Everything posted by southsider2k5
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 06:33 PM) Hard to say that everything else would be the same though...would he walk less than? Would he hit as many home runs with that approach (when he did hit the ball)... One could certainly make the argument that with more balls in play he would have more production, but I think that probably would come with a significant change in approach that might change everything. I think we have actually seen a change in his approach. It seems like he is swinging harder when he swings this year, and it is reflected through higher K and HR rates.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (Chisoxfn @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 04:07 PM) The real question, and only you can answer this (and it is your opinion) is whether you think that Adam Dunn, from a career perspective, is an A player. I think it depends on where you as an individual fall from a stat perspective. Given that he can't play defense and has flaws (such as a low batting average and high strikeouts), I personally would never rate Adam Dunn (via his career averages) as an A player. I'd rate him a B to B+ player. To be frank, that is the same rating I'd give a Paul Konerko on a career average perspective (or very similar). However, I think some people would potentially argue Dunn (at his averages) is an A player (because of OBP, OPS, and his pure slugging). There is a disparity in how 2 different people view certain stats and give weight to certain stats. I'd put Dunn on the same plateau as Peavy and Konerko in terms of expectations.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (Steve9347 @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 04:00 PM) Yeah, but Adam Dunn has only grounded into one double play this season. ONE. Viciedo is already at 9, tied with Alexei Ramirez. Rios at 7, Slayer at 6, Paulie at 6. Dunn at 1. Strikeouts aren't as awful as you make them out to be, and when Dunn LEADS ALL OF BASEBALL IN WALKS, I'd say that tips the scales and makes up for the k's. Oh, he's also 2nd in HRs. I'd venture that he would have many more hits and homers if his K rate was something closer to his normal rates. And as Reddy would say, walks are factored into OBP and OPS.
-
White Sox releasing $5 upper deck ticket for TOR series
QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 05:07 PM) I am going to the Wednesday night game. Anyone else? PM me and maybe we can meet for a beer I think I am going Wed. PM me.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:44 PM) So you get to remove last season from Dunn's body of work, but keep all of Peavy's seasons in for his body of work...and Peavy's expectations are drastically affected by his injury but Dunn's aren't by his historically bad season last year... That's just inconsistent... I'm not saying I could honestly articulate exact criteria with which to grade, and I am sure some people would disagree with some of my grades... But bottom line...in this era of baseball...you cannot say a guy on pace for 50 home runs and a .375 OBP deserves a C...that just does not make sense on any level. Even if Albert Pujols, who probably has the highest expectations in all of baseball, put up Adam Dunn's current line, I would not give him a C. I did say I adjusted my expectations because of Peavy's injury. He is literally never going to be the pitcher he was in the middle 2000's. Part of what makes his pitching this year so much more impressive is despite those physical limitations, he is still beating some of those numbers. I look at Dunn's 2011 as a horrible aberration, as he is pretty well proving that wrong, and he has no physical reason to have that held against him. If you want to grade him, include them. That is your prerogative.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (Reddy @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:41 PM) so you're telling me, that solely based on a high strikeout total, a guy goes from an A to a C. Regardless of the Runs Created.... Regardless of the WAR... Regardless of the OPS, the RBIs, the Home Runs, the Runs Scored, the highest walk rate of his career. Regardless of all that. 88 strikeouts is worth grading him a C. If you say yes to all this, then we'll leave it at that and speak no more of it. I never said that at all, but OK. Honestly I think OPS is a bit misleading because it gives overweight to slugging stats, and doesn't weight their negative outcomes very well. Looking at Runs scored and RBIs is another double counted stat for a home run hitter. He gets an RBI and a run scored in each homer. Runs scored are also a product of the guys hitting behind you. RBI's are a large part of the guys hitting in front of you. Even at that... OBP-in line with career numbers OPS-barely ahead of career numbers. Balance that with the things you choose to look at, plus his negatives, and then add in the expectations there are for an Adam Dunn, and I arrive at a C. If you want to detail your grading system and do something, have at it.
-
The Pet Thread
QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:18 PM) all cats are identical. I bet I could swap yours out and you wouldn't even notice. Not even close.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (Reddy @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:37 PM) but dude, the whole point is that average is FACTORED IN to OBP and thus OPS. the low average does NOT balance out anything, as it's already in the equation! And 88 strikeouts isn't.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (Reddy @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:33 PM) ok i don't remember exactly, but if you DID use OBP and OPS, you mentioned that the OBP is about his career norm and that his OPS is ABOVE his career norm, which leads him to get a C. Only players EXCEEDING career numbers are allowed higher grades than a C. Is this generally correct? And as I laid out before, OPS is very close to normal. Couple that with the horrible average and historically bad strike out rate, and I would say that balances out the extra .019 OPS.
