Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

caulfield12

Members

Everything posted by caulfield12

  1. And gave up solid prospects for him, too. Every Sox decade needs an Alex Rios/Javy V. type player that scouts fall in love with…but actual results on the field inevitably end up leaving fans disappointed.
  2. Overpaid for Castillo and now May. Sox just don't learn to wait out second and third tier markets until the last week or two and even into ST. Did the same with Grandal. Did the same with Robertson/Cabrera. Did the same with LaRoche. Or wait too long and get stuck with "bargain" Dallas Keuchel after his expiration date because they refused to pay for TOR frontline guys. But but but look how being the last one standing for Murakami and the Peters deals worked out so well…patience is a virtue!
  3. https://brewerfanatic.com/forums/topic/48780-may-to-white-sox-3-yrs-525-m/#comments "A good reminder of why the Brewers don’t sign free agents, especially EARLY in the off season (when the bargains aren't there, and overpays abound). I thought Dustin May would work out for us, at least better than he did. My inkling is that whatever adjustments we tried to make with him just weren’t sticking and he ended up performing worse for us than he did with the Cardinals. I hope he pitches well for the White Sox." "May just got more money than Bauers... Let that one sink in. 😬 Yes, he is 2 years younger and Bauers is a risk for regressing... but May doesn't have anything but "potential" (i.e. a big arm) and no real history of results to back him up. The cost of starting pitching... woof"
  4. Brewers board is baffled...totally worth a read It's the prize behind the puzzle. If you are built like a big leaguer and have the physical tools of a big leaguer ... teams can't help themselves believing they can be the one to unlock you. I'll never forget sitting and talking with a White Sox scout during a TBRays game in the early 2000s. We had a guy on the team named Mike Wilson, outfielder. Built like a middle linebacker. He struggled early season and was striking out a ton, not getting on base. But when he connected with one he hit it over Hwy 41. We had another outfielder on that team named Sebastien Boucher. Canadian kid, centerfielder. I thought he was awesome. Dylan O'Rae type of hitter, not a ton of power but all fields and was always on base. He matched Asdrubal Cabrera's production day in and day out. This guy wasn't giving Boucher a 2nd look because "not a MLB body, he won't make it". But he was salivating over Wilson. "He will be able to withstand the grind" "Major league fastballs won't intimidate him". He could have cared less about the at bat to at bat results ... he was looking for a body that could be put into the machine. May is 6'6 and has a tool bag that should dazzle. Whoever unlocks it has a TOR guy. Can anyone unlock it is the question. Most want to try."
  5. https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7789996/2026/11/17/dustin-may-mlb-signing-analysis-white-sox/
  6. The betting line would probably be around a 2 fWAR. That's pretty much in line with his salary...but does he stay healthy enough to get there??? Pedestrian move, overall. Just like throwing darts against the wall, except Castillo and May aren't exactly at bargain basement prices. Guardians never do this deal in a million years. There's just no way that if Ishbia were coming in as owner it would be any other option than Skubal King Peralta or at least Taira from a marketing/lower cost but fascinating acquisition angle (since Imai Sasaki and Imanaga mixed results push down his value a bit.)
  7. Wegner must be in charge now...
  8. To finish the year, though. He's going to be 37 and a solid regresion candidate if you look at overall track record over last 3-4 years. Definitely buying high here.
  9. That ONLY leaves Skubal King Peralta Rogers Taira (mixed bag)...not so sure about Holmes.
  10. Braden Montgomery...errr Brandon did it
  11. Are they now? Not really...sort of nibbling around the edges. Itoh aka Sugano Jr. next?
  12. Too many additional Hail Mary's, Our Fathers and Glory Be's.
  13. Keuchel and TLR's fave Meat/Potatoes extended after Dunning trade? Murakami? Danks or Buehrle? Grandal?
  14. Brewers sort of "fixed" and the McKinven's/Roffe's of Sox probably got all kinds of recommendations from various connections with MIL to vouch for him as a teammate, aka chemistry fit. Needed an organization that would basically guarantee him a consistent starter's slot in the rotation. Pitching is still dear, as they say in economics. At least in FA. One has the feeling JR would probably prefer the other starter to come via trade or Taylor and/or internal candidates. Burke May Martin Castillo/Kay (takes over Newcomb role?) Taylor The usual cast...Schultz Sandlin Thorpe McDougal (starter or pen)
  15. If only you had the Mays and Castillos of 4-5 years ago in terms of arm talent...that would truly be something. And Castillo's durability/doggedness.
  16. “If you're a team that has a lot of bat-to-ball skills, you can handle a little bit of swing-and-miss,” the executive said. “If you have a lot of swing-and-miss, you might be a little more averse to bringing on somebody like that. We’ve certainly seen guys adapt to our game here, which gives you reason to be more optimistic about the next guy translating to success.” mlb.com on bringing Japanese hitters like Murakami Sato and Okamoto to the States
  17. Probably had no other similar options. Or wanted to erase Boston Marathon/Red Sox City Connect Massacre day game memories.
  18. Three he must prefers the West Coast...family roots and all.
  19. https://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/article/yankees-reportedly-re-sign-lefty-reliever-tim-hill-to-1-year-225-million-deal-221804576.html Ex Sox castoff Tim Hill with Yankees Thanksgiving Week won't provide as much time off to GM's interested in Sato Taira Itoh...
  20. Pitching staff was toast. Batters turned to deer in the headlights after that bad Meidroth at bat when they could have broken the game open.
  21. Started to wear down against James Cook Somehow Purdy’s making it work with CMC Kittle Samuel Watkins K.Allen…guess Evan’s will be next one back Chiefs’ offense looked dominant with Downs as E.Johnson had a monster game for one of the early MVP candidates in Walker
  22. Like moving from StL to East St Louis Maybe not that bad, as area by the speedway and concert venue and minor league baseball stadium is at least nicer than Hammond IN
  23. More affordable/realistic.
  24. SICorey Seager Trade Destinations: Best Fits for Rangers St...The Rangers may be looking to offload Corey Seager this offseason, and there are a handful of teams that make sense as possible landing spots.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.