Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

southsider2k5

Admin

Everything posted by southsider2k5

  1. QUOTE (pittshoganerkoff @ Oct 15, 2013 -> 10:19 AM) Right. And that's where a guy that makes mistakes ends up sitting because of those mistakes. That's a part of coaching, too. It's tough, but there will come a time (and maybe that time has already come) where he's told to get his head out of his ass and utilize his tools and make a difference. In a key situation (such down one in the 9th inning kind of stuff) I would send a guy with less speed out there who I knew wouldn't get picked off or doubled off, versus a guy who could get me a run, but could cost me the game just as easily.
  2. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 15, 2013 -> 10:16 AM) But I think that's the point -- there's still value there. Those of us arguing in favor aren't saying that ADA is an elite baserunner, we're just pointing out that his positives mathematically outweigh his negatives. He can both be a mentally poor baserunner and still provide substantial baserunning value. This is important because the context of the argument is that ADA's poor baserunning is something that must be replaced with high priority, and the results just don't line up with that notion. I have never said that.
  3. QUOTE (pittshoganerkoff @ Oct 15, 2013 -> 10:15 AM) Well, this is a no brainer, and you don't need advanced statistics to tell you to put De Aza in. However, to play the devil's (SS2K5) advocate, what if you had De Aza and Leury Garcia on the bench, and even though their stats match up you've seen De Aza picked off first base a few times and get a few bad jumps and consequently kill a few rallies, who do you put in the game? I'm personally not a fan of advanced statistics...let me rephrase that...I don't know much about them and haven't made an effort to do much research. But advanced stats aside, De Aza is a fairly valuable player due to his decent hitting and good speed. He has made some bad decisions and has looked dumb on the basepads at times. But that's the kind of thing that can be coached. You can't as easily coach a slow runner to be faster. I like De Aza, and for his price he's fine in the outfield (preferably LF). It's ludicrous to say the guy has no value because he makes mistakes. You take him for his tools and you coach the mistakes. From what I have seen, Garcia would be out there over De Aza in a heartbeat. Granted at this point it is limited samplesize.
  4. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 15, 2013 -> 10:13 AM) I don't understand what you're arguing here. You made an attack on the credibility of the numbers I was referring to, and I attempted to demonstrate credibility for them. By showing me that they are flawed, and perpetually being fixed, yet can't have missed this one particular standard.
  5. QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Oct 15, 2013 -> 10:12 AM) People meet annually to tweak them, to improve them. As is, they are still pretty damn accurate. Here are the top 30 in order from this past season (min 200 PAs): Jacoby Ellsbury Rajai Davis Eric Young Elvis Andrus Mike Trout Alcides Escobar Alex Rios Starling Marte Jarrod Dyson Daniel Murphy Everth Cabrera Adam Jones Carlos Gomez Coco Crisp Hunter Pence Nate McLouth Leonys Martin Craig Gentry Emilio Bonaficio Justin Upton Carlos Gonzalez Austin Jackson Andrew McCutchen Desmond Jennings Carl Crawford Juan Pierre Alex Gordon Drew Stubbs Christian Yelich Alexei Ramirez If you won't agree that those are the 30 best base runners in the league, can you at least acknowledge that those are 30 of the most valuable - in most cases, this does mean fastest - base runners in the league? Out of the ones I looked up the other day out of that list, none had as many base running mistakes as De Aza, so it would make sense that they would hold more value.
  6. QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Oct 15, 2013 -> 10:05 AM) Isnt it pretty much a guarantee that once a RB has a 2000 yard year, that the fall off is steep and dramatic? I could have sworn i read something that showed that once a RB crosses that line, chances are they will not be the same again. It has only happened like half a dozen times, right? It is hard to repeat that sort of performance for sure.
  7. QUOTE (iamshack @ Oct 15, 2013 -> 10:02 AM) Look, I'm all for being reasonable here...and surely many advanced statistics are not perfectly fine-tuned. But to dismiss them outright because there may be some flaws is ridiculous. I don't know why you seem to be holding on to this line of reasoning because we all know you are smarter than that. Let me put it this way. If we were in a postseason game, tied, in the 9th inning, and PK singles or doubles with less than two outs, and you have De Aza on the bench...would you not pinch run him for PK? I'm holding on to the idea because it doesn't pass the common sense test. If the stat made sense, it would be much easier to accept.
  8. QUOTE (Quinarvy @ Oct 15, 2013 -> 09:15 AM) I posted some deals I'd accept for Sale last time this was brought up... Diamondbacks I'm asking Skaggs, Eaton, Owings, Davidson, Holmberg, Trahan. Pirates I'm asking Tallion, Cole, Polanco, and Hanson. Cardinals I'm asking Wacha, Martinez, Taveras, Adams, and Wong. Red Sox I'm asking Bogaerts, Bradley, Owens, Ranuado, and Cecchini/Brentz Orioles I'm asking Bundy, Britton, Rodriguez, Schoop, and Harvey. The price for Sale is high, astronomical, unprecedented. A team like the Orioles would have to take Dunn. The Cards Alexei. The Pirates Alexei and De Aza. There is a price to get it done, but no team wants to pay it. I'll be honest, if I am not getting a young superstar bat, I am not trading Chris Sale. Basically I want his equivalent as a hitter. I want Stanton. I want Trout. I don't want prospects.
