Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

southsider2k5

Admin
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by southsider2k5

  1. QUOTE (ScottyDo @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 09:25 PM) Everyone looks like a Reinsdorf apologist when arguing with irrational, inconsistent, and made up Reinsdorf rants.
  2. QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Mar 26, 2014 -> 08:00 AM) So basically Emery went out and got the top two available DEs against the run, and against the pass. A big hint something was coming was with the Cutler contract conversion that was just done.
  3. QUOTE (Marty34 @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 09:02 PM) You act like the Sox are a small market team. We've been over this, but there are no laws limiting revenue. Pfft, reality is overrated anyway.
  4. QUOTE (Marty34 @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 05:56 PM) Because the value of an established #2 starter, should one become available, is going to be prohibitive and if you take Quintana off the table, we likely wouldn't have enough. Baseball needs more GM's like you for Rick Hahn to trade with. Trading cheap #3 cost control starters, to acquire full price #2 starters? Awesome.
  5. QUOTE (raBBit @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 05:09 PM) The amount or people overlooking Rodon is surprising. Best player in the draft and it's not very close. People are putting WAY to much stock into early season statistics.
  6. QUOTE (Quinarvy @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 04:58 PM) MKG was looked at as a consensus #2. Zeller, yeah, didn't like that one but it was also a s*** draft. I'm more intrigued with what the Bobcats do in this draft. Hopefully, give us their pick.
  7. QUOTE (ZoomSlowik @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 04:16 PM) This argument is silly. Executives make terrible decisions even when they've seen guys play In the NBA. Kwame Brown was such a bust, yet he's still made over $80 million in the NBA. He's still collecting checks right now. If we wait until NBA executives get enough info to make the right decision more often than not, the players will be collecting retirement benefits before they enter the draft. You can't honestly see the difference between drafting someone at an older age vs a younger age?
  8. QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 04:46 PM) If you trade for a guy that was a Rule V draft, he is yours just as if it were any other ordinary trade. They did this with Jason Grilli about 10 years ago. In the case of Angel Sanchez last year, the Sox actually offered him back to the Angels, and they didn't want to pay the $25,000 to bring him back, so the Sox got to keep him for free. Depends on what you mean by "trade". If you trade the player to a team that isn't the team you drafted him from, they inherit the roster requirements for that players. A team can make a deal for the rights to the Rule 5 player from the team they drafted him from, then all roster restrictions are dropped, because he is now "your" player.
  9. QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 04:12 PM) Well first, you can certainly take some evaluation from multiple years of two players in A and A+, when they are at the same position and a similar age. Especially if you look at the right numbers. You can't just throw out those numbers, they do mean something. Baj and Jenks had very different paths through the minors. You think sticking with the team in 2014 means he's got an inside ticket - and there is some truth to that. But it isn't as cut and dried as people think. Smith gets to develop and move up, while Nieto is likely to be overwhelmed. You want a comparison, look at Jesus Flores, who took this route and never put it together to be a starter. I think a year from now, barring injuries or trades obviously, that Smith is just as likely to have a shot at the team as Nieto does. Smith looks like a better prospect to me overall, if only by a little, which is offset by Nieto's early exposure to the majors. And after 10/1 of this year, the Sox don't have to keep Nieto on the active roster any more than they do Smith. Except Nieto has jumped to the front of the line. Smith doesn't have that get out of jail free card, no matter what their numbers look like. And at the end of the day Nieto and Smith now have very different paths through the minors.
  10. QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 04:00 PM) It's actually a very strong comp in terms of their prospects for the future. The Rule V aspect is the wildcard. People can debate that part all day, but the key thing here isn't that Smith should have had the job - he shouldn't. It is that people's expectations of Nieto should be tempered, and Smith is a good description of why. Further, while Nieto may be with the team this year, that doesn't mean he's likely to be a starting C with the club in 2015. I think his chances at that are only as likely as Smith's. That's the long-term view, for me. I really can't take two guys A Ball numbers and use them to define expectations down the road. I think everyone involved here has said he probably won't be that good this year, and it could be years, if ever, before he is any good. The reality is, if he does stick out the team for this season, by very definition his chances of being on the team in 2015 are way higher than Kevan Smith, or any other catcher in the minor leagues, no matter what their A ball numbers looked like. Those numbers can be a useful too, but they sure as heck aren't the be all, end all. I remember making that mistake in comparing Jeff Bajenaru's AAA numbers to some guy in AA named Bobby Jenks, because they were favorable to Bajenaru.
  11. southsider2k5 replied to Kyyle23's topic in SLaM
    QUOTE (Iwritecode @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 03:31 PM) Who's Line was always one of my favorite shows. Although I'm kinda disappointed that Drew isn't the host anymore. He was always such an easy target for jokes. Aisha doesn't seem to get involved as much and doesn't do a skit at the end of the show. I wonder if having a "guest star" is going to be something they do for every episode now. I hated Drew Carey on that show. Clive Anderson was awesome. Aisha is funnier, but you are right where she doesn't get involved.
  12. QUOTE (Leonard Zelig @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 03:48 PM) I thought they were considering raising the uprights, not the crossbar. What does raising the uprights do?
