Everything posted by Chisoxfn
-
2016-2017 NBA Thread
QUOTE (SoxPride18 @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 12:44 PM) Ric Bucher is saying that the Bulls are shopping Jimmy Butler..... On the bright side, his value is only higher now then it was in the off-season.
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (bmags @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 11:26 AM) They had an elite offense with him for the second half of 14 and all of 2015. Hell, you could even go back to Warner. Cards have had a few good rolls of the dice with end of career QBs providing suddenly competitive windows. I view the whole Warner thing, somewhat akin to the attempt of Romo (or also the Bronco's attempt at Peyton Manning). Not saying Romo is as good as either of them, but you are still talking about a guy that is a probowl QB when healthy.
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (bmags @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 10:49 AM) If we do it well we could be in the same shape as the cards with their Palmer resurgence while we find a new QB. I probably watched less college football than any year of my life. So I can't claim to have a strong opinion, maybe I'll learn more, but it was just my impression there was not a can't miss prospect this year but it was deep. So that's why I've been fine with a stopgap qb plus a later round vs going after Jimmy G. One thing to remember is, Palmer was the #1 overall pick in the draft, so it isn't like he didn't have a lot of talent. He has always been turnover prone though, but the Cardinals certainly benefited from having an elite defense (for a while).
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (Y2JImmy0 @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 10:37 AM) I agree with this. I'm in the minority on this board but I'd absolutely take DeShone Kizer at 3. His Texas game was better than any QB in this class. He has obvious flaws but he has a big time arm, ran pro style stuff, makes ridiculous throws, stands in the pocket, can move around, and is said to be incredibly intelligent and will impress in workouts and on the whiteboard. His games against Texas and Virginia this year were great. I watched his game against Clemson from 2015 and there were a ton of dropped balls. He would be my guy. I agree with you, at his best Kizer, had moments where he looked like a #1 overall pick / franchise player. The thing is, I still don't see the Niners & Browns passing on a franchise QB, so if Kizer does all those things, I don't know if we will get our shot at him. Trubinsky is next on my list, but there are a lot more suspect things about him vs. Kizer, imo. I think Kizer is a safer pick. None of them are the safe pick, but outside of the every 4 or 5 year generational QB that is there, none of them are ever "that" safe. All I know is, last year it was a weak class and then next thing we know, there is a flurry of activity and Wentz/Goff go 1/2. I presume we'll see that happen this year, question is which QB's make the big move. I wonder if Josh Allen is going to go pro?
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 10:19 AM) Hoyer's numbers this year are better than I remembered, but you can't be surprised if a QB who is turning 32 next year gets hurt during the year compared to 27 year old Tyrod Taylor, so basically what is your goal next year - to add a QB to win games or to mentor someone else? You also mentioned Romo a post or two ago, which makes me think your goal next year is to win games, not to get better for 2018. I think there are a couple directions you go. I think if your goal is to win games, you go with Romo and spend a ton on defensive free agents (probably targeting Eric Berry plus another FA corner) and then wait on QB (drafting someone in the 2nd or 3rd round...say a Josh Allen or the Texas QB or even a Watson if he falls). Part of the Romo situation probably is more tied to the fact that you don't see any QB's worth taking in the 1st round / being difference makers (and don't believe in Jimmy G / AJ McCarron). I think Romo is still a well above average QB (if you can protect him) and he can give you 2 years time to find someone else. If you think Kizer or one of the picks is the guy, then I think Hoyer makes a lot more sense as a bridge (probably doesn't change your free agent plans a ton, as I still think the Bears probably look at an Eric Berry / CB signing as those are major needs regardless) as you can still compete (in the sense that you don't want things to be a dumpster fire, especially if your defense comes around faster...although likelihood of it being totally dominant is less because you are no longer using the #3 pick on a guy you hope would be a high impact defender right away) before giving at least half a season to your young QB with a bigger eye on the following year (and most realistically, you are probably two years away if you got it right with your QB, because the reality is, it still takes time for the young QB, if he is the guy, to pan out). I presume we will end up taking a QB @ 3 overall and spend our FA money on DB's (potentially using our 2nd round pick on a DB as well or a tackle). To me, whether you go after Romo, hinges on how much you like the QB's that are available (long-term). If you think a guy in the pack is a franchise QB, you need to take them. If you don't, then I think Romo buys you time to do other things (better then say a Tyrod Taylor). Hoyer seems like the perfect groom guy.