  9. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 15, 2013 -> 12:29 AM) This is the most backwards thing I've ever heard. You start with a conclusion, then try to find something that supports it. When you find nothing, instead of considering changing your conclusion, you just say everyone else is wrong. All I've been doing is pointing out that these numbers DO take all the things into consideration that you have assumed they don't. The fact that you keep asserting different missing things that actually ARE factored in tells me you still haven't tried to actually understand it. Because if you did, you'd know about them. As opposed to you flat out telling me that these statistics are so accurate, that people have to meet annually to fix them, but that there can't be any bias or error in the statistics related to something that they aren't quantifying correct? Please.
  10. southsider2k5 replied to knightni's topic in SLaM
    http://m.yahoo.com/w/ygo-frontpage/lp/stor...amp;.lang=en-us
  11. QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Oct 15, 2013 -> 08:39 AM) 12 years in the life of a 27 year old is a long time. First and foremost, it's just under half of what they've currently lived, but if they have kids, they don't get to see them grow up, and if they don't have kids, then they probably will never have kids at that point. It's not some in and out over the weekend because you got caught drinking and driving. I hate to see that risk minimized. In my mind it is more dangerous than a bar fight.
  12. More at link http://www.forbes.com/sites/theapothecary/...ans-true-costs/
  13. QUOTE (scs787 @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 09:42 PM) I'm friends with Reddy on fb but I don't think we've ever talked since he tried to get me back into the whole beachbody thing. From what I can tell we have a lot of pretty rad people here that I wouldn't mind meeting up with, but I don't know how to "get to that point" with people I've never met in person. Someone mentioned a softball game, do you guys do that annually? I'd be interested. We had done a game against WSI a couple of times in the past. Only like five people showed up from Soxtalk, so we hadn't done it since. I think it has been like three-ish years since we did it. If we got interest from a bunch of people, no reason why we couldn't try to do something again.
  14. QUOTE (iamshack @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 07:10 PM) As for the linear weights argument, it's pretty much just math, guys. It's used because it's math, and math works. And for De Aza, he's NOT a good runner of the bases, as that phrase or skill is commonly understood to mean. But he's still fast! And those two things are not mutually exclusive. A runner can be of average speed or even slow but still be a good base runner. A runner can have blazing speed but still be a terrible base runner. But when you add up the speed ability and the technique/baseball IQ, you can still have someone that creates value as a runner but still not be a particular good "runner of the bases" as we commonly understand the phrase. When you have a season that is that bad, it cancels out value. Outs on the bases kill teams and games.
  15. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 07:02 PM) But they do! lol That's what I'm trying to say. Most of the innovators of linear weights-based statistics in the early 2000's are or have been employed by Major League teams. Tom Tango. Paul Depodesta. Russel Carleton. Voros McCracken. Dayn Perry. Dan Szymborski. Alex Anthopolous. All of these guys were working and/or consulting for teams when they were BUILDING their advanced metrics departments. When you interview the former guys they all say something along the lines of, "yeah everyone has their own constants, but it's all based around the same types of math." Why don't you just read up on some of it and make an informed decision? I don't understand the reluctance to learn about stuff. I mean I respect your opinions, it just doesn't mean much for you to dismiss something without giving it a chance. Linear weights like changed the way I looked at player valuation. It's so exciting how much sense it makes and how cool it is to be able to find a common denominator for comparing guys. Your version of "read up on stuff" isn't helping. It keeps bouncing back and forth between different points and then swearing that I am misunderstanding them when I call them out. It essentially turns into this thing where you can't have any eye test at all, despite the obvious fault here of crediting De Aza as a positive influence through his base running last year. The common denominator is faulty if it is rewarding De Aza for his performance last year.
  16. QUOTE (SCCWS @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 05:49 PM) So if Sale is an injury waiting to happen, why would a GM offer 3 top 50 prospects for him??? Remember all the great prospects "fans" thought Peavy would bring?? Well the Red Sox turned down Peavy for Bradley. If Sale is an endangered species as some feel, he will not bring back a windfall. Therefore I expect to see him in a White Sox uniform next spring ready to win 20 games next year. BIG difference between Chris Sale and Jake Peavy. Pretty much in every single way shape and form, Chris Sale blows away the worth of Jake Peavy.
  17. QUOTE (Rowand44 @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 04:21 PM) Ok sorry, rumblings from fans and mystery sources. Just making a point really that the Sox wont come out and say they use or don't use a specific stat just as they wont come out and claim they're trying to upgrade from De Aza. Why else would they want to dump De Aza? His offensive output is actually pretty nice. It is absolutely because of his defensive and base running IQ.
