QUOTE (HickoryHuskers @ Sep 12, 2012 -> 07:36 AM)
You have to remember that those splits are AVERAGES. That does not mean that a terrible LH/SW hitter like Johnson, Hudson or Olmedo is going to fare better than a good RH hitter like Youk or Konerko. You might be able to sell me on starting Danks over Viciedo, but no way do I want to see Johnson, Hudson, or Olmedo starting against any pitcher no matter what his splits are.
The splits are cumulative and they say that a LH batter has a significantly better chance of reaching base than a RH. We don't weight splits by if a player is "bad" or not because that's subjective and hence dumb. You're also ignorant to the fact that Youkilis is sporting a hot .208 BA against RHP. What a good hitter!
QUOTE (HickoryHuskers @ Sep 12, 2012 -> 08:56 AM)
Dan Johnson's last 476 AB in AAA (2012): .879 OPS
Jordan Danks' last 218 AB in AAA (2012): .945 OPS
Dan Johnson's last 91 AB in MLB (2011-12): .443 OPS
Jordan Danks' last 57 AB in MLB (2012): .556 OPS
If you aren't willing to start Danks over Youkilis or Konerko, then you sure as hell shouldn't be willing to start Johnson over Youkilis or Konerko.
Spot the sample size bias, everyone!