Chisox378

I know he strikes out alot, but what about Corey Dickerson. He had 28 2B in 279 Plate Appearances last season. Or, maybe even better in my opinion depending on the price of Dickerson, is to save the money for pitching, throw Adam Engel in CF and let Mendick play RF.

No, Im saying it may be of no use to sign Hamilton if we already have Engel. Engel is terrific defensively too. Kind of a risk, but with a good farm system its worth a try and we can save the money for pitching. Here is the thing. For Engel to stay and play at the MLB level he has to: 1)Keep up stellar D 2) Hit and get on base regularly 3)get a full time shot at leading off and stealing bases.

If we already have Hamilton in Engel, why not just trust in Adam Engel to leadoff and play CF? If things dont work out, we can pick from the farm.

Hmmm.interesting take... We have been waiting for Engel for years, but he hasnt been ready to hit MLB pitching. Still, I like that you are thinking, we should give Engel a look for sure if we dont sign a CF. Engel can go get em too. Maybe he comes into spring hitting and getting on base and stealing like crazy. That would be the best scenario, because Engel is only 27.

Yes, I was thinking that if we dont get a CF leadoff hitter with speed, Madrigal would be the next best option at leadoff. Dont expect 60 SB (as would could with Hamilton) but Madrigal could pop for may 25-30, no? And Madrigal would hopefully get on base alot. If Madrigal shows in spring he is up to his old tricks of hitting and walking, then he should make the opening day roster, especially if we dont get a Hamilton(or Hamilton himself) type player.

Now days, speed is hard to come by.

1)B.Hamilton CF 2)Madrigal 2B 3)Rendon3B 4)Eloy LF 5)Moncada RF 6)Abreu 1B 7)Grandal C 😎 8.Anderson SS 9)Collins DH 😎 Good lineup with the batting Champion batting 8th!

I like Nimmo too, but not for Collins, then we would need another DH.

Take a chance and sign CF Billy Hamilton. If he doesn't work out at least we will have good speed off the bench.

Strikeouts are selfish. They don't move runners over or make the defense work. The don't get a batter on base. They kill rallies. Players that choose to try to hit a HRs instead of giving up themselves and their at bat for the best of the team, are selfish hitters. This is the last thing I'll say: players that lead the league in strikeouts, no matter their HRs and OBP, are not the best hitters in baseball.

Yes, I'm tough to impress when you make Taris Jr. to be the next Griffey Jr. Let's put it this way; I think Moncada is a little above average hitter, he strikes out too much. I don't think Taris Jr. is a better hitter than Moncada. Tatis Jr. is a first pitch hitter,once pitchers get ahead of him he struggles mightily.

110 k's to 30bb in 372 pa. I'm not very hot on Tatis Jr. If he batted a full season he would have been one of the leaders in strikeouts.

Our defense and rebounding need alot of work.

White Sox being loyal again. After further review, I change my mind on this one. What better than to have a player stay with the same team for 9 years of his pro career. The key is, lets hope he can continue to be Jose Abreu. If so, even better. Remember, it went Frank Thomas, Paul Konerko, and now Jose Abreu as faces of this franchise. The next couple of years we will see who takes the baton as face of this franchise but for now its Jose Abreu. And no better man and person is fit for this job right now. Lets bring home a championship Jose!

Silly move. I love being loyal, but we should have done this on a year to year basis with Abreu.

I hope the Red Sox feel the way you all do about Benintendi, then I would make the swap immediately...Collins & Dunning(or another prospect) for Benintendi!

Go watch his at bats. He is a better hitter than the hitters you mentions. Benintendi had a down year last year, he will be better as the years go on.

There is more to judging hitting besides WAR. Watching the players at bats is worth alot. Even though Moncada had a better WAR he is not a better hitter than Benintendi. Benintendi had a down year last season. I predict Benintendi to be a borderline Hall of Famer when its all said and done.

If its not Benintendi, then Collins is a keeper.

Sorry, I looked back and seen that. I need to read and understand before I respond.

No way would they deal Benintendi straight up for Collins. Prepare to deal more of our hot prospects. Benintendi would immediately become our best hitter with Eloy coming on strong.

Your right, it looks like McCann may take a hit in plate appearances. Although this stinks for him, since he had such a good year last year, Im sure he is the type of guy to sacrifice for the better of the team. Its good to have him on this team, seems like a really good clubhouse guy.

While McCann's k to bb rate is poor, he did bat .273, 18HR, 26 2B in only 476 plate appearances. He hit very well vs. LHP with a .295ba and .372obp.

Benintendi in my opinion is many levels above Haniger and Mazara.

Silly to trade Collins. Collins is Grandal but only 25 years old. I say we platoon Collins, Grandal, McCann at C, 1B, and DH. Get them all maximum plate appearances. If anything we need outfielders now. Dickerson seems like a good pickup to play RF. Attach that along with Billy Hamilton signing to lead off and play CF would be the icing on the cake! To get Bennitendi alone it would take Madrigal and Vaughn...too much to give up.