  18. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 04:27 PM) Right, because there couldn't possibly be any other reason that would want to trade him other than they think he's totally garbage. And the newspaper media has NEVER made something up for an article, because they are never ever fed inaccurate or partially accurate information from sources inside baseball. Everything they say is totally true and always happens. I'm not talking about fans. Fans are you and me. When you say, "any stat that says ADA is good at baserunning is flawed, period," THAT'S fans talking. These are professionals who make a living by analyzing baseball, and dozens of them get picked off to be consultants and analysts for baseball teams. These are people that pioneered and invented the stats that have birthed the latest publicly available versions. With all due respect, so what. If it isn't deemed valuable by baseball teams, what value does it really have? Tell me that teams are using it, then I will agree with your statements about "widely accepted" etc. People with no connection to the game don't really matter as much as the teams making the actual decisions. If teams aren't using these specific stats, it tells me they think other measures have more value.
  19. QUOTE (Rowand44 @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 04:18 PM) Rumblings from fans, nothing out of the organization. Everyone would be fine with upgrading from De Aza, it's just not as easy to do as some people seem to believe. What organization public states it is trying to dump its own players?
  20. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 04:00 PM) Who knows? Franchises don't tell anyone what they use. But linear weights metrics are the basis of the research done by tons of analysts that have been hired by teams over the years, from FG guys like Matt Swartz (Orioles) to BP scouts like Kevin Goldstein (Astros). There are no less than three conferences per years led by organizations like the Society for American Baseball Research and Baseball America where these statistics are unveiled, discussed, and scrutinized. Dave Cameron and several FanGraphs staff are at the forefront of much of this. Their particular set of constants and formulae are among the most popular in existence, and are particularly useful in relation to Baseball References formulae because FG prioritizes accuracy over completeness whereas BR does the opposite, giving us a wide palette of different angles from which to reference in a field that is difficult to predict. I'm not challenging your opinion, I'm challenging you to take a look at this stuff before you form your opinion. It's fine if you ultimately don't agree with it, but at least try to make sense of it before you decide it's BS. I don't honestly care what baseball fans think. I care if the organizations think it is worthy, and then you actually have hit your standard of "widely accepted" and "state of the art". If not, their opinions aren't any more widely accepted than the "eye test " group out there in baseball today. If the Sox felt those numbers were an accurate representation of De Aza's true value, there wouldn't be rumblings of them looking to upgrade his spot.
  21. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 03:47 PM) According to what? Make an argument for it. It isn't good enough for you to just say "because I think so." Show me why the widely accepted state-of-the-art measurement is wrong. By the way, I'm not being rhetorical. People are always questioning these things with reasoned arguments, and it drives them to constantly improve the stats. Show me where this is "widely accepted" and "state of the art". How many franchises use this number for anything of substance, such as game planning and utilization of their base running strategies.
  22. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 03:29 PM) Yet you clearly have no idea how it works, because you keep accusing it of not taking factors into consideration that it DOES take into consideration. How can you be against something you don't know about? How do you know it makes no sense in reality? If the stat states that De Aza was a good baserunner, it makes no sense in reality. Period.
  23. QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 03:00 PM) If someone calls and says they're interested in Chris Sale, you don't hang up the phone. No team should ever do that. What you do say is that it's going to be incredibly difficult for us to deal him and no matter what your proposal is, we will have to take a lot of time to contemplate it. Beyond that, I really don't think trading him for prospects is the best option simply due to the flame out rates of prospects. The most interesting trade in theory is one for Trout, because the Angels could actually use a big arm like that with their outfield depth. The problem is that you have to include more than just Sale because Trout is that good. You may be able to take a flier on a guy like Tommy Hanson, even if the Angels might DFA him anyways. So, would you guys trade Sale and Santiago for Trout and Hanson? In a heartbeat.
  24. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 03:10 PM) Why are you assuming that people think all outs have the same value? That's why these stats are based on linear weights. Run values are produced based on the weighted differences in base/out states. For example, if De Aza is caught stealing with 2 outs and a runner on third, it's far more harmful than if he's caught stealing (or picked off) with the bases otherwise empty and no outs. All that stuff is baked in, league adjusted and updated every season based on changes in the run environment. The only thing that isn't here is the "emotional impact' on the rest of the team. It seems like the only people that are against these stats are those who haven't taken the time to understand them. I'm against ones that make no sense in reality.
  25. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Oct 14, 2013 -> 02:43 PM) What's the alternative? If we can measure 80% of something and assume that the rest is unpredictable, we have a much more useful picture than "10 mistakes is a lot! No it's not a lot! Yeah but they were big mistakes! No they were medium mistakes! They cost us the whole season because everyone got depressed!" You're essentially choosing to measure nothing at all as an alternative. All outs are not created equally. Any stat that pretends they are is flawed. Pretending that base running mistakes are somehow equal to an infield pop up is just silly. Saying it can't be quantified so therefore it can't be factored isn't good enough either. There is obviously an effect, otherwise it wouldn't be talked about as much as it does when compared to other outs. Common sense tells you that.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.