What?! Disagree very much?
Garcia has more K's, less BB's, lower WHIP than Mulder. Lower ERA by 30 points.
Advantage: Garcia
Pavano has more K's/inning and less BB's/inning than Hudson. Lower ERA by 25 points although he does pitch in the NL. Lower WHIP than Hudson.
Advantage: Pavano
Buehrle identical K's to Zito, but less BB's and a lower ERA while playing at a field where HR's are hit at a greater rate than anywhere else. More innings per start. Buehrle has lower WHIP than Zito.
Advantage: Buehrle
I can't really argue that Contreras is better than Harden. But with better control he's just as if not more capable than him. He needs work.
Advantage: Harden
Redmond lower ERA by 18 points, Garland more IP/start. Garland more K's/inning, less BB's/inning. Garland lower WHIP by 10 points. I'm going to give it to Garland because he has to pitch in the Cell.
Advantage: Garland