Jake

Colas didn't have near the level of consensus that Vargas had from evaluators and also has little track record of good play. Colas has only tanked his value since his high watermark in the rankings. Vargas had a tough run in MLB, then killed AAA pitching, and has held his own in a second cup of coffee in MLB. And is younger with more positional versatility and by all accounts, doesn't have s%*# for brains like Colas.

I assume Rosado had an injury shortly after his signing and then flopped upon his return as a starter. Hard to complain about his debut as a reliever. Old for the level but has minimal experience so it's not like it's a guy who has needed 200 innings to solve low-A.

Yeah it's hard for me to criticize honestly, I don't think DeJong had much value at all so just getting anyone who is not going to be imminently released for poor performance is fine with me.

22 year old righty reliever dominating low-A. Okay, whatever

Feeling like we're about to get cash considerations at this point

Maybe it will be a straight swap of the teams' starting shortstops??

per Rosenthal https://x.com/Ken_Rosenthal/status/1818372833153565070 Jarold Rosado per DST

Developmentally, losing the last month of the minor league season doesn't seem like the end of the world. But this does feel like a typically White Sox thing, though.

Will be really surprised if DeJong is still on the team tonight, not that I could tell you which team would benefit from having him around.

It's that White Sox Midas touch!

James McCann (?)

There's a certain age where it begins to interfere with me caring about control. So I'll say in general that I can't value the many years of control of a 27 year old very highly because of my concern that even if a player "turns out," he has high risk of collapsing by age 30 or so. Probably moreso for a hitter than pitcher although pitchers can imminently self-destruct regardless of age...

What would you say to AJ Smith-Shawver, Nacho Alvarez Jr, Jose Perdomo?

I think Getz would like Nacho Alvarez Jr.

If you want to say Kopech was traded for the two 19 year olds, then holy crap what a deal, maybe Getz really knows what he's doing!

I think the league clearly isn't seeing Fedde as a sure bet, Getz still could have probably at least gotten another player of the caliber of the two 19 year olds we received, and also that Vargas is the superior prospect out of Vargas/Norby/Stowers which likely relates to why Sox dealt with Dodgers rather than O's.

I don't really like either of those guys over Vargas, but it's surprising that Rogers nets much value at all.

You certainly have to hold out for a good return, but don't get cute either. Crochet is really a ticking time bomb and Sox won't have as much leverage in the offseason. Don't let perfect be the enemy of the good here.

Jasson Dominguez would have been fun although the injuries are scary.

For any who play MLB The Show, Vargas was once nearly the top ranked player in the world in its online multiplayer. I do remember hearing that he had engaged in a mild form of cheating to get there though, lol

For the analytically inclined, Edman's 15.9 career WAR would slot him into a tie for 38th among position players in White Sox history, tied with Carlos Lee, just short of the immortal Zeke Bonura, and just ahead of 2025 manager AJ Pierzynski

I've been worried that Kopech might degenerate into full-blown yips at any time so I'm sympathetic to the view that maybe you should just offload him. Of course in this deal I have no clue how much, if anything, he got added to the return for the Sox.

Looking forward to having Fletcher back on the team. Would like to see him show whether he can be an everyday major leaguer

I don't know. As soon as I heard we did a three-way deal with the Cardinals I suspected there was a chance the industry valued those two guys the same (although I remain fuzzy on Edman's injury status) but I was hopeful the Sox could get more for Fedde. But can't rule out the possibility that teams just aren't that high on Fedde given his long track record of being terrible before this season.

Strongly suspect what was intended with the comment in the confusing tweet was the Sox agreed that they would probably accept a trade in which the Sox accept the prospect return for Edman as the prospect return for Fedde