Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

southsider2k5

Admin

Everything posted by southsider2k5

  1. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 02:18 PM) No one is is claiming that emotion doesn't matter, but (1) you can't measure it, so it's silly to assign some huge, arbitrary value to it based only on intuition. In this case, it's better to leave it out of analysis entirely and accept something as being an incomplete picture rather than throw in a valuation completely out of nowhere for the sake of completeness at the cost of making the entire thing wrong, and (2) I think you are overstating the difference between a big out on the bases and a big out of any kind. Further, I think you are underestimating the ability for professional players to stay focused despite disappointment. Part of the reason they are in the Majors is their ability to perform at a consistently high despite physical and emotional fatigue. You can't measure it, so throw it out and pretend it doesn't exist? I can't agree with that either.
  2. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 01:43 PM) I don't see anything where you are telling me why the two statistics below provide inaccurate results: http://www.fangraphs.com/library/offense/ubr/ http://www.fangraphs.com/library/offense/wsb/ Are you referring to where you talked about the demoralizing effect of a killed rally? I thought wite pointed out that all kinds of outs kill rallies all the time, and that other types of outs occur drastically more frequently. What if Garcia pops one up because he swung at a bad pitch, that's still a mental error, right? And besides, how can you possibly make a claim as to quantifying an effect like that? It's one thing to suggest that it could be a factor, but entirely another to just decide that its effect is immense enough to make ADA the worst runner in White Sox history despite other evidence to the contrary. Taking human emotion out of the game is just silly. All outs are not created equally. That is a faulty assumption I don't agree with.
  3. QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 12:37 PM) It's interesting from the Sox perspective, but the Marlins would turn it down in a second. Even with Stanton in the lineup, the Marlins' team splits were .231/.293/.335/.627. Logan Morrison and Christian Yelich were their only two competent hitters. That team was just awful offensively. A trade like that probably never happens in real life, but that is the type of deal I would take for Chris Sale.
  4. QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 12:13 PM) The best hypothetical trade I've seen remains Stanton for Sale, and I still don't think I'd do that. Now that would be one worth talking about.
  5. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 11:46 AM) If you're going to call an objective measurement of something garbage, you should tell us why it's garbage and how your intuition and selective human memory are more accurate. Go back and read the rest of the posts.
  6. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 11:44 AM) No, I am serious. You are claiming 'the government' is 'punishing' people here because 'they' aren't getting 15% of funding. Who is doing the 'punishing' and how? Now you are just being obtuse on purpose.
  7. QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 10:55 AM) I was basically stating it for argument's sake, but seeing a guy who is held to that high of esteem struggle like that and pout isn't good for team morale. I also think arguing this is MOVING THE GOALPOSTS. Numbers and examples are brought into it and suddenly we start talking about something subjective like "demoralizing the team." Nobody can say what effect that has on a team, so you are going to disagree about any and all of this. I think De Aza scoring from 1st on a double has an energizing, positive effect on the team as well. I think Alexei making an error has a huge demoralizing effect. I think Dylan Axelrod giving up 12 runs a game has a demoralizing effect. How are we going to measure each of them individually? Which goes back to my point about the baserunning stat that shows De Aza as being a good base runner as being garbage.
  8. QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 11:42 AM) You suggest that as if it's a good return. Carlos Guillen hit .264/.335/.383/.718 with the Mariners, Freddy Garcia was an innings eater but, other than an incredible 2001, was pretty much your run of the mill #3 starter for them, and John Halama was a 27 year old soft-tossing lefty who was a virtual non-prospect at the time of the deal. The fact that he pitched as long as he did was a miracle. I hope you are not using that as an example of what the Sox should get for Sale, because even getting more than that would be incredibly disappointing. If nothing else, you've established exactly WHY you don't trade Chris Sale. The hope is that you get a package like the Orioles got for Bedard or the Marlins got for Beckett, but even those deals had their weak points. Fact is, the closest the White Sox will be to legitimately competing will come with Sale on the roster. If you want to stockpile the system, then sign a bunch of guys to one year contracts and don't be afraid to trade. I agree fully.
  9. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 11:42 AM) Can you explain how 'the government' is 'punishing' people here? Wait, what? You can't be serious.
  10. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 11:41 AM) I have no idea what you're talking about here. I know you don't. That is kind of the point.
  11. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 11:05 AM) The government is beholden to the people. More than can, I think we must have a robust federal government that provides many services to many people and which would be economically harmful if it were dismantled if we are to be a modern democratic state with a powerful economy. I see nothing bothersome about having a significantly large government such that substantial cuts to that government would cause real harm. Can you lay out a basic framework for the type of government you envision such that it's expenditures are insignificant to the economy as a whole? Except it isn't, and you can plainly see that by this demonstration of government power and control. The government is literally showing off its depth and breadth by punishing the people for not getting funding for a mere 15% of the government. The government shouldn't have the ability punish its own people in such a way, even in a theorhetical ideal, let alone reality.
  12. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 10:37 AM) Should have said "important" there. Regardless, few share your vision of a minimalist government that has a non-measurable impact on the national economy. I don't even know how that'd be possible for any country in the industrialized world, let alone for a country that's one of if not the most technologically advanced, has the world's largest economy and military, is physically as large as it is and has over 300 million inhabitants. I think we can do better than to have a population beholden to their federal government. If this demonstration of power and control hasn't bothered you, there isn't much point in discussion.