-
2016-2017 NBA Thread
Cavs evidently interested in Rondo. Not sure if that would be via trade (as I don't know how salaries would match) or if it would be if the Bulls released him.
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (bmags @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 09:43 AM) My push for Taylor is if you want to be competitive next year you can be competitive with a Taylor and not lose financial flexibility. You aren't signing a brock osweiler to market prices in other words. I"m not saying drafting a qb is bad, I'm saying that just because we have the 3rd overall pick we don't need to draft a bad qb. What if the QBs go 1-2, should we draft the 3rd best QB on board just because? I guess I don't see how Hoyer is much different (and at least he has a year in the system and is probably more willing to work to groom another player then someone like Taylor).
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (bmags @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 10:06 AM) No, that is clearly what Fox thinks, but local media, national media, fans, their handling of so many injury situations has been bulls***. Correction, the media doesn't like it, so they make a big deal of it and it gets picked up by the fans. National media doesn't really play it up much at all, but local media hasn't liked Fox from day one because they didn't get the "access" they were used to so they always gripe and complain and thus the fans hear it enough they think it is a big deal. In reality, it means nothing, just another thing for the media to whine about (which has no real impact on the actual club performance).
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 10:01 AM) come on man, this is the NFL. they all do that s*** Just look at the Pats.
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 09:55 AM) To me, the press conference is irrelevant. If they come out and hang their heads and dont say much, they are crucified. If they come out and beat their chests and say they expect to win and compete, they are crucified. if they come out and talk openly about their deficiencies and what they expect to do, they are crucified. The only thing they didnt do is hang their heads and refuse to talk. THey talked about addressing needs openly, DB, QB, health, skill players, it was all addressed. The only thing that will make these end of season press conferences palatable is winning. There isnt much to say anymore, we all know the drill. We are heading to year three(year 5, post Lovie), this is a big year for the front office and coaching staff. I thought McCaskey's press conference was the best. He basically said, Fox & Pace are 100% on the same page and aligned and that while he doesn't want to be patient, Pace had told him from the get go he needed him to be patient and trust the process. I haven't seen any reason to stop. Think about what would have happened with the Raiders if they didn't trust the process with Reggie McKenzie (or whatever their GM's name is). Early on, the Raiders still looked like the Raiders, but they stayed with the course and despite Carr's injury, look like they are just scratching the surface of their potential.
-
2017 Catch All thread
QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Jan 4, 2017 -> 10:14 PM) Facebook friends know, so my Soxtalk brothers and sisters may as well know too: I accepted the Executive Chef position at the Ramkota Hotel in Bismarck. So, if you are in Bismarck anytime in the near future, come find me. We serve good food. Also, unlike most promotions, I'm much less scared about this. I'm much more scared of more f***ing snow. Congrats Wite. Awesome news.
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (bmags @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 08:44 AM) I've mentioned before, but Tyrod Taylor is likely available. Romo may be available. I'd rather draft a qb that we've rated appropriately then giving up a 3rd overall pick and a 4th for garoppolo. I don't see any reason to go after Taylor. We know what he is. I'm all for Romo and letting him bridge the gap. If you think Josh Allen or someone else that you can get in a later round is the guy, but needs time, you can bridge things that way. I'd rather have Hoyer then Taylor, to be honest. But you can't ignore QB, it is just such an important position. I suppose I could see some logic for Taylor, but I figure he's going to get too much guaranteed money.
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (bmags @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 08:30 AM) If there was a really good qb at 3 i'd be happy to draft them, but just prioritizing "getting a QB" is not worth it. edit: for example - getting Jay Cutler Cutler didn't pan out, but I'd still make that trade every single day. Was absolutely the right move to make. Now how we built a team around the franchise QB and the subsequent moves we made, were not the right ones. Putting him behind a suspect oline, having no continuity at OC, and waiting forever to surround him with weapons, were all major mistakes.
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 07:09 AM) assuming they trade back, correct? What if we traded our 1st for Jimmy G and the Pats 1st? I would presume Pats would make that trade...but might be a bit of an overpay for Bears. Of course, it all comes down to how Pace & company view Jimmy. If they think he is a franchise QB, then you need to figure out a way to get him. If they are less sure, then that obviously changes the price you are willing to pay.
