WestEddy

And don't promote any of the name prospects if those 4 aren't cooking. "These are the Glengarry prospects. And to you they're gold, and you don't get them. Why? Because to give them to you would be throwing them away."

Never in this whole string have I said "...compared to other pitchers". When Crochet pitched at the Arizona complex, he threw actual innings to actual hitters that aren't logged on Baseball-Reference.com. This is getting tiresome, old ladies pretending the Sox are wheeling a hospital bed out to the mound for Crochet to throw the first pitch he's ever thrown in his life.

So you agree that saying Garret Crochet threw only 12 or 24 innings last year is nonsense. I'm glad we got that out of the way.

As has been pointed out, a pitcher starts rehabbing about 2 months after surgery. Please post his doctor's medical opinion, or just stop.

If a pitcher is throwing MLB innings, they're not in Arizona throwing complex games. So, no, it isn't.

Nicky Lopez has played 1B for 18 innings of his career.

Which, if it happens, would have happened as a starter or reliever. He had shoulder inflammation last year during his rehab stint.

I just read somewhere in the last few days that signing a player to a multi-year contract before their debut nullifies the ROY draft reward.

McGreevy is their #14 ranked prospect. https://www.mlb.com/prospects/cardinals/

HE'S ONLY THROWN 63 INNINGS IN THE LAST 2 YEARS!!! OMG!!! IRRESPONSIBLE!!!

I understand that this place gets so reflexively negative, even sober takes on the reality of this team are seen as happy talk. But if you don't have a dream, how you gonna have a dream come true?

I don't like Grifol. He reminds me of Bevington. But he should be obsessed with turning this team around. https://chicago.suntimes.com/white-sox/2024/03/29/pedro-grifol-obsessed-with-turning-white-sox-around

Didn't Bill James disprove the "base clogger" meme? Like, there's a level of base running proficiency, or non-proficiency, that detracts from a player's production. If he's on 2nd, and can only make it to 3rd on a double, that's bad. But I think Vaughn's OBP would outweigh his inability to score from 2nd on a single. And seriously, watching this team in spring training, they have to put 5 guys on base safely to score a run. They're already station to station. Get more guys who can reach first, then worry about unclogging the base paths.

Point being, it's not accurate to say that Crochet only threw 24 innings in 2023.

The arguments can be made that Crochet doesn't have the long term wear and tear that a normal starter would, and that Crochet might just fare better on a 5-day program rather than the chaotic, up-and-down schedule of a reliever. And the innings totals everybody's quoting are just the innings that have been reported in regulation games. There are whole seasons worth of games played at their Alternate training site that never get logged. Spring training. B games. So none of the 79, 91 or 132 totals are accurate.

edit.

Along with Cory Knebel and Joe Barlow. I haven't seen any news of those two opting out.

I think Carlos Perez will get most of those innings at 1B. He was listed as an infielder elsewhere. They might even cycle one or two of the OFs through 1B. Tim Elko is conspicuous in his absence.

No Terrell Tatum, Yoelqui Cespedes, Jake Eder or Ky Bush, either. AA, A+ & A opening days are April 5.

No Nick Nastrini. https://www.milb.com/charlotte-knights/roster

Did you read the section I was quoting? He said, "The Sox braintrust doesn't exactly inspire confidence that they will manage his innings to maximize said immense talent for that matter either." The Sox are currently bringing a few higher profile players back from injury. I understand the "doesn't inspire confidence" line is just reflexive, but they are showing extreme care in other situations, which leads me to believe they are in this case, too.

Do you feel the White Sox are rushing Noah Schultz?

I'd imagine he doesn't throw more than 90 innings this season.

So, let me get this straight. The only way to rehab from TJS is to throw in real baseball games. And to not throw a lot of innings. He did that, but it was too aggressive. Are you actually saying that it should take 4 years to come back from TJS? You know, you could just admit you're wrong, instead of trying to rewrite all of medical history.

Maybe Maldonado accepts being a coach, and maybe they decide they can deal with the diminished defense during LHP starts, and Grossman's in the OF. DeJong will be here until Monty wrests the position away.