Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Chisoxfn

Admin
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Chisoxfn

  1. QUOTE (Tony82087 @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 08:40 PM) If that is the actual package, they didn't sell the farm off for Samardzija, although I'm not seeing what apparently others do in Marcus. It seems like the Sox are ready to spend. If that's the case this team could be set up quite well, Out of the two players, Danish has more upside, imo and given his delivery and where he is, he's still far away. Semien will be a solid player with upside of slightly above average. I don't think he'll be more then that and I could see him being below average as well. All that said, I liked Semien, but that is the type of guy you are willing to move, especially from an area that this org has significant depth in. I still think we should sign Shark to an extension and this is coming from someone usually very anti longer term deals with a pitcher, however, he seems willing to take a hometown discount and if he is and will do a deal in the 5 yr neighborhood (sub 100M) then its a no brainer, imo. Now our next all-in deal will be an outfielder/closer. I'd say something like Rasmus short term would be most realistic but maybe we'll see a classic Kenny move and Sox will acquire Kemp or Upton.
  2. QUOTE (Chilihead90 @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 08:39 PM) We were at like $63M before Duke ($5M), and LaRoche ($12M), which puts us at about $80M I believe. I still think we will move Viciedo.
  3. QUOTE (Chilihead90 @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 08:26 PM) If that #5 pitcher has a 0 WAR all season and is considered replacement value. Lets look at this another way, Kershaw was 21-3 with a WAR of 7.5. Did the average starter who made as few starts as Kershaw, did the average replacement level starter win that many games? I know there are other aspects that contribute but then go as far as the average winning percentage, etc. I don't know the answer just posing the thought. However, I'd also point out that you can't just add WAR's and say that is how many more games you will actually win.
  4. QUOTE (fathom @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 08:30 PM) You don't sign LaRoche and trade for Samardzija and go into the season without an established closer. If we don't sign an established closer, then heads should roll, haha. We have zero people we can count on in-house. I still don't get why we'd spend all that money on Duke when guys like Miller got more years and more money but not that much more from an AAV perspective.
  5. Shark doesn't exactly fill our closer need, if anything, it makes the need to add other talent far more significant. If you sign Shark to an extension, you can be less aggressive with other roster holes cause you have a longer opportunity. If you don't, then you can't make a trade like the Shark trade without addressing spending money / making other moves to address other concerns (e.g., outfield + closer).
  6. We know Sox had been tied to Upton rumors in the past and I am sure at a minimum, they will be inquiring now. Would think the price in a package deal w/Johnson would be cheaper.
  7. I wonder if Rasmus or Melky + a closer are in our future as well.
  8. QUOTE (staxx @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 08:22 PM) Let's not overvalue our prospects. A legit #2 for Danish/Semien is a relative small price to pay. See Russell, Addison. Russell was a much steeper price. Top 10 prospect in all of baseball for two guys who aren't top 100 prospects, albeit I do believe Semien / Danish both will have major league careers. Still, until we see official you just never know who may / may not get swapped out. All I know is the deal seems very fair if it is that, and if we sign him to an extension, then it moves up in my book. If we let him walk, it will be disappointing because this should be about how we can make ourselves better for our extended window. We are not in a position to give up multiple prospects for a rental unless we have some other major moves out there (I am fine giving up one piece like Semien cause it is replaceable but three quality aspects for a rental would be a bit different). I will say that if Shark is pitching well and we weren't in contention, Sox maybe presume they could then move him for another piece but I have to hope this is much more about signing him to an extension. If we don't sign him to an extension, we better have another outfielder in mind + we absolutely need a closer.
  9. QUOTE (SoxAce @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 08:20 PM) If that deal is correct, I can see why bucket said some might not like it. Sign the Shark to an extension! Do it!
  10. Interesting. I am curious to see who goes with Semien but presuming Semien is the centerpiece and the other name is lesser, you can sign me up all day as being thrilled. Next step sign him to an extension and sign us a closer. I prefer K-Rod to Robertson. Presume we can get K-Rod on a shorter term deal.
  11. QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 02:56 PM) By fWAR, the answer is no. League average is right around 2 WAR. Gordon's rookie year was the only time he even eclipsed 1 WAR: http://www.fangraphs.com/statss.aspx?playe...amp;position=2B Well than...in that case, consistent with my posts, I always knew he stunk, haha.
  12. Been waiting to hear this name and I think he's a tremendous fit. If we intend to compete / try to compete, we absolutely need to sign a closer, imo.
  13. That is really really interesting.
  14. QUOTE (Rowand44 @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 02:42 PM) I also LOVE the idea of somehow getting Reddick added to this. Not sure what that would do to the cost to bring Jeff in but I believe adding a top defender in the outfield would do wonders for this team. Agree Shark and Reddick would be great additions.
  15. QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 01:54 PM) If the White Sox are an example to follow, then that's not exactly true. Seems to me that in the past 10 years, the Sox have had several front of the rotation starters but only had one above average 2B during that entire time frame in Tadahito Iguchi. People saying that it's easy or that it's not as important have yet to really win me over with that argument. Frankly, if Semien is dealt, the Sox are looking at Carlos Sanchez and Micah Johnson as the internal candidates at 2B. Those two were both less than impressive at both AAA and the MLB, depending on where either ended up. All we can say at this point is we'll see. Technically, outside of this past year, wasn't Gordon Beckham pretty close to a league average 2B (when factoring in his defense)? Slightly below average, but close?
  16. QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 01:20 PM) People keep claiming that 2B is one that is the least impactful or least important. Why? I'd like to understand the reasoning behind that because I sure don't understand it. And then I'd point out that Robinson Cano signed a 10 year, $240 million deal. I believe the Mariners overpaid, but that was a franchise that surely felt that 2B was not the least important position on the field and they almost clinched a Wild Card spot last year and are in great position to do so this year. Most people reacted extremely negative to that deal because it was less important / less impactful. Bottom line is a league average 2B is not near as productive / valuable as say a league average cf'er, etc. Basically put, standards are less. Is it easier to find a league average centerfielder or a league average catcher? I know someone will say, league average is league average, however, I tend to view it from the standpoint, guys with less tools, less overall credentials, prospect status, etc, have a higher probability of being league average at say catcher / 2B than other positions. A lot of that, in regards to 2B, is driven by the fact that the position doesn't require as many tools or as good of tools to succeed than other positions. Cano signed for such big money (and if you remember, it was significantly more then any other team offered) because the Mariners needed to overpay to sign him but they also needed to drastically change their culture and try to find a bat that could play in that stadium. Cano is a very special hitter and will go down as one of, if not, the greatest 2B to ever play the game and even than, I don't know that long term that deal will be all that great and it was an extreme overpay by a team who had to, to bring in an impact bat and try to drive a contender. Sox also have 4 guys who could potentially play 2B as well.
  17. QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 01:15 PM) Because it takes one idiot team to make sure you don't get the player back. Exactly. If all you had to pay to get Shark now (a season earlier and when you have exclusive rights to negotiate with him), was a guy like Semien, you do it and not worry. Heck, even if it was a year earlier than when the club intended to contend, I'd do it, however, with guys like Abreu, Sale and Q and the general value they bring, now is the time to look to contend and start our window. Is this year aggressive, sure, but there is no reason with that sort of front of the rotation, you can't be in the picture. Favorite...no, but possible, certainly.
  18. QUOTE (iamshack @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 01:11 PM) I don't know if I agree with the bolded...it's too early to say Marcus couldn't be a special player. That said, I'd move Semien for Shark but not Anderson. I think Semien has a chance to be an average to slightly above average ball player. My view of that is because he doesn't have insane power at the position, doesn't show the ability to win a batting title, and doesn't play premium defense or play a premium position. He does have the chance to be an above average offensive player, but "special", perennial all star, I don't think so. I think Tim Anderson has a chance to be the games best offensive player at a premium position (meaning..best offensive shortstop in the game...not best offensive player in the game). Book is still out there on his defense and I'm not saying it will happen, however, Anderson is an explosive athlete with a big time hit tool. He is still extremely raw so bust factor is high as well. Just my 2 cents, but we obviously agree in general on willingness to move Semien for Shark. Plus, like I mentioned earlier, we also have significant organizational depth at 2B (in terms of guys who have a shot at being serviceable players at a cheap cost).
  19. QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 01:07 PM) Ultimately I probably would trade Semien for Samardzija, but I'd try and take about every avenue possible to avoid it. On the long list of players I won't trade, Semien is far from the top, as is Micah Johnson. Why...because we have two of them, plus Saladino and Sanchez. All four of these guys have flaws in their game and none of them, with the possible exception of Johnson (because I overrate speed) has a chance of being a total impact maker at their position. I think all of them have somewhat of a chance of being a league average player at one of the least important / impactful positions in the game. And we are literally saying we won't trade that person for a starting pitcher, one who might be overrated by some, but with low mileage, plus stuff, and who has been taking positive steps forward the past couple years and a guy that I could project to be better 3 years from now vs. now (when he is already above league average and would, on our team, be arguably, the best 3rd starter in baseball). Come on now.
  20. QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 01:06 PM) Like I said, the only way this deal proposal makes sense for the Whtie Sox is if for some reason Billy Beane accepts a "he should have hung up the phone" offer, and even then it's still confusing. Except you seem to think a Semien for Shark offer is absurd for the Sox and I am telling you that is a hang-up the phone type offer for Beane.
  21. QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 12:59 PM) So basically trading for Samardzija makes sense if Billy Beane forgets to call 28 other teams and gives him to us for a huge discount. If you "fully expect the white sox to make a run at signing him to an extension", why on Earth would you give up anything in a trade for that guy unless you have a competitive roster this year? Again hitting my point, this makes no sense. If were going to blow 9 figures on a pitcher, just go add Shields. PS: I just saw the insaneness of the 2nd part of your post. Why trade for Shark and sign him now, when you could wait a year and sign him as a FA? Well, one, we are playing and designing a plan to be a contending team this year (and a top 3 of Sale / Q / Shark is as good as any in baseball) and two, that price of an extension might be significantly more expensive with Shark on the open market vs. shark today. You have far more teams competing for him, etc. I will continue to say that your style / approach is to only have guys who are more valuable then their contract, never anything less, and under your scenario's, we either give at bats to guys who are young and may or may not have talent (as you don't know unless you give them like 3 years worth of at bats given your general approach to patience) and surround that with guys who you sign to one year deals coming off lousy previous years but with good stuff...who may or may not rebound...you will hit on a few, fail on others, and continuously be a horrific ball club. Edit: Okay I give, we might not be horrific, but we will never win a world series / be a consistent contender with that approach.
  22. QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 12:57 PM) It makes a LOT better in the rotation, unless you believe in Chris Bassitt, or Andre Rienzo over JS. Even once Carlos Rodon is up, Hector Noesi is next in line. That front three of the rotation is as good as any team in baseball.
  23. QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 12:59 PM) So basically trading for Samardzija makes sense if Billy Beane forgets to call 28 other teams and gives him to us for a huge discount. If you "fully expect the white sox to make a run at signing him to an extension", why on Earth would you give up anything in a trade for that guy unless you have a competitive roster this year? Again hitting my point, this makes no sense. If were going to blow 9 figures on a pitcher, just go add Shields. You are the guy that said you wouldn't trade Semien for Shark. I just said that is insane logic and extreme over-valuing of the deal. I am okay trading Semien, Beck, Johnson, and others (not all in one package) for Shark. I don't want to trade Anderson and I'm also okay with a package centered around Alexei. I also think we plan on signing him long term and I'm okay with that based upon the dollar figures I've seen thrown around (which is a 5 year deal If I was given the choice of Shark for a little less than 100M or Shields (and the loss of the pick) for the same price (bug we get to keep Semien), I'm taking Shark 100 out of 100 times and I think pretty much every executive in baseball would too. No slight on Semien here. But I think Beane would hang up the phone if that was the Sox best offer.
  24. QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 12:52 PM) Marcus Semien for 1 year of Jeff Samardzija continues to make no sense for the White Sox. It makes us slightly worse next year most likely in the lineup (Sanchez becomes your full time 2b, have to go sign a utility infielder just to back up Gillaspie), which is even worse in a way than Trading Anderson since trading for Samardzija is such an "all in on 2015" move. I am sorry but this post is just an insane overvaluation of Marcus Semien, who I happen to like. If we could get Semiene for a yr of Shark, I would do it every day and twice on Sunday because at the deadline, there is a high likelihood if we were out of contention I could sell him for far better talent than Marcus Semien. Plus, I fully expect the Sox to make a significant run at resigning Shark if we were to trade for him. Trading Tim Anderson with no intention of signing Shark to an extension, would be something I would have an issue with. Anderson has a chance to be a special player, Semien does not. You also can't view this in a vacuum, if you trade Semien for Shark, why do you just assume we go with Carlos Sanchez vs. looking at outside options (either via FA or trade)? PS: I think it is just as likely that Johnson starts at 2B anyway so now we are trading a utility guy for an above average major league starter.
  25. QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Dec 8, 2014 -> 11:37 AM) Paul Sullivan ‏@PWSullivan 2m2 minutes ago San Diego, CA Kenny says Reinsdorf won't allow him to talk with Jays "at this time." He is not considering resigning. You really wonder if some of this comes down to the competitiveness of this occurring during the course of our off-season, with specific plans and tactics lined up. I think if it is still available in late January, it becomes fair game. But right now, we just lose a significant competitive advantage by having Kenny with what he knows leave the organization.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.