-
2012 MLB draft talk
QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:29 PM) LOL, OK, yeah, its a "lock". Nevermind that since 2006 the've only done that once with their first pick (Sale in 2010). I love when people call this sort of thing a "lock". Did you buy a lottery ticket today? (Poreda 2007)
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (Reddy @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:25 PM) do you understand that you can use statistics incorrectly? you can read them to mean something they don't? if you don't understand the stats that matter, your opinion also doesn't matter. I used the statistics you laid out. Now you are going to argue that they don't matter? Come on man. And yes opinion matters. Baseball is largely based on opinion. If we weren't talking about opinion, no one would post on this board, well pretty much ever. Even worse would be calling someone stupid, which you did at multiple points in this thread, over opinions.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:11 PM) That is certainly difficult to articulate...and I do not blame you for not being able to do so. I figured as much. I articulated how I decided grades and why. I even gave statistical analysis of how and why. I don't know why you need to take a piece of out everything and turn it into a personal insult, if you are going to, at least be able to come up with what you are asking me to do. At the end of the day is something to talk about on a an off-day. No need to turn it into a reason to insult multiple people.
-
The Pet Thread
QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 02:46 PM) haha I like dogs, they are just too time consuming for the style of life I lead right now. I feel guilty leaving my cats when I go out at night and they have 2 booda domes, 2 water bowls, a water fountain and free rein of an apartment. Bingo. Cats fit the lifestyle.
-
It must be said - Hawk Harrelson has to go
QUOTE (Chisoxfn @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:06 PM) I do not support full instant replay. And in reality, I don't get too worked up on the whole ASG thing. Selig has done some pretty good things in his tenure, one of all, labor peace since 1994. In the playoffs, I can get behind it and support it, but not for the regular season. I had no idea how expensive it would be to implement.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:06 PM) I'd like to think most of it is based on objective facts... So what is your exact grading scale?
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:03 PM) Yeah, and the League factor...my guess is he was negatively affected by some of the PED users then though...so my guess is it balances out fairly closely. I think Jake ends up around 3.5-3.75 era with 190 k's or so and a WHIP in the 1.20 range...which would be outstanding as far as I'm concerned... I would throw a curveball here and say I wouldn't be shocked if Jake were a PED's guy at some point. The loss of velocity plus the odd ball injuries beg the question.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (Chisoxfn @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:00 PM) You also have to take into account the park factor. Peavy has been dynamite this year. And pre-injury he was one of the best pitchers in the game. People forget that. He's finally 2 years removed and we are seeing the benefits of him having a normal off-season. I don't know if he'll keep it up, but the stuff is great and I think (that said, I was one of the few people backing Peavy this off-season) he'll be one of the better pitchers in baseball all year. That said, you never know what could happen. And that is without his ability to his 95-96 on a regular basis anymore.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 02:43 PM) And that's fair...I don't have a problem with giving Jake an A...I guess I don't think a grading scale should be based on your subjective expectations... Dunn is coming off the worst season in modern professional baseball history...yet your expectations were exactly what he is doing now....and therefore he gets a C... But hey, it's your thread. Um, all discussion here is based on subjective expectations.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (Reddy @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 03:00 PM) it's like banging your head against a wall repeatedly with these two. they don't understand value in baseball, so there's no way to convince them otherwise. Its funny because you ran away pretty quick after throwing around some insults only to see those advanced stats blow up in your face.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (Cali @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 02:54 PM) What are Reed's splits between Save Situations and Non-Save situations? Are they drastic or similar? He hasn't been scored upon in a save situation.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 02:35 PM) I didn't mean to put the K/9 in there. The rest are dead on. http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/p/peavyja01.shtml I also don't have the same expectations for him, post shoulder surgery. Dunn has no such limitations.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 02:33 PM) You sure about those numbers? He put up several seasons in SD with higher k/9 than this season. He also had 4 seasons there with an ERA under 2.86.... I didn't mean to put the K/9 in there. The rest are dead on. http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/p/peavyja01.shtml
-
Locking up the young pieces
Sale would be the first one, then Dayan. Reed I wouldn't be too worried about as a closer. Gordo would have to be a pretty attractive discount or plenty of option years for me to sign.
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 02:27 PM) No...it actually makes you an inconsistent grader... Not sure why Jake would get an A but Adam a C...I mean the last few years have really skewed Jake's career totals...He's nowhere near his numbers from 2004... he is also in the top five of the Cy Young race, and has a career best WHIP, is .25 ERA better than even his SD numbers, along with a career bests in K/9, BB/9, and K/BB. Plus a close to career best in HR/9
-
1/3 of the way through the season
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 4, 2012 -> 01:55 PM) I'm just trying to get a feel for your grading scale...I've made the argument that it is almost impossible, minus cherry-picking a player who is producing at an unsustainable rate, to earn an A in your grading scale, if you are an elite player. I think that is a legitimate flaw in your scale. You haven't really addressed that. And in your unknown scale it would be seemingly impossible for bench and low ceiling players to earn anything but a low grade. Then again, I had a decent amount of A's, and two of them were from star players. Makes that argument kind of weak, don't you think?