Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

caulfield12

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by caulfield12

  1. Integral part of the evaluation process when you bring someone on board. Even then, look at all the issues with Madrigal, who was billed as a manager playing the field.
  2. It wouldn't be hard at all with 150-200 healthy at-bats. Alas.
  3. Just need to wait on Moncada and Grandal to turn things around...
  4. Zaidi is one of the Top 3-5 execs in the sport. Full stop. The weakness this year has been injuries and the rotation aside from Webb and Rodon. Losing Gausman really hurt.
  5. At 6'5" 285 and his advancing age What could go possibly wrong? Why the hell is Leury so far down the RF line?
  6. Sosa should simply appreciate the twelve at-bat tryout and stop hunting for hits...pulling low and away to 2B every at bat is far more preferable.
  7. He definitely would have had less outfield territory to cover in GRF...
  8. Can't we say the same about Cueto? Or Narvaez/McCann before they came to the Sox?
  9. Sure would be nice to have Joc Pederson in the Sox lineup... That the players are already having thoughts about it being a "sit and wait year" is quite a telling quote from Liam. At least he didn't speak of blowing things up as that would be even more depressing.
  10. Don’t you mean the Warriors or Bucks in your first sentence? Or just E.C?
  11. Why can’t they be cheap but at least spending their limited money effectively like the Rays, Twins and Guardians??? There’s certainly no Mariners/Angels/Phillies/Rangers award for allocating payroll resources inefficiently. No Sox fan goes to the ballpark feeling grateful for the 7th highest payroll in the majors because everyone in the world can see how poorly it’s distributed. We said it the entire offseason…it’s clear we were going backwards from playoffs 2000 and first half of last season. Nobody predicted Grandal, Moncada and Giolito being this bad…but about 75-80% of what has transpired was easily foreseeable. Nobody thought LaRussa could be this much worse than he already was…but he didn’t have a sinking ship to fix, and that has proved to be a task well out of reach for not only TLR, but all the coaches, trainers and strength & conditioning staff. Certainly our co-GM has been pretty much helpless. But we feel better knowing he is hurting his hand slamming his file drawers over LaRussa in-games decisions. Then stop bring such a pussy and fix the damn roster…do something besides casting blame somewhere else.
  12. So Abreu is better than Arraez this season, Robert is better than Buxton, Moncada and Burger are better than Urshela this season. I’ll have some of what you’re drinking. If you asked every major league GM to choose between Anderson and Correa, this year they’d choose Anderson but it’s not like it would be a slam dunk because Anderson has also missed time, made plenty of errors and has been the opposite of clutch. If it was before the 2022 season started, you wouldn’t have ANY of the Twins starters ranked over Sox pitchers except for the 5th starter’s role. But the Giolito and Lynn of today are not the 2019-20 or even first half 2022 versions or the White Sox would be in first place right now, or at least close to it.
  13. So we should throw out all the ratings because Mark Buehrle turned out to be the best pitcher of that group? Or Josh Fogg and Kip Wells had higher career fWARs instead of the likes of Rauch, Biddle, Barcelo, Stumm, Honel, Wright, Ginter? By your argument, Iowa FB would always be #1 for taking the 2-3 star or walk ons and making them into NFL players. Of course, you would also find a massive correlation between the Top 15 rated recruiting classes and the final results any given season…
  14. Nobody cares about the past. It would be nicer if we didn’t have to live in the present. Would the Twins take Moncada for Urshela in trade? Probably they could fix him, but they just dumped Donaldson to get cheaper. Where did I write anything about Cease’s trade value? Statistically, by many measures, Gray has been just as good or better. Ober is better in the sense his stats and salary are better. If we went by past numbers, why would we even have a reason to play a new season each year? Why would the Twins want Grandal more this year, performance or salary-wise? As for Giolito, you can decide for yourself…he has been declining in performance from 2019 through the present. We have a full thread dedicated to all the reasons why. If the White Sox are so much better than the Twins…more talented…which we’ve been hearing as a consistent argument since about 2001 or so, they have only backed up that boast in 2005, 2008 and 2021. And now here we are yet again, in complete denial.
  15. It counts in the same way every divisional winner or WC has counted from the AL Central since 2017. Wiped out in the first round of the playoffs. We were promised a lot more than early playoff exits when they started this whole rebuild. Were we not? Most fans are not so easily satisfied after a decade of terrible baseball and the third longest playoff drought in the game. Then to have LaRussa foisted on us, it makes it that much worse. We are a weekly laughingstock.
  16. Clevinger, Manaea, Myers, Rogers are all free agents at the end of this year. Myers has a $1 million buyout. Hosmer will have his salary cut from $21 million to $13 million per year the next three seasons and there’s at least a 50/50 likelihood he takes the option to opt out. That could go either way. So $39 million/3 years, possibly. The way he started the furst six weeks, leaving seemed obvious. They have two more arbitration years on Voit as insurance one way or the other, as well as Profar.
  17. I can do the exact same exercise for the Twins and Guardians if you prefer, since I have watched both those teams this year more than the Padres without Tatis. The Padres are simply the White Sox in an alternative reality with KW replacing Preller with his riverboat gambling GM style. Whether it’s Machado, Tatis, Manaea, Mazara…the irony is that the White Sox would be well ahead of the Guardians if you simply reversed the Clevinger trade. Just one trade. I have been right about the Twins all year long, and right about the Guardians rising to challenge them in June with an easy schedule. What I completely misjudged was the Guardians winning five games in their final at-bat in the span of two weeks worth of head to head. Cleveland just has this incredible knack of fighting back, and it’s something you either have or you don’t in your team DNA. So I honestly would still favor the Twins based on talent, with the caveat that Minny’s pen and psyche are shook. Urshela >> Burger and Moncada Correa =< Anderson (TA7 better so far this season, but not necessarily the better player in the clutch or on defense) Polanco >> Harrison/Mendick/Leury Arraez >> Abreu Buxton >> Robert Kepler >> Pollock Other OF’s << Vaughn (obviously Vaughn shouldn’t be in the OF) Jeffers >> Sox catchers Sanchez (DH) >> Sox DH’s I would call that 7-2 Twins, depending on the Correa/Anderson argument. https://www.baseball-reference.com/teams/MIN/2022.shtml Cease=Gray Ryan << Kopech Smeltzer = Cueto Archer >> Giolito Ober/Bundy/Winder/Paddack >> Lynn, Keuchel, VV, Martin, Lambert
  18. That 2000 playoff appearance was built on the backs of beating the heck out of the Tigers and Royals with the unbalanced schedule. Even then, they collapsed under pressure over the last couple of weeks and might have faded completely with another 10-15 games on the schedule against better competition from the AL East and West or simply more games against the Twins and Indians.
  19. 6. Completely botched his evaluation of Rodon…who has risen from a $3 million make good deal to the front tier of the 2022-23 FA class along with Musgrove and deGrom. Worst-case scenario, we have the comp pick and more draft money to spend. Best case, one of the best, deepest, most balanced starting rotations in baseball.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.