Everything posted by southsider2k5
-
Frank Thomas: "I could have won 4 more MVP's"
QUOTE (Big Hurtin @ Nov 22, 2013 -> 09:35 AM) Get ready to hear some national guys say "How do we know for sure he was clean?" Meh, I dont' care what the talking heads say.
-
Royals sign Jason Vargas
QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Nov 22, 2013 -> 08:27 AM) It's not even cherry picking but flat out out lying. Jarrod Saltalamacchia had 30 plate appearances at the major league level 4 years ago. That's complete and utter chickens*** to use that sort of argument. Roy Halladay has a 15.8 WAR over the last 4 years while Chris Sale's is only 11.7. Are you going to take Roy Halladay over Chris Sale or are you going to admit that the argument you used was absolutely stupid and the timeline manipulative and wrong? QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Nov 22, 2013 -> 09:08 AM) I'm not saying his WAR is irrelevant. I actually really don't mind that contract for the Royals. It initially seemed like an overpay, but it's really not a bad deal. It's league average production for about league average rate. He's just a soft tosser who doesn't have a ton of upside which is why people have been overreacting. I think it's a perfectly acceptable, if boring, move for the Royals. I don't even have a problem with you comparing the WAR of a pitcher to the WAR of a hitter. The point of WAR is to try and be able to generally quantify the value of hitters and pitchers so we can value their production properly and compare them to one another. The only problem I have is you comparing Vargas over the last 4 years to Saltalamacchia over the last 4 years. As I said, if you want to make that comparison, my comparison of Halladay to Sale is on the table. Saltalamacchia has only had significant playing time over the last 3 years. Using 30 plate appearances from 4 years ago is absolutely ridiculous. #1) What players did 4 years ago is, for the most part, completely irrelevant to what they do today. Carl Crawford had a 7.4 WAR and Andres Torres had a 6.6 WAR in 2010. Do you want to bring them in and give them big deals? #2) Tying into that, recent production is much more relevant, applicable, and likely to be repeated. As has been pointed out 3 years - Saltalamacchia 7.1, Vargas 4.5 2 years - Saltalamacchia 5.5, Vargas 2.3 1 year - Saltalamacchia 3.6, Vargas 1.5 Don't you think you'd like to give out a contract based on those numbers, or do you still want to give out big deals to Colby Lewis, Tommy Hanson, Roy Oswalt, and Chad Billingsley? DA, it is time to walk away. You have been pretty thoroughly dismantled here.
-
Frank Thomas: "I could have won 4 more MVP's"
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 07:51 PM) There were many reports of voters turned off about it. Frank's biggest obstacle is not his numbers vs. PED guys, he is seen as clean. His biggest problem in whether or not he will be a first ballot guy is how much he DH'd. He doesn't have to campaign to get in. It will happen really soon. I do think Frank will get an extra boost of support from the morality police amongst the writers. They have been quick to punish the PEDs guys, by contrast that means they need to reward the "clean" guys. Frank is the face of the clean players. I think he gets in with around 90% of the vote.
-
Fielder to Texas for Kinsler
QUOTE (RockRaines @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 11:21 PM) I'll go on record for this. I think he's a Maggs type impact player for the Sox. That would be a dream come true, as long as you are talking about on the field, and not how he left.
-
Hahn says trade talks have heated up.
QUOTE (BigHurt3515 @ Nov 22, 2013 -> 01:02 AM) even after Rangers trading Kinsler?? Seems odd that they would trade him but would love to have him I agree. That makes no sense for a team that just traded for Prince Fielder.
-
Hahn says trade talks have heated up.
QUOTE (Leonard Zelig @ Nov 22, 2013 -> 12:06 AM) A St. Louis writer takes a little jab at the Sox (Hahn?) in the last sentence. I wonder what they were asking for Alexei back at the deadline. http://www.stltoday.com/sports/columns/ber...70aead2b04.html Good for Rick Hahn. Unless he absolutely needed to move Alexei, he shouldn't have a low price tag on him. Why should the Sox be in the business of helping the Cardinals?
-
Royals sign Jason Vargas
QUOTE (flavum @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 07:24 PM) How's that John Danks signing looking for us? I mean, can a Sox fan really point fingers coming off 99 losses? The Sox signed John Danks this off season?
-
Frank Thomas: "I could have won 4 more MVP's"
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 05:47 PM) Frank doesn't need to campaign like Ron Santo. He also sounded more than a little jealous of the treatment the team is giving Paulie. Says he doesn't get what the organization is doing. He wouldn't be Frank if he acted otherwise.
