Everything posted by WestEddy
-
Fall/Winter Ball 2025
Arizona Fall League | MLB.com Streaming on the front page.
-
2025 Division Series
Hagen Smith's 1st inning is starting in the AFL, if anybody's interested. Arizona Fall League | MLB.com
-
Getz 2025 Grade: your vote matters.
There's a lot of debate of Getz now vs. Getz when he ran the organization through Hahn and KW. Here's Caden Conner talking about the difference between Getz vs. Machiavellian Getz: add: he also talks some around 10:30 about talking to vets on various teams.
-
Getz 2025 Grade: your vote matters.
Correct, a top ranked farm system will probably produce more major league stars than the lowest ranked system. No, not shocking, so we should probably stop presenting it like we invented the concept of number "one" being a good rank to have. I don't think we should disregard prospect rankings "because many will bust". I think they should be seen more as a snapshot in time of individual player pedigrees, and not of the system as a whole. We just graduated 3-4 top 100 prospects, which makes the system ranking take a hit. Our top pitcher was injured, another needed work on his mechanics, while a third prospect played across 3 levels and didn't mash at the highest level he attained. That also was a hit to the ranking. 4 other starters just had TJS that delays their careers for 18 months. Another hit. Did our minor league system suddenly become bad? No. Did Schultz, Hagen Smith and B. Monty suddenly drop off and are no longer considered prospects? Of course not. But because of the nature of ranking systems, they need to look at healthy, pedigreed dudes who are dominating their current, age-appropriate level, and declare who has an elite system from that. Is it unfair? I wouldn't say that. We just drafted an elite defense shortstop who could be a stud if suggested hitting tweaks are made. We also plucked an elite high school bat that will also rank once he produces at any level. But their true potential remains to be seen, so that's a drag on the overall ranking. Every other system experiences the same ebb and flow, so a #19 ranking has so many moving parts. Colson was dropping, but he just put up 3.3 bWAR in less than half a season. To paraphrase another poster, here, minor league rankings don't win World Series. Players putting up 6 WAR seasons in the majors do.
-
Getz 2025 Grade: your vote matters.
Again, I'm still not getting where you're going with all this. Yeah, teams need good players to win. Profound.
-
Getz 2025 Grade: your vote matters.
I can't figure out what's being argued here. I think you generally get anxious over the lack of top ten (in the game) pitching prospects, and you want the Sox to obtain/develop their pitching prospects to be considered best in the game with no chance of failure before you'll recognize the Sox are doing a good job developing pitching. You're not "saying" this, but that's what I glean from your posts. There are currently no pitching prospects in the MLB top ten, and only ten pitchers that rank above Noah Schultz at 40. He got up to 16 on that list but fell back due to injuries this season.
-
2025 Division Series
I think this is appropriate:
-
2025 Division Series
I think the question is "how does any of this service my 'Chris Getz sucks at every turn' narrative".
-
2025 Division Series
Andrew Vaughn taking Chris Getz' lessons and teaching the Brewers how to win:
-
2025 Division Series
Miss Otis Regrets she's unable to pitch today.
-
2025 Division Series
I get in the weeds with this French 60's pop stuff. This is probably something you want to take a gummy, then really dig it.
-
2025 Division Series
Adrian Houser would have been a great addition. But Civale should have probably started one of these games for them.
-
2025 Division Series
At least Adam Eaton would get himself knocked out cold.
-
2025 Division Series
We'll take that one
-
2025 Division Series
Okay, The Franchise Ortiz has got to do something sometime, right?
-
2025 Division Series
They're really "Imanaga and Boyd, and pray to not be so annoyed"
-
2025 Division Series
do or die tonight
-
2025 Division Series
I'm kind of glad for his appearance on the All-Star team. Kind of took some of the shade away from Shane Smith.
-
2025 Division Series
I read that if he pitched tonight, he could appear in game 5 on regular rest. different plans, I guess.
-
2025 Division Series
Give him a fresh inning to start?
-
2025 Division Series
Okay, fuggit. Andrew Vaughn - Cub Killer. Now go have a career.
- MLBTR projected arbitration salaries are out. #18 made us gasp!!
- MLBTR projected arbitration salaries are out. #18 made us gasp!!
-
Colson Montgomery has arrived
I believe a group of these guys are getting together in Nashville to train and work out together.
-
“The 78” is alive and well for the Sox, Bears are 'advancing' Hammond development
And at this point, it's the regional fanbase teams try to cultivate, not part of one city. The Cards' base stretches well into KY, TN and AK. Cubs draw from IA, MI, IN. When the Cubs had a team in Peoria, there were lots of Cub and Cardinal hats at the game. The Sox get into the South, SW suburbs, and Indiana. They really have to grab fans' imagination to battle with the Tigers, Brewers, Cubs and Cards to get households.