  13. QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 10:36 AM) It just boggles my mind why Konerko gets a free pass. I understand everything he's done for the organization, but it seems as though the organization is considering bringing him back to have a significant role on the team when he was the biggest culprit out of anyone in the organization last year. He was terrible offensively, defensively, and on the base paths, and he single handedly cost the Sox a ton. Say want you want about guys making outs on the base paths being demoralizing, but I think seeing the Captain throw temper tantrums after popping out is just as demoralizing. I don't buy that at all. Creating an extra out is going to kill way more than a guy throwing his bad and putting his head down after a popup.
  14. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 10:19 AM) I'm sorry that an overwhelming majority of people in our democratic society don't share your vision for a minimalist government, instead preferring a government that provides many essential services like national parks and funding for basic scientific research. National Parks are great. I use mine very regularly, but essential? Um, ok.
  15. QUOTE (GreatScott82 @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 10:15 AM) I'm calling it now... Don't be surprised if Sale is traded this winter. His value is absolutely beyond high right now and who knows just how much longer he will stay healthy with his current mechanics. My question for you guys is, If the White Sox can net three top 50 prospects and two mlb level position players (or something along those lines) would you pull that trigger? Chris Sale isn't going anywhere. Forget it.
  16. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 09:57 AM) This implies that cutting certain government programs/funding would, at best, not be detrimental to an economic and societal recovery. Given the context (sequester, shut down), it's a transparently bad argument; cutting funding or programs is obviously going to have a detrimental effect on society/economy. The only way it could be neutral or positive is if that money were instead shifted elsewhere (other programs, or tax cuts) and you could actually show the impacts. As it is, it just looks like a shallow argument that government doesn't do anything useful so who cares if it gets cut anyway. Which is exactly how it was set up. The government is now methadone to the American economy.
  17. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 09:51 AM) Which country in the modern era has not been dependent on a functional and robust government? I prefer all knowing and controlling to describe it.
  18. QUOTE (TaylorStSox @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 10:00 AM) There's a difference between being slow and running into outs every 6 games because of boneheaded decisions. De Aza was comically bad at times. Exactly. There really isn't any defending De Aza's baserunning this year.
  19. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 09:45 AM) I can think of two off the top of my head: Dayan Viciedo and Avisail Garcia. The point isn't that De Aza is awesome, it's the the whole team sucks, and most of the team sucks worse. Those of us who want this team to turn around quickly cannot also be advocating we replace De Aza before we replace Beckham, Flowers, Phegley, Viciedo, and Gillaspie, at least. I'm not even talking about dumping De Aza unless we find something better. I'm just saying he had a legendarily bad season on the basepaths. Comps for this year are Ozzie Guillen and Chet Lemon. That isn't pretty by any stretch.
  20. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 09:39 AM) Like 10? What about all the things he did right? EDIT: Ok, 11. Those 19 outs are balanced by 20 stolen bases. Doesn't seem like much of a balance to me. I don't see it is as a positive if you are giving your team an extra out for each stolen base you get.
  21. QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 09:39 AM) Chet Lemon for the wins. Seasons of 16, 15, 12, 12, and 11. Caruso's max was 6. BTW, the answer if people want to know out of the original group I checked was
  22. QUOTE (Al Lopez's Ghost @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 09:35 AM) I know that Chet Lemon ran into a lot of outs, but I'm gonna go with Mike Caruso. BTW I'm in the camp of "If De Aza is one of your regulars, you're real bad." Chet Lemon for the wins. Seasons of 16, 15, 12, 12, and 11. Caruso's max was 6.
  23. QUOTE (Jenksismyb**** @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 09:14 AM) I'll prepare to be flamed here repeatedly, but at some point, maybe it's ok that certain government programs/funding gets put on the back burner while the economy and our society in general heals from a pretty major blow in the recent past? Yes? Maybe? Just a little? I think the demonstration here should scare us more for seeing that just a 15% cut in governmental operations is hitting pretty much everyone in the country. Granted part of that is done on purpose to maximize the hit, but still, I can't figure out why no one is more concerned with the entire country pretty much being utterly dependent on the government these days. We need to be asking how it happened, and what we can do to fix it.
  24. QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 09:22 AM) Just for reference sake, I have been picking through current and former Sox players to see if I can find someone who managed to match or beat De Aza's season of stupidity. So far I have run through Pods, Rios, Alexei, Guillen, Rudy Law, and Claudell Washington. Only one guy has hit 11 times making outs on the basepaths like De Aza did this year. I'll let you guess as to who it was. Out of the top 10 base stealers this year (Ellsbury, Eric Young, Rajai Davis, Jean Segura, Andrus, Sterling Marte, Carlos Gomez, Everth Cabrera, and Leonys Martín) none have even a single season of 11 Outs on the Bases. Out of all of them there was one season of 10 in Carlos Gomez.
  25. QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 09:07 AM) Between the bad reads and horrible and regular baserunning mistakes, I feel pretty good about those statements, especially the baserunning. He killed more innings that I can remember seeing a Sox player do ever. Just for reference sake, I have been picking through current and former Sox players to see if I can find someone who managed to match or beat De Aza's season of stupidity. So far I have run through Pods, Rios, Alexei, Guillen, Rudy Law, and Claudell Washington. Only one guy has hit 11 times making outs on the basepaths like De Aza did this year. I'll let you guess as to who it was.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.