caulfield12
Members
-
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Currently
Viewing Topic: White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal
Everything posted by caulfield12
-
AND THAT'S A WHITE SOX WINNER!!
QUOTE (oldsox @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 11:22 AM) Hudson stays alive with big hit. Didn't he do that last week already? 2 more than Alex Rios had all of 2011...joking, sort of.
-
AND THAT'S A WHITE SOX WINNER!!
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 11:21 AM) +1.5 on CLE +6 on DET Despite all the angst over Humber, Floyd and our 2-4 homestand (see Greg), we've lost all of 1 game against CLE and the Cubs actually beat the Tigers, which you wouldn't have predicted, anymore than the Reds' bullpen imploding last night. So things are more or less exactly where they should be... Because I know at the beginning of the year, we all predicted Pablo Escobar Quintana would be gunning down Adam Wainright at Busch Stadium in the middle of June with the White Sox in first place by just half a game!
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
QUOTE (Baron @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 11:17 AM) You would think that. Or it could be quite the opposite. What prospects did you want up? Castro or Molina? Molina's not close to ready. Castro has better stuff, overall, but he's been maddeningly inconsistent. If we're looking for yet another Quintana, it's Pedro Hernandez, but he's currently on the DL.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 11:15 AM) This year we've had two starters worth a crap and Quintana for a few good abbreviated starts. I would expect we could piece together 3 guys that could give us what Floyd/Humber/Danks has produced for us thus far. Right now, the next starter in would clearly be Axelrod. Option 1A would have to be either Stewart or Santiago, but then you're going to get the game to the pen in the 4th or 5th. Option 2 would be Simon Castro, but can you really go to a AA pitcher in the heat of a pennant race? Didn't we already learn that lesson with Jackson for Hudson/Holmberg ONCE already?
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
QUOTE (Marty34 @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 11:08 AM) I think if they got Grienke tomorrow they'd be among the favorites for the AL Championship. Now do that without trading Viciedo, Jones and Mitchell. Our left fielder would be Dan Johnson, Jordan Danks, Lillibridge or Fukudome. We'd have nothing left to deal to fix LF's lack of production. Trading Jones would blow another hole in the bullpen, and remove a future closer from the equation. If you wanted to go crazy, you could stick Dunn in LF with Flowers at DH, but you know how bad that would make our outfield defense? Do you really want to go there...with Hudson at 3B and Dunn in LF? Look at the results of that kind of approach in Detroit this season!!
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
We beat the World Series champs on the road with a Colombian 95% of SoxTalk didn't know about 4 months ago and yet we've spent most of the game thread trading Alexei Ramirez and Dayan Viciedo. If JR hadn't been burned by 2009-2011, there might be some willingness to spend on a Wright or Greinke. For now, they're too hot to the touch. Besides, the Mets aren't doing to lose both Wright and Reyes, their attendance is already falling big-time. They have to keep a homegrown star in the fold. As for Greinke, the price is Viciedo and Reed, bargained down to Viciedo and Jones or Mitchell. Nothing less.
-
AND THAT'S A WHITE SOX WINNER!!
Quintana is the Phil Humber of 2012. Has really saved the team, and especially KW's butt. Whoever recommended picking him up deserves a promotion in the scouting department. Of all the starters in MLB in the middle of June, 2012, his story might be the most surprising of all. This puts a ton of pressure on Humber's next outing.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 10:55 AM) No, I'm well-aware of them. There won't be an left after this year. Any money for the White Sox to spend or superstars to attract to the SouthSide? Remember, with Wright, there are going to be some of the same concerns about transition to the AL that were evidenced by Dunn's 2011 and the beginning of Pujols' 2012 season.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 10:51 AM) Luckily for you, I'm not putting in an application. There are certain players worth the money...is Miguel Cabrera worth the contract? The Tigers were ridiculous to trade cost - controlled talent for him...dombrowski obviously does not know how to run a franchise. Cameron Maybin and Andrew Miller were overvalued and had yet to prove anything at the big league level when they were acquired. We have nobody like that, other than Mitchell, and he's not the centerpiece of a Greinke trade.
