Giving up 6 hits in 3 innings is not bad luck. Besides the Pujols hit, the others were struck solidly.
Peavy isn't good anymore. Without the wipeout slider he had in SD, he's just another guy.
Dye
Rios
Beckham
Alexi
AJ
Dayan
Brian Anderson
Joe Crede
Juan Uribe
All these guys would swing at anything. There are others, but I think that's good enough to make my point.
Most of our lineup swings at everything and anything. That's why we have such a low team OBP, which therefore leads to inconsistent run production. It isn't that difficult.
Low OBP sluggers have been the model since KW took over.