  13. QUOTE (Boogua @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 03:53 PM) People are disagreeing with this? Executives will make mistakes, but more evidence can help them limit their mistakes. Exactly.
  14. QUOTE (ZoomSlowik @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 03:51 PM) Tyrus Thomas wasn't a one-and-done player, so the rule wouldn't have affected him. We also don't know what Brown would have done in college. Maybe he dominates and still goes high. Andre Drummond didn't even play that well and he was still a top-10 pick. And again, you're assuming that the right people will get picked early when the entirety of NBA history suggests they won't. I've thrown around probably a dozen upperclassmen that sucked in this list that went early in the draft. Teams are still going to pick the guys that they think have the highest potential whether there is an age limit or not. Doug McDermott is not going to go #1 with this rule change. I am not assuming anything. I said it will improve the process, not perfect it. Every year you get to observe a player is another year to give you a better picture of the player. You get another year of physical maturity, of mental maturity, of basketball IQ, etc. If you pushed it to three or four years, it would improve even more. It is the same thing in baseball where the high school draftees are way bigger questions than the college kids. It doesn't mean the college kids projections are perfect, it just means they are better, because you have more information to analyze.
  15. QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 03:39 PM) Yes, which is why they kept him. I'm not arguing that, with him in camp, this wasn't the best way to keep him. I just have doubts about his readiness, and about his future after this year. And I found it interesting how much interest he's getting, while a very similar prospect isn't mentioned. That was all I was really going for. If Nieto had been in the Sox organization all along, he wouldn't be in the majors. That is why the comp doesn't work. I get the numerical similarities and all, but the situations can't really be compared because Nieto's situation is unique.
  16. QUOTE (whitesoxfan99 @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 03:17 PM) Eh. Most guys are just never going to be good enough. If you take out the guy drafted on "potential" you replace him with a guy who doesn't have the tools necessary to be a good/great NBA player anyways. There are only a certain amount of guys with the elite talent needed to be stars in the league and just looking at drafts on year to year basis demonstrates that giving teams more years to evaluate players doesn't really help them with talent evaluations. You push the Tyrus Thomas's and Kwame Brown's of the world down the draft board, and push the Jimmy Butler's and Taj Gibson's up it. It gets the guys who will be solid, but not spectacular NBA players into better positions, while exposing the players who while they might have potential, but are never going to realize it. Those are the differences that are being talked about here.
  17. QUOTE (flavum @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 03:29 PM) I'd rather see Konerko get a nice intro when they line up, and then pinch hit when the Sox are up 10-2 in the 8th. If he came back to be a Ploach, he should sit on opening day. BUt I guess they don't have to worry about Dunn's feelings in his last season. I'd bet money if you asked Adam Dunn, he would tell Robin Ventura to start Paul Konerko.
  18. QUOTE (Y2JImmy0 @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 02:59 PM) Daryl Van Schouwen ‏@CST_soxvan 4m Ventura said Konerko might get Opening Day start at DH over Dunn because it will be his last one. "It's a possibility,'' he said. Well Greg will be happy. I predicted this a month ago. To me, it was obvious.
  19. QUOTE (ZoomSlowik @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 03:03 PM) Except that's not what happens. They move onto the next young guy with potential because they need to find studs to win. It's also far from a guarantee that the old guy is going to be better. There's plenty of busts that were 22 year olds that were more developed and skilled and flopped when they lost that edge in the pros. But if you push back everyone a year, some of the guys get weeded out. It isn't perfect, but it is a hell of a lot easier to project a 22 year old, than an 18 year old. It is easier to project with every additional year of knowledge you have about a player. Period. Some guys come on late, some guys never reach potential, etc.
  20. QUOTE (ZoomSlowik @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 02:55 PM) That assumes that they're "ready" after another year, which is BS. 95% of college players are never going to be "ready" for the NBA. You never know which ones are or aren't until they hit the league either. Around draft time, you would have said Derrick Williams and Evan Turner were ready and Andre Drummond and Michael Carter-Williams weren't. Yet the last two were way more productive as rookies. No. You weed out more guys who might be drafted because POTENTIAL, but with another year you can better identify that potential is never going to become ability. Another year in college probably sorts out more of those kind of guys.
  21. QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 02:50 PM) It's the only way to be able to call people out on their predictions being wrong while leaving them unable to respond. Yet about as unsurprising as Ozzie Guillen saying something stupid to the media.
  22. QUOTE (Boogua @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 02:42 PM) Couldn't you argue that those players stock dropped because there was a better evaluation on them? I'm also fairly certain that Noah wouldn't have been drafted above 9th overall after his freshman season. That is the point exactly. In the NBA's eyes, it is good their stock dropped, because that is one less not ready player at the top of the draft, rotting on the end of a bench somewhere.
  23. Dan Hayes ‏@DanHayesCSN 12m Robin Ventura also says Adrian Nieto has earned the job even though there's still a little time left in camp. #WhiteSox
  24. QUOTE (Leonard Zelig @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 02:14 PM) Seems strange to play an NL team so early. Now interleague happens every day.
  25. QUOTE (HickoryHuskers @ Mar 25, 2014 -> 02:11 PM) So you think the Sox are going to get a Wilcard at 80-82 and then lose the Wildcard game? One of the options above is a block of between 80-83 wins.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.