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 06:03 AM) I think they are in a similar position as the Sox were with Sale. There is no rush here, they have the hot property(not nearly as valuable as Sale of course), and can slow play it. They may not get a 1st and 4th, but I dont think they are getting only a 2nd back I would be okay with the deal Greg Gabriel proposed, where you give up a 3rd or something this year and then a conditional pick next year, that could be as high as a 1st round pick (based upon how well Jimmy G plays). I don't know if Pats would do it. AJ McCarron is going to get a lot of looks as well. Is the Wyoming QB going pro or staying another year? I have a feeling he's going to shoot up some draft boards (has a ton of tools).
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (Y2JImmy0 @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 05:42 AM) Yeah this is true. Kevin White can't be counted on. This kind of hinges on Jeffery. Jeffery and Meredith each had 800+ yard seasons with bum QB's. Jordan Howard is very good. It's clear that QB and secondary are top needs but another pass rusher, a starting TE, and more speed at WR is also necessary We just have to hope that Kevin White emerges in year three like Demayrius Thomas did for Denver. Thomas wasn't quite as injured, but he battled quite a bit of injuries his first two years before emerging as a very good wideout.
-
2016-2017 NBA Thread
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Jan 5, 2017 -> 08:21 AM) There is no more infuriating team than the Bulls in the NBA. They own wins against Cleveland (2) and San Antonio this year. They also own losses against Timberwolves, Dallas, and the Lakers. They can win, there are just times they choose not to. To me, it is an inditement on their coach (and obviously players) cause it does seem they play pretty solid against good teams, while wetting the bed against more mediocre teams. The general thoughts are, our coaching staff can't get our guys to play at consistent levels. That said, last night was one of the more enjoyable Bulls games in a while (despite the Cavs obviously missing Kyrie / Love). Niko actually took good shots (and by that, I mean he took three's where he had his feet set and was in good form, with the exception of about one three last night). That is not the norm out of him as he usually has such poor shooting fundamentals (because he takes a lot of bad / rushed shots). When he actually uses his right mechanics, he's lethal from long range and Doug was fantastic in that 2nd quarter. MCW is such a step up from Rondo, mainly because he isn't afraid to go for the shot. That drive and dunk he had was awesome to watch last night. MCW has his own massive limitations cause he clearly can't shoot that well, but he's clearly a major upgrade (both offensively / defensively) from Rondo who has been totally worthless this year. Grant doesn't show me much and Valentine got hurt a day where he played well (couple nights back) which stinks cause I'd like him to get more minutes. They did this all on a night where Butler struggled, up until the fourth, where he played like the superstar he is. Taj was fantastic too. Unfortunate how crappy / inconsistent a lot of our parts are and in Doug's case, I don't really understand why we don't look to get him more involved cause he's such a damn good scorer. Wish we could replace Wade / Rondo with Cousins / CP3.
-
Quintana Rumors: Round and round and round we go
Shutting this down due to turning into a gigantic massive catch all. Especially in light of some new / fresh updates coming out.
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jan 4, 2017 -> 02:00 PM) Are you willing to give up that 2nd round pick for JG? That was the price for Cassel. I have absolutely zero problem giving up a 2nd for JG. None at all. I prefer that to any other plausible scenario. I'd then try to trade down from #3 to accumulate more picks. Jimmy G is ready to start. Whether he's good or not, hell if I know, but I've seen enough that I'd have no problem going that route and taking the chance.
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jan 4, 2017 -> 01:26 PM) Do you count a 2nd as a high pick? I would be genuinely disappointed if there's not at least a 3rd spent on that spot this year. I totally get not using that first round pick on a QB, but especially if one of the "potential 1st round QBs" falls as we have seen before, picking early in the 2nd could set this team up. Very rarely do later round picks pan out, so while I always get the fascination of waiting a bit, I think you either like Kizer or others and think they have a shot or you don't. If you don't, then you need to find a QB another way and it can't be, well lets take a flyer on a guy in the 2nd / 3rd / 4th, cause reality is, if you thought they had a good shot at starting, you'd have taken them higher, so there is a lot more crapshoot to it already (and QB is such a difficult spot to scout) to where I just don't see how you can do that. To me, we are either taking a QB in the 1st round or trading for one (Jimmy G / AJ McCarron / Tony Romo). Had Cutler not totally sucked, I could have gotten more on board with taking someone in the 2nd-4th this year and hell even again a year from now cause you'd have the luxury of time, but we don't have that luxury anymore. They could have had it if they just used a pick on a QB a year ago, but I don't think any of them saw Cutler blowing up as much as he did this year (and the reality is, he'll bounce back and go back to being a league averagish starting QB...unless his arm is shot). And I recognize all my talk of McCarron / Jimmy G is counterintuitive to my late round picks normally don't pan out. Part of that is also the fact that you look at AJ / Jimmy G and it took them a couple years before they were even ready to be "starting" material and if Fox/Pace get a guy like that, forget about them ever being around long-term and remember, while they have to make decisions in the best interest of the franchise, they also have to view things from the lens that these decisions should also maximize their ability to continue to get paychecks from the Bears!