-
Something has to be done to improve the rotation
I'm sure he had a conversation with his manager about the team's possible future plans for him and KW advised the staff that he wasn't in the picture for them going forward. Can't blame the kid, he's done everything he could do at the minor league level this year.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 10:47 AM) I'd pay the money for Wright. You're going to give him a $120-140 million contract? That's nice, but you aren't JR. It's always fun to spend the money of others, especially after watching what happened with Peavy, Dunn and Rios the last 2-3 seasons.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
Carlos Marmol against the Tiggers, this should be good.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 10:43 AM) Ok, I shouldn't have said elite. I guess I mean more like all-star. Now this nonsense about him not having trade value is pure horses***. He can't be amazingly talented and yet have marginal trade value, given his paycheck. Maybe the Brewers would trade for JUST him (Viciedo) for 3-4 months of Greinke. If I was them, I hold out for Nathan Jones and Mitchell, too, because 10-12 other teams will be in on Greinke. I just think it would go down with the Hudson/Holmberg moves as a short-sighted one that crippled the franchise, because I have no illusions of Zack signing a long-term deal with the White Sox on the open market.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 10:35 AM) He will be for weeks at a time I think...just not consistently enough to be an elite player. And there's only 10-15 elite players in the game. I'm not going to put him in the Hall of Fame or anything, but he's going to be a very solid contributor who makes 2-3 All-Star games for the White Sox before all is said and done. Nobody acquiring him would give up "elite" prospects anyways, because he's a defensively-limited left fielder. He does have a good arm for the position, but that's more important in RF. Still, when you look at our roster in 2015 and beyond, we have zero power there except for Viciedo, Barnum, Hawkins, Trayce Thompson, etc. He's still worth a lot more to the White Sox going forward than to another franchise. It would take a huge haul for KW to part with him at this point, after all the development investment has started to pay off on him.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 10:32 AM) He was spraying hits in 2010 too. He can't hit a good fastball. This poses a minor problem. I'm not saying he won't be a good hitter, I just don't know that he'll come anywhere close to meeting the expectations of you folks. He has the bat speed, more than even Frank Thomas, it's just pitch selection. He's more comfortable with sliders and offspeed pitches right now. For Big Hurt's entire career, he had a slider speed bat, but it never stopped him from becoming a first ballot Hall of Famer because of his great patience and plate discipline. Obviously, that's Dayan's weakest point, but, once again....he's a 23 year old still learning and adjusting. He has a full four years to go before he would even be considered to be in his prime.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
What's his high in RBI's with the Sox? 65 or so? 70?
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
Contract time, AJ! He's definitely the back-up AL All-Star catcher if there's any justice in the world.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 10:27 AM) What I'm trying to get across is that he's extraordinarily talented at a young age...we all get that...I don't see him developing like most folks do. He's shown virtually no difference in approach since he was here before. In my opinion, I guess I'm saying he's very well might max out a a very young age. When he was hot, he started driving fastballs to right for singles as well as getting a number of groundball singles, and was keeping the pitchers honest. He also was laying off the high fastballs, and his K rate went way down compared to the first 4-5 weeks. Then he was picking his pitches to drive when ahead in counts, mostly sliders and change-ups. Now he has to make another adjustment. But he clearly had a different approach when he was going well there...it was obvious, look at his hit charts.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
What was Beckham doing that time? He hasn't been one of our better baserunners since joining the Sox. Trying to protect the runner from getting thrown out at home?
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
Great recovery by Russell there to limit the damage.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
Cubs giveth and taketh away. Two games in a row with late rallies for the Tiggers' offense. We do NOT want them getting that belief back, but it was probably inevitable. The Cubs just suck.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
Thornton's slider got tagged last time out....just pouring fastball after fastball in there.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
QUOTE (Jake @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 10:00 AM) Q needs to start working deeper into outings if he wants to take the jobs of the big boys His pitch count wasn't high, it's just that Ventura felt he was probably very fortunate to give up 10 hits and only a single run, and putting Jones in there when Greene was 2/2 against him wasn't a bad idea, it worked. In the future, you can trust him more, perhaps...but you can't blame Robin for the quick hook in a game we really need.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
QUOTE (iamshack @ Jun 13, 2012 -> 10:01 AM) For 20 starts? I disagree. 6 weeks ago, everyone would have thought that trade was the steal of the century. Now, not so much.
-
GT: Sox @ da Champs, 06/12, 7:15, the U
Really going to extend the bullpen tonight... C'mon, Crain and Thornton, we need you to come up big.