200916 yr C - Joe Mauer 1B - Albert Pujols SS - Hanley Ramirez 3B - David Wright OF - Grady Sizemore SP - Tim Lincecum SP - Johan Santana SP - Zach Greinke SP - Cole Hamels SP - Justin Verlander
June 13, 200916 yr Mauer Kinsler Longoria Pujols Jones (Adam) Lincecum Santana Halladay Verlander Strasburg
June 13, 200916 yr I have my baseball-boner on. If there is any list that does not include Mauer, you lose. Every good GM builds with two factors in mind...up the middle, and pitching. That said... C - Mauer (McCann) (Wieters) 2B - Utley (Kinsler) SS - Hanley CF - Granderson (Sizemore) (Maybin???) 1B/3B/DH - Pujols Santana Lincecum Haren Felix Joba - CL (Papelbon) --Sabathia nearly made it on. He wont make it 3 more years I don't think Joba sticks in the rotation, simply because he's too damn good out of the bullpen. I'm wrong, BTW, but I like it. Edited June 13, 200916 yr by witesoxfan
June 13, 200916 yr Hanley Ramirez Albert Pujols Ian Kinsler Joe Mauer Adam Jones Dan Haren Zach Greinke Josh Johnson Roy Halladay Stephen Strasburg I'd put Lincecum on the pitchers list but I just dont trust him staying healthy
June 13, 200916 yr QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Jun 13, 2009 -> 08:05 AM) If there is any list that does not include Mauer, you lose. I'd rather have McCann for the long term. He's more healthy and will still be a catcher in 3 years.
June 13, 200916 yr Grady Sizemore Carlos Quentin Hanley Ramirez Manny Ramirez Albert Pujols Santana Haren Peavy Holladay Sabathia
June 14, 200916 yr Carl Crawford Evan Longoria Albert Pujols Joe Mauer Ichiro Johan Santana Roy Halladay Josh Beckett Tim Lincecum Francisco Rodriguez I was torn between Ichiro and Justin Upton. In the end having three left handed bats with multiple skill sets won me over. I have 4 starters, one lefty, and my closer. It was either KRod or Jonathan "Shrek" Broxton.
June 14, 200916 yr QUOTE (ChiSox_Sonix @ Jun 13, 2009 -> 11:17 AM) Zach Greinke Josh Johnson Roy Halladay Stephen Strasburg I'd put Lincecum on the pitchers list but I just dont trust him staying healthy You do realize that Josh Johnson had Tommy John, right? And that Tim Lincecum is the best pitcher in baseball and has never had a history of injury trouble?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.