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (RockRaines @ Jan 4, 2017 -> 01:22 PM) Using a high pick on this QB class looks to be pretty darn stupid. I think they will plug that hole while improving the rest of the team. The problem is, the GM / Head Coach can't just wait forever to address QB. You aren't going to win keeping Hoyer and odds only increase of you never seeing your way to success longer term without finding the solution. Kizer has all the tools to be an NFL QB. I don't see how you ignore the position. I think the best move is to trade for Jimmy G or go with Romo and let him buy you time (i.e., allow you to take a guy in the 2nd or 3rd and evaluate and maybe even take another guy a year from now if after a year you don't like what you see from the first pick).
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
Our RB coach wasn't let go, he is taking a job at Texas under Herman.
-
President-Elect Donald Trump: The Thread
QUOTE (bmags @ Dec 23, 2016 -> 07:10 AM) You know saying something that dangerous is the exact sort of thing that people warned of with Trump, and were met with claims of exaggerating Trump's danger. People are just too far removed from the 1930s and 40s and for some reason think stuff like this can't happen again. But it wasn't happening again because those citizens post WWII valued that peace and stability, and it's clear many are taking it for granted. Boy, the book "the end of history" really had a short shelf life. History repeats itself. Civilizations forget the first hand impacts of war and therefor repeat the past. I am so damn afraid of going to war, more selfishly, bringing it to our land or getting to a point where we had to instill a form of draft. The scariest part is, war in the modern era can literally wipe the population off the face of the earth with the threat of nukes.
-
President-Elect Donald Trump: The Thread
QUOTE (caulfield12 @ Dec 22, 2016 -> 01:57 PM) Even then, how many professional who average thst type of salary for 20+ year don't end up with a net worth in the $2.5-3 million range, at least? They might not be true 1%ers....but they're still generating most of their retirement income from investments (many shielded from taxes) and real estate. You don't have to run a hedge fund or work for one of the big banks to fall into this category. There was an article weeks ago asserting the average benefit to the 1% would be $300,000 while the average middle class tax payer would get $900 back. With inflation expected to rise eventually, a good chunk of that will be completely wiped out...the deficit will grow to $25 trillion...and those families will still vote for Trump because he "saved" a handful of jobs at Carrier and put a 5% import tax on Chinese and Mexican goods which further wiped out the remaining tax cut benefits by passing added costs onto consumers. It's also a consistent GOP talking point to claim that the estate tax kills numerous small businesses (forcing them to be sold or split up) and small American farms, but that's also been determined to be the case only 3% of the time. But slap the label of death tax and death panels on it...the majority will buy will buy that narrative. The same argument is buried here...those who are being taxed too highly are "good Americans" and hard-working people like everyone else with upper middle class (not elite) values. That statistic is probably skewed because I presume the 1% impact as a percentage of their income could be significantly different. As a percent savings, it might be pretty significant. I still fully believe that the people who are the most tax screwed are most likely the upper middle class people or for the sake of this exercise, because the data is available, the 80-99%th percentile (134K - 615K by tax bracket), they also pay approximately 38% of total taxes). The 1% pays about 46^ of the taxes, but that is largley skewed by the fact that you are taking about huge mega dollars getting applied to a capital gains rate, so the effective rates at that level are much lower then the effective rates of the 80-99% percentile of income). More specifically, it is those who are in that percentile who are not self-employed who take even more of the brunt as their are just so few tax advantages.
-
2016-2017 NFL Thread
QUOTE (RockRaines @ Jan 4, 2017 -> 10:55 AM) They need to collect as many picks as possible in this draft and have to hit on most of them. If that doesnt happen then next offseason will be much much worse for them. I also think they need to use their free agent money wisely and they probably need to spend a good chunk of it on secondary pieces (as well as using a pretty high pick on the secondary). The most critical decision will relate to the QB position, which is such a freaking crapshoot. I disagree on having to hit on most of them, they need to have a few big wins though, that is for sure, and I do think they are best served by trading down a bit. To me they should acquire a QB outside of the draft.