-
Ryan Braun
QUOTE (JohnCangelosi @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 04:38 PM) Floyd isn't going to pitch in 2014 more than likely. Also, what nobody has mentioned is the fact that Braun played all of 2012 and had a great year with no positive drug test. How anyone can assume he was juicing all year after the fiasco at the end of 2011 is beyond me. Again, I repeat, he had no failed drug tests in 2012, so how does everyone know he was juicing that year in which he had 41 HR's and raked all year? You know something that hasn't been reported yet? Last I knew, Floyd was already playing catch.
-
Rule 5 decisions coming soon
QUOTE (IowaSoxFan @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 04:04 PM) If they pick up Perez, they would conceivably then need to DFA Flowers opening up another spot. The roster as far as the Rule 5 draft is locked as of 11pm last night. You can make changes, but it doesn't affect your roster numbers as they pertain to the draft.
-
2013-14 off season player movement thread
QUOTE (Soxfest @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 03:36 PM) They will regret this deal. That is the least risky boast ever. This is the Royals. Every move they make, they regret.
-
Rule 5 decisions coming soon
QUOTE (TheFutureIsNear @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 03:37 PM) Something tells me we will end up with 1 of the power arms that throw 95+. Wouldn't hurt to see if a guy can develop on the fly into a hard throwing late inning guy. Not like they can be worse than guys like Axelrod or Leesman We only have one open spot on the 40 man roster.
-
OBAMA/TRUMPCARE MEGATHREAD
QUOTE (Iwritecode @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 03:30 PM) One could argue that college is a luxury. Odds are pretty good you wouldn't be stuck with a 15k job if you had a college degree. Even if you had to work one for a while, it probably wouldn't be a lifetime thing.
-
2013-14 off season player movement thread
QUOTE (fathom @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 03:16 PM) 4 yrs, 32 million for Vargas to the Royals Has Gil Meche written all over it.
-
Rule 5 decisions coming soon
That leaves the Sox room to make a pick. http://chicago.whitesox.mlb.com/news/artic...rticle_64079778
-
The Brandon McCarthy thread
Brandon McCarthy @BMcCarthy32 1h No it wasn't. RT @Ken_Rosenthal Kinsler’s agent: Trade was like “getting smoked on the side of the head”
-
Fictional Affair
QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 02:56 PM) wites fictional affair is with a squirrel That's not fiction.
-
2013-14 off season player movement thread
Ken Rosenthal @Ken_Rosenthal 1h Source: #SFGiants agree with LHP Javier Lopez on three-year, $13M free-agent contract. Just working through guaranteed language.
-
NBA Thread 2013-2014
QUOTE (Jordan4life @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 02:58 PM) So for fun, would you trade Anthony Davis for the first pick in the 2014 draft? if I was getting the #1 pick? Hell yes.
-
Hahn says trade talks have heated up.
QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 02:50 PM) Over 600 plate appearances, it's 21 more times on base. That means you are looking at 21 more times that he has extended an inning, which results in pitchers getting that much more tired and the team scoring more runs. I don't want the Sox to acquire Freese, but he's a much better overall player than Conor Gillaspie. If you had a team doing that, it would mean 1+ additional base runners in each game.
-
AAP: Brandon Brennan
Brandon Brennan @B_Brennan124 48m Cleared to start throwing come December 1st! So happy!
-
2013-14 off season player movement thread
Buster Olney @Buster_ESPN 7m Tampa Bay Rays making progress in effort to retain Jose Molina. Could be a two-year deal.
-
Rule 5 decisions coming soon
QUOTE (dayan024 @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 01:28 PM) Rule 5 draft top players Says Whitesox might draft Astros Catcher Carlos Perez #3 overall Makes a ton of sense honestly.
-
Hahn says trade talks have heated up.
QUOTE (TheFutureIsNear @ Nov 21, 2013 -> 01:16 PM) Rosenthal reporting that the Cards are looking for OF depth in exchange for Freese. DeAza for Freese? Makes a lot of sense to me, but I seem to like Freese a lot ,ore than most here. De Aza doesn't strike me as Cardinals material.
-
2013-14 off season player movement thread
Ken Rosenthal @Ken_Rosenthal 37m Source: #STLCards targeting outfield depth from #Angels in return for Freese. Discussions do not include Aybar or #Cardinals’